Spirit Guide (Z)
Ami
Jex
Murder
Potassium
Bardull
Gova
Arcane
dabuz
Levi
Werekill
I think the J lynch was really silly. It was pretty bad for me to say yesterday that a levi lynch would likely be a mislynch. We really should have lynched him yesterday. Now we just have another day that is taken from lynching Werekill.
Werekill to me is as good as a cop guilty. His play is really transparent to me.
Levi has said a lot of things that I have liked, and I didn't disagree much with his reads posts as much as Murder did. The main thing that sticks out about levi to me is his read and interaction with Werkill. It feels so forced and reach to me. I can understand people not scum reading Werekill, but if anything he should be null. A town read is really pushing it. And the points that Levi used in his reads post were really stretched. I think Levi/Were are s/s attempting to display a hard town read of each other. When you look at these town reads simply do not look genuine. Almost everyone has seen Levi as suspicious or scummy; but Werekill flat out claimed that he would 100% not vote Levi yesterday. His hard town read of him just came out of no where. Especially when you consider his claim to supposedly only have town/scum
Leans.
dabuz is a tough cookie. He's been really suspicious to me all game, but he is not playing to the scum meta I have on him from FEA. Although now that I think about it, his defending of Jex throughout yesterday reminds me of his white knighting of Ruy in FEA. It's just that I remember dabuz having a really hard time trying to produce content and fake scum hunting that game. If he is scum, he has really improved because he is actually asking questions and making cases here. Dabuz is Ran's strongest scum read though and I trust his read on dabuz more than I do mine. I'd also like to make notice that Ran was the only person who correctly read dabuz as scum in FEA. The rest of the cast defended dabuz from Ran since the moment Ran entered the game.
Arcane is uh null.
Gova is null.
Bardull is null slightly town.
Potassium is slightly town.
Murder, as I said, has been playing incredibly towny/protown.
Jex became transparent town during my read starting from like page 9. I think his thoughts flow naturally and have become pretty easy to follow.
Spirit Guide (R)
Ami
Murder
Bardull
Arcane
Gova
Potassium
Jexs
Were
Levi
Dabuz
Dabuz is simply the scummiest to me because of his lack of pro-town intent, and lack of drive to find scum. His presence is lacking, and he tries to emulate his town play. In his
#343, he makes a big post. Most likely to seem pro-town, big wall, but afterwards his play is lacking in between. Zen feels off about the meta not lining up exactly with FEA because there, Dabuz didn't even try. He didn't need to, he was skating along while not even interacting with me (his scumread down the line), yet no one batted an eye. Here he makes an effort to emulate his town play, but his scum still shows. In his
#481, he votes Levi with a lack of substance. He's simply re-iterating what was already said in thread, along with lulzy omgus. Finally, he isn't reading the thread carefully enough. His questions are few and far in between. In his
#1184, he uses the same wording as in his #481. "So I get the feeling that..." I dislike that he brings that point up in 1184, as if he's trying to say something he isn't actually able to make into a stance. It shows he is having trouble faking stances here or faking concern.
Levi is also one who I feel is trying to emulate his town play. In the mini I had no problems with him, and agreed with his direction. Here he seems to have good reaons, but he vibes off. For example, his backing down of his push on Protein was out of character for him. I would expect him to continue to push him if he genuinely felt he was scum. To me, him switching out was to salvage his play as he was under some heavy attack, especially from Murder, who he was simply appealing to, if I can call it that. Again, his switch to Dabuz was unimpressive. The words still ring in my ear "Well, there's still Dabuz." What kind of drive to find scum and convince the rest of the town is that? This is why I feel they are both scum together, he sits on Dabuz while he may lose his life in the game.
Secondly, on his role. I don't see any reason to let him live after today. First, he connects himself to vague roles, and outs that he feels he may have been roleblocked. He doesn't have confirmation that he was roleblocked, simply that his role failed. I am not willing to wait on role information from others when his is vague itself, and he is suspicious. I can understand Pott saying we are concerning for saying that other roles stepping up to insure that he is legit would be the only thing that holds me back, but I do not want that. Remember that him claiming that vague role would have to force others to claim. So the one who is concerning is Levi himself for forcing that situation. I want his lynch.
Finally, on the night kill speculation. If Levi were scum, it would benefit him to kill off Protean, as out of the cluster of Murder/Protean/Ami/Levi, murdering murder could bring attention to Levi, in time. Nk'ing protean could make some equally doubt Levi/Murder, since both seem to be of the same skill level. @
Protean- I'm wondering if this seems legit to you? If so, vote Levi. You scumread him, and I still believe he is scum. Don't lose your way. If you still feel Murder is scum for some other reason (related to the nk), then vote him again.
Werekill. I have him as slight scum because Zen convinced me of it first. I thought it was that he was simply not able to find scum because nothing caught his attention. It took me a while to develop reads as well. I wasn't feeling Protein- at the time. Zen told me that while he first Voted Werekill, that he was not calling Zen out on dumb things while he was doing so at the same time in Monster Mafia. This also shows with how he reacted to our RVS, he simply said "I'm glad you stepped off Jex, I felt it was weird" but he never actually questioned us before we unvoted. Regardless, I agree with Zen's assessment above. Re-reading, Werekill never felt the argument against Levi. He said he felt he was town because he was leading things and would hold things to his chest in his
#373 and his
#646. As you can see, this post
#380 shows that he isn't actually trying to figure out Levi's alignment, saying that he digs his attitude and simply agrees with his protein direction, and states that his reaction might change his opinion while it never really does nor does he make an effort to attain it. I found something odd just now, actually. In his
#834, he comes to a conclusion of Dabuz's most recent post. It felt pre-mature, as he only just posted it at 5:48, while he posted the conclusion at 6:09.
Jex is now null. ToDay I have seen a little bit more effort and more 'why' from him. I felt I did ask him alot of questions, but it was me trying to figure out his alignment with what little I got at the time.
Pot is null.
Gova is nulll.
Arcane is null.
Bardull is slight town. I liked that he was seeing the same thing as me with Jex. I would like to see more of Bardull today though.
Murder is town to me. I was confused quite a bit, but the only thing that tripped me up was his re-evaluation on Protean, which turned out correct. I can understand why he may have prioritized others over Jex now, and agree that part of this is because he was the most vocal.
Combined Spirit Guide
Town: Ami, Muder
Town Lean: Bardull, Jex
Null: Potassium, Gova, Arcane
Scum: Were, Dabuz, Levi
Leviathan is the read we both agree on. Zen is willing to support Ran on dabuz and Ran is willing to support Zen on Were. We would like to continue working with Murder as well so right now it's looking like we need to hardbody Levi the **** outta here.
Vote: #HBC | Leviathan