Mafia Tournament Sleepover! Game Over! SK wins the game! (ITS LEGIT THIS TIME! LOL)

[DtJ Jungle]

lol i'm not bothered by being grouped with bros. I'm bothered that people seem to want to lynch the bros simply because they are calling themselves bros.

 

[Morrigan]

But after that, someone (I don't remember who exactly) brougth up an interesting point. One of them could be an """"""""undercover"""""""" scum using the bro stuff for his advantage, while his other not scum bros say "we're just playing" providing reasonable excuses... the scum bro gets free from suspicion by other players.

 

[DtJ Jungle]

Yeah no i totally get that. However, as scum, they are more likely to slip than the other bros, as they are attempting to hide something. Lynching a someone just because they are labeled a bro si stupid and fruitless.

 

[mentosman8]

Also, Dekuu, the bros thing isn't a "we all listen to eachother no matter what, and won't lynch them!", just a running joke. The bros I'm sure all look into eachother as they do everyone else, and that point is moot and ridiculous.

 

[CT Chia]

Junglescumfever (what name should I refer to you anymore lol) - What's your top scum list atm and why? In exchange, who is cleared in your book if any and why?

 

[DtJ Jungle]

Call me Jungle if it's easier.

Anyway, I'm goignt o be completely honest: This game has gone nowhere. Because of this, my scum list is complete bull****.

My suggested course of action is to make a stronger D3 team. Honestly, I think we should get rid of either Karthik or Nix. Nix isnt scumhunting at all he just wants a tracker/watcher/cop to claim then work from there. Karthik is just being blatently unhelpful and whether he is scum or not the town benefits from losing someone who is useless.

 

[DtJ Jungle]

EBWOP: Meno also in my mind just posts alot of fluff.


unvote vote Karthik

yeah you can die today.

 

[CT Chia]

While I wouldn't disagree per se with lynching someone that isn't being helpful, it wont make it too different from the situation we are in now atm. Think about it, we're practically discussing without them, so if they die tomorrow we're discussing stuff as well... without them lol.

I don't have many leads atm either but I would be more down with lynching KK, as per my post #596

Unvote Vote KK

whos with me

 

[CT Chia]

EBWOP I didn't see jungles post #607 when I made mine, it was a coincidence that we both voted KK and not Nix

 

[Morrigan]

This game is dying

And you're not doing anything to keep it alive.

Vote: karthik_king

 

[KevinM]

How about we all lynch Chibo instead?

If we're lynching off blatantly being unhelpful that is.

 

[Rockin]

With 15 people, it takes 8 to lynch

Chibo (5) - Ronike, Marshy, Meno, KevinM, Frozenflame

Tom (1) - KK

KK (4) - Mcfox, scumfever, Chibo, Dekuu,

Those not voting : Mentosman, FF, Omis, Tom, Bunbun

Deadline is Dec 5, 2009

 

[deepseadiva]

Kevin is amazing.

 

[BunBun]

I just had a death in the family and am at home without real Internet. Please put me as inactive at least til Friday

 

[Rockin]

Kevin is amazing.

new rule updated.

I just had a death in the family and am at home without real Internet. Please put me as inactive at least til Friday

I'm sorry to hear. I will keep that in mind Bunbun. Please keep me updated.

 

[deepseadiva]

It's funny that you say that because with a game this size shouldn't there be a lot of things to discuss?
One would think that more people = more stuff going on = more conversation, right?

Ironic is it?

This kinda bothers me because you generally come here and post here whenever people ask (or demand) you to or when you receive a vote.

This is exactly how I've been playing, yes.

There's nothing to post about, so I've either had to resort to fluff to not be modkilled, or not posting. In my defense though, I have been trying to be more active lately in my own right. Kevin is coincidentally being a ***** following the "lynch all lurkers" thing though, so it's obvious how it would appear that way.

Also, Dekuu, the bros thing isn't a "we all listen to eachother no matter what, and won't lynch them!", just a running joke. The bros I'm sure all look into eachother as they do everyone else, and that point is moot and ridiculous.

Regardless of how silly the bros thing is, I don't believe Gheb's death was total coincidence. If only because scum noticed Gheb's connection to them and is using it to their advantage to cause WIFOM confusion. It's likely that at least one bro is scum, but I'm starting to think it would be even more likely that it's non-bro trying to frame them.

