Lost Mafia - Who won? - The viewing audience of course

[Asdioh]

Wow already?

 

[KevinM]

Sup Asdioh, I'm town for once in a game wanna win it with me?

 

[Tandora]

With 17 alive, it takes 9 to lynch!

Vote Count:
RR: (1) Mentosman
Dooms: (1) Soupamario
Glyph: (1) Rajam
Mentosman: (5) Red Ryu, Kataefi, Glyph, Evil Eye, Ryker
Circus/J: (2) Chaco, KevinM
Gorf: (1) Aushper
Auspher: (1) Joey
Soupamario: (1) Gheb
Rajam: (1) J

Not voting: (3) frozenflame751, Gorf, Asdioh


Deadline December 26th, 11:59 PM.

33 hours to deadline.

 

[Swiss]

Really been falling behind in my modding duties.

-------------

With 17 alive, it takes 9 to lynch!

Vote Count:
RR: (1) Mentosman
Dooms: (1) Soupamario
Glyph: (1) Rajam
Mentosman: (5) Red Ryu, Kataefi, Glyph, Evil Eye, Ryker
Circus/J: (2) Chaco, KevinM
Gorf: (1) Aushper
Auspher: (1) Joey
Soupamario: (1) Gheb
Rajam: (1) J

Not voting: (3) frozenflame751, Gorf, Asdioh


Deadline December 26th, 11:59 PM.


--------

There ya go guys.

Thanks for flying Oceanic!

 

[Dooms]

Good job Swiss.

 

[Rajam]

Back from chrismas and prod-dodging. I'll be reading and then posting content at night.

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

same when my christmas is fully done.

 

[Asdioh]

Anyone else have ridiculously slow internet speeds around Christmastime?

/johns

 

[#HBC | Gorf]

Hey I don't have a vote. Vote: Kat

 

[mentosman8]

Still not a lot to comment on really, but meh. Good to see some people have brains in this game and realize how horrible the push on me is.

Mentos, that's a really terrible fixation on what you believe to be the main push against you. That's not it at all nor is it why I think you have such a wagon against you over a trivial matter as "they don't like your playstyle". I also have to say Kat's post against you is a "case"...sort of.

I don't like the way you are dealing with your wagon formed on you. It is giving me different vibes to the way you acted when the gambit happened.

@Mod: My vote is on Rajam but just to help.

Unvote
Vote: Rajam

Most of Kat's "case" on me is exactly what I was referencing in the post this responds to. Not being overly aggressive? That's Mentos alright. Airy? Yep that's normal. Paying more attention to some players than others? Yeppers. He talks about my reads being on the same general reasoning when they aren't(just to point it out)

Acro: We had a little back and forth early in the day and I really didn't like the responses I was getting. He then disappeared and I was unable to grill him further so there wasn't much else than continuing to state that I thought his responses were bad

Soup: Similarly from early in the game, a couple things he had done which I felt were odd, and though he seemed to pick it up I've stuck with mentioning it because *something* has bugged me about him since then.

Auspher: Main problem with him has been the fact that he has been asked several times to open up and give us something to work with in ways that weren't very pressing and still refused, wasn't the content of the posts was the fact that with town repeatedly *asking* him to offer something he still didn't put effort in.

Ryu: Was on the edge earlier in the day while debating if I agreed with the case Gheb brought up, then he started to irk me more, especially once he began his attack on me out of nowhere vastly exaggerating my actions to do so(which you yourself mention feeling he has done)

Glyph: Had slipped under my radar, but what made me eventually start to question him? None of the things Kata posted as the general cause for my reads, instead the fact that he was twisting my actions after the daykill gambit. The only reason I didn't push him as hard right away was because I felt there wouldn't be time to got something through on him.

So we've got part A, the way I play making him think I'm scum. Part B, him stating my scumreads and vastly oversimplifying them and not picking out the underlying reason. Part C talks about me going easier on Glyph, what did he want from me in that post he says I does so, somehow force Glyph to read the game? There's a different way you handle someone that has actually read the game and someone who there's no hope to get to do so, I'm not going to waste my time pushing for reads from a player who is literally unable to give them.

So yeah, what part of that "case" holds up except the part that is literally pointing out things I always do regardless of alignment and saying he doesn't like them? Other than that the only arguments against me are Ryu who is playing the over exaggeration game, then a few people saying that I don't "feel" right and pushing my lynch over it(and no I'm not a hypocrite because that's how I feel with Soup, I'm not about to push his lynch over gut, just state my suspicion)

Anyway, I'll be here for a few more hours then on in the afternoon tomorrow, hopefully town sees some sense and lynches someone that actually makes sense. I remain down for RR/Glyph/Auspher lynches.

 

[mentosman8]

The only reason I didn't push him as hard right away was because I felt there wouldn't be time to got something through on him.

Dat tense fail, I miss quickedits : C

 

[Tandora]

About 19 hours remain for D1.

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

I would be able to post til close to the deadline due to work and some other things.

Mentos you should at least claim right now.

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

Would should be won't*

 

[Asdioh]

Still haven't read.
I have a feeling this is going to be painful.

 

[KevinM]

I would be able to post til close to the deadline due to work and some other things.

Mentos you should at least claim right now.

Oh my god...

I just wish there were dumb things that weren't said so my head didn't hurt...

If it wasn't so close to deadline I'd be pushing for you to die.

 

[KevinM]

Actually nope not gonna let that slide..

He's L-4 and he's not the lynch candidate we're taking today.

Vote Red Ryu

He should NOT claim at L-4 when a number of people aren't seeing a case on him, your votes feel hasty and piled on and you calling for him to reveal his role so early looks like a cute little ploy to try and get info while most people are v/la.

 

[Dooms]

I'm fine with Ryu lynch.

Vote: Red Ryu

 

[Dooms]

Actually, I don't like the reason why you're voting him, but I don't like RR either, so I'll still go along with it. I wouldn't have minded Mentos claiming if we didn't start putting votes on RR, because of the fact that the activity for the past few days (due to Christmas obv) has been total ****. I don't think RR is scummy for saying that specifically, either.

 

[~ Gheb ~]

Unvote Vote Red Ryu

Yeah, I'm still OK with this. Mentos wagon looks really weak and the people on it don't make me change my mind at all. None of them are really credible other than EE who's gotten a bit more quiet recently. Not that I'm sure why people think mentos is scummy to begin with ...

 

[Chaco]

Sorry for inactivity, family bombarded the house and getting to a computer, witj mine dead, has been a challenge. Anyways, As of tomorrow, I WILL be V/LA until after New Years.

I don't support the Mentos push whatsoever. I feel he is town, stemming from his responses to me previously.

I really havent read much into RR because he always comes off scummy to me, but if someone would lay out other reasons besides what is inherently scummy, I might join on.

I still dislike Circus's slot from the previous play, but I'll have to read more into J toMorrow.

I don't see Rajam being a lynch target today so I'll save that as well.


Anyways, Unvote.

 

[Radical Fiction]

Oh my god...

I just wish there were dumb things that weren't said so my head didn't hurt...

If it wasn't so close to deadline I'd be pushing for you to die.

Less than 24 hours in the phase and you want to get on RR for asking the largest wagon to claim? He's completely justified in doing so.

 

[#HBC | Ryker]

Derp ^^^^^^^^^^^^^

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

Wow, those jumped votes are jumped votes are scummy as hell.

it's less than 11 hours to the deadline, and mentos had the most votes and momentum.

Asking for a claim is completely justifed at this point.

FoS: KevinM

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

I also put a case on him for why I want him lynched, which he didn't answer my rebuttal yet.

 

[mentosman8]

Because your "case" was based entirely on exaggerations of my actions and ignoring most of the points made in my original rebuttal. I'm not going to waste my time arguing in circles when there are people I can respond to(a la Kat) who might actually take notice instead of saying the same thing again.

 

[Dooms]

Yeah Ryu, your case was pretty bad. Your play with Auspher was bad as well. That's all I remember at the moment, but it's more than enough to make me want to lynch you over Mentos, who I think is town.

 

[mentosman8]

But hey, for the hell of it let's jump on the merry-go-****ing-round. I'll make this easier by numbering points in your post and renumbering them below.

1. You may have reiterated some lynch picks, but you remained rather reluctant to give information to town.

2. And no, no you didn't reread your first post, you gave reasonable doubt it was fake, even more so to the fact it was real. You doubted the shot more so than you believed it. That is null but the fact to that you did nothing to either side, proving it was fake or real in either situation.

3. You picked safe scum picks when you were gonna die, no way. If your gonna die I would be legit honest safe of not with scum picks. Even if I thought someone a lot of people thought was town was scum I would say it. There is no reason to place such safety on us when you could speak your mind on what you truely think is scum over what you win you town points if it was safe.

Which btw, you knew based on your responses to Glyph.




4. Are you kidding me? You never showed intent to give Ryker any info until it showed he was being serious. You never cared to give info until it looked like it would cave in on you. Face it , you never cared to.

5. You have been flip flopping with what you choose to give. You only give what makes you look good, not what makes town win. That is a scum tell.