If that's the case, then yes, the point is moot and we should drop it.

More on the Chibo wagon:

Chibo has switched from Tom, to Jungle, to KK very quickly, and earlier Cacti, Ronike, Omis, and KevinM. His reaction to his wagon has been finger-pointing to finger-pointing. As much as I'd enjoy a KK lynch, it's possible we might have hit something with the Chibo wagon. I'll stick to it - unless a chance to hammer KK presents itself.

That might be too tempting to pass up.

 

[McFox]

After reading everything since I left,

Unvote

Vote: Chibo

 

[CT Chia]

Chibo has switched from Tom, to Jungle, to KK very quickly.

I'm still for Tom essentially. I don't like someone in a game being able to be this inactive. I've already stated my case for voting him quite thoroughly. The reason I unvoted and moved on was because the Tom case was literally going no where and for some reason people were just getting suspicious from me wanting to try and keep the game active and players involved wtf

I then mentioned two people I wanted to keep tabs on, Jungle and KK. I voted Jungle and said some of the things I said to kind of spark some interest out of him and get him talking, and to hear a scum list from him which is what I really wanted to hear essentially since he hasn't been quite vocal about his own thoughts yet today.

Then naturally the other person left I currently had suspicion on was KK, and when I saw Jungle thinking the same thing, I decided to go for KK. It was a suspicion I had, a player I want to hear more from, and it has support from other players.

 

[mentosman8]

So, you decided to go with KK when Jungle, who you are suspicious of, went for him? Why would you go to someone in part because of another suspected player being suspicious of them? I could understand if you thought Jungle was town following through when he voted him, but I don't see your logic here.

 

[Steel]

i replaced tom

vote chibo

-1

ill post with my thoughts when i have more time tomorrow

 

[Rockin]

Gah! ****it Steel! I wanted to do a flavor D:

screw it

With 15 people, it takes 8 to lynch

Chibo (7) - Ronike, Marshy, Meno, KevinM, Frozenflame, Mcfox, Steel

Steel (1) - KK

KK (3) - scumfever, Chibo, Dekuu,

Those not voting : Mentosman, Omis, Bunbun, Nix

Deadline is Dec 5, 2009

Steel replaces Tom

Flavor will be slightly delayed cause Steel is too quick >=/

 

[karthik_king]

I'm still for Tom essentially. I don't like someone in a game being able to be this inactive. I've already stated my case for voting him quite thoroughly. The reason I unvoted and moved on was because the Tom case was literally going no where and for some reason people were just getting suspicious from me wanting to try and keep the game active and players involved wtf

I then mentioned two people I wanted to keep tabs on, Jungle and KK. I voted Jungle and said some of the things I said to kind of spark some interest out of him and get him talking, and to hear a scum list from him which is what I really wanted to hear essentially since he hasn't been quite vocal about his own thoughts yet today.

Then naturally the other person left I currently had suspicion on was KK, and when I saw Jungle thinking the same thing, I decided to go for KK. It was a suspicion I had, a player I want to hear more from, and it has support from other players.

You wanna here my scumlist rating thing huh?

Well here it is

1.Meno
2. Chibo
3. Scumfever
4.Iggy/Tom/Steel
5. Marshy
6.Mcfox
7. FrozenFlame(he is still alive :o )
8. Omis
9. KevinM
10. Ronike
11. BunBun
12.Nix
13. Dekuu
14. Me

I would hammer right now but I am nice enough to let you roleclaim, so go for it.

 

[CT Chia]

Before I claim, since it's really a last ditch thing - can someone please explain to me wtf I've done to deserve being at L-1?

And WOW at Steel replacing in for someone who hasn't posted in over a week, and you yourself haven't said a single thing yet you want to just come in and put me at L-1. What a ridiculously anti-town move.

Screw this, the replacement for Tom has proven to not help much either. I'm glad I finally got Jungle and KK to start talking, but I'm going back to my gut instinct of Tom/Steel.

Unvote Vote Steel

Seriously, how are you going to force someone to out themselves when you haven't done a single thing in this game yet, and the person you replaced literally didn't even do a single thing at all this entire day. This alone shows that there is more to be discussed in the game.

 

[karthik_king]

You hammered early is the attack msot people use.

I find your reasoning's for votes scummy because honestly in your position I would have hammered too. It's just your current reasoning for votes that rubs ,me the wrong way on you.