6. Yet from a stand point that was nothing more that just a bandwagon to hope on. I'm fine with his lynch. Good for you you to say that when you again perform nothing ti support it.





7. You refused to give **** until pushed. That bothers me a lot. You never even with the gambit EE pulled tried to push any kind of scum push. Good you wanna push it back at me, too bad it's an OMGUS when town is no where near the null you say they are.



8. Forget Soup for a second, tell me anything you said about the playlist as a whole, ignore in actives, just frigging tell us. Your very resultant to tell town **** about what you think and feel compared to anyone else.

9. Glyph hasn;t done ****, I agree, you still seem to , why active, do nothing to assist town much like Glyph has. On the flip side though, you were placed in a gambit. In the gambit you tried to play off EE as fake, despite you lying about you thinking it was real.
Even if you did, you tried nothing, no read immediately, no direction for town to go, no nothing to let town know where to look.

You left us in the dark.

1. (facepalm) see, merry go round, same point I've already responded to yet you ignore that and say it in a borderline contradictory way. "Yeah you gave us your lynch picks but you were being reluctant to give information!" What other information is there for a dying player to give? Should I have told you my thoughts on flavor? Oh wait, maybe I should have gone into thorough detail on everyone in the game, including those I didn't have reads on and risked getting killed before I could post just to make sure that I didn't come off as not giving info. Yeah, that makes sense.

2. ... Are you serious? You can't be serious right now. As I've said before, the first post I really did go "no way, there is no way that is real right now." Then, once again as I've said, as time passed I thought more and moreso that it was real. You're qualified to judge my thoughts based on the first post I made immediately after reading it before I actually thought about the odds of EE gambiting?(Which, seeing as I have *never* seen him gambit was incredibly low)

3. Sweet troll Jegus it keeps getting worse. My scumpicks were safe? THEY'RE THE PEOPLE I WOULD WANT TO LYNCH! You can't hold it against me that my best scumreads in the game halfway through D1 are ones you consider safe. Did you ever consider that I *was* being honest with my scumpicks? Oh wait, you want to get me lynched so you decided to ignore that possibility because it hurts your case. Got it.

4. Did I ever say I intended to give Ryker information before he got serious? Because I don't see it there. What I *did* say, was that if literally a SINGLE other person in town felt the questions I was refusing to answer would be helpful and said "hey mentos, could you answers those questions of Ryker's? I'd like to hear your thoughts on them" or something along those lines I would have responded with the answers. Ryker beat people to asking that by providing comments and then I provided the answers directly to him. Quite simple.

5. First of all, you've played with/seen me play before right? This is actually the most open I've been in a game in ages. So if you don't like the way I play big whoop.

6. Yep, I tend to not restate cases that have already been said when I say I'd be fine with a lynch. Cool.

7. Once again welcome to my playstyle. Oh, and it's OMGUS huh? The fact that I suspected you before this attack on me(granted I have gotten much more suspicion since then, your cases have been ridiculous) kinda damages saying that.

8. Ohai more playstyle critiques, whassup. I'm always more closed off and I absolutely *hate* the idea of townlists(I'm pretty unhappy that I indirectly gave on in this game). It's pointless to say what you feel about every single player in the game. I gave my scumpicks at first, and then gave my town reads that I wasn't fully confident of(generally more hesitant to give out town reads) late when I felt resigned just as something else to toss out.

9. More assumptions about my thought process, more ignoring my pointing out that after the first post I made following where I was incredulous I started believing it more and more and in my *second* post(first when I thought it was real) I immediately put back out who I'd be willing to lynch. If scumpicks and saying "hey if this kill is real look at the guy who did it cuz it's scummy" and "hey this guy is twisting my actions" don't count directions for town to go, what do you want from me?

There ya go, I've responded to your case *again* since there is almost nothing changed between this and the post I had already responded to. I'm quite happy with my vote where it is.

 

[#HBC | J]

Since a little less than 8 hours are left in the day it seems to be dwindling down between RR or Mentos and I am definetely leaning as to having RR die over Mentos based on what I have stated previously with my distaste for him being greater than anything I feel for Mentos at the current time.

Unvote
Vote: Red Ryu

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

J your case for me being scummy is meta off one time i played as scum, in majoras and megaman X, there is no difference off ****ty meta.

Joey, what about auspher was bad, I know probs better than anyone else except maybe Gheb.

He will not get active and post unless you pressure him. He is extremely shy and will not put himself in the spot light. He does this in real life and offline. I've known him for almost a year, he does this in mafia as well. If your going to lynch me for trying to hold my newbie friends hand, then I really have no rebuttal other than your dumb.

I'm a VT, claiming