 

[Steel]

nice omgus. i said IN THAT POST i'll give more of my thoughts later.

 

[CT Chia]

You hammered early is the attack msot people use.

I find your reasoning's for votes scummy because honestly in your position I would have hammered too. It's just your current reasoning for votes that rubs ,me the wrong way on you.

There's no f'ing way people can honestly use my hammering on D1 as a reason to kill me today. Do people not realize the situation? I understand that you actually just said now it's not your reason as you would have done the same, but for anyone that is trying to lynch me based on it is just using it as an empty reason trying to find an excuse to take me out. He was at L-1 three times and wouldn't claim any of the times. The game wasn't moving much and things had to get going. What do ppl honestly think could have came out of those last couple days?

nice omgus. i said IN THAT POST i'll give more of my thoughts later.

You don't just pop out of no where and put someone at L-1 ready for mafia to snipe and then explain later. Explain yourself first. How do I know you're not hoping someone will hammer to quickly end the day before anyone finds out anything about your role, since there is 100% nothing to go by on you this day.

---

Everything I've practically done so far is to try and keep the game actively rolling. I got us out of Day 1 with the only reasonable solution (hammering someone at the brink of lynching so many times only for the general consensus of the town to never change (putting him back at L-1 time and time again and not someone else)), and I got on Tom's case today so we can not let someone's role go 100% undiscovered today. The comments of people saying that they just want to hear from Tom was holding up the game, and if we had never heard from him then what would have happened?

 

[Steel]

You don't just pop out of no where and put someone at L-1

Well i just did.

 

[CT Chia]

Steel why don't you explain how what you did is a pro town move?

 

[Steel]

because i think you're scum

 

[CT Chia]

WHY

you or Tom haven't said anything

 

[Steel]

thats what im GETTING AT. maybe if you wait a ****ing day when im not studying for two tests you can stop arguing about NOTHING

 

[deepseadiva]

Um, yea no.

Steel you're not helping by coming in just randomly and doing an "L-1" and telling us you'll explain later. ...lol.

And to be safe, let's not "wait a ****ing day when im not studying for two tests" at L-1:

Unvote Chibo

I'll happily revote once Steel actually explains.

Also Chibo, at this point I'd like some sort of defense from you. Even at one vote away, you're still resorting to "generating discussion"?

 

[CT Chia]

If your in the middle of a lot of studying for two tests you should not be replacing into a big mafia game yet especially when your in other games also atm.

Putting someone at L-1 when we aren't ready to end the day yet is not a good move when the mafia could just jump on me at any moment to end it.

 

[KevinM]

Chibo gettin mad defensive over here.

 

[KevinM]

Fos Meno

Meno is most likely scum.

 

[CT Chia]

What defense do people want to know? I'll explain anything. I've already explained my reasoning behind every single thing I've done recently. I explained my hammer from yesterday time and time again, I explained why I pushed for Tom originally because of activity (preventing more ppl from using waiting for Tom johns to allow themselves to not post and instead coast), I originally went for Jungle to get him to post and here some of his opinions on the game since he hasn't said much of his own thoughts yet this day. After Jungle came out of hiding I switched to KK for essentially the same reasoning, and was being backed by Jungle and the extra pressure got the job done more efficiently. I'm currently voting Steel now going back to my original gut instinct of Tom (I just honestly can't imagine Tom of all people straight up leaving a game for over a week without a single courtesy VLA post, normally Tom is so strict about mafia games) and with what Steel had just done, putting me at L-1 without any explaination until "later."

 

[#HBC | marshy]

can you claim already?

 

[Steel]

If your in the middle of a lot of studying for two tests you should not be replacing into a big mafia game yet especially when your in other games also atm.

Putting someone at L-1 when we aren't ready to end the day yet is not a good move when the mafia could just jump on me at any moment to end it.

it's one day, i won't be studying for two tests the rest of the game. i said i would post tomorrow did i not?

the move is fine. if mafia jump on you out of nowhere then let them. quick lynches don't happen.

meno?

you're unvoting because i didn't explain my vote but will glady revote once i do?

 

[CT Chia]

Tbh it would also help if McFox would also explain his vote.

The only thing that really makes it different is that Steel knowingly put me to L-1 and McFox didn't.

 

[karthik_king]

claim please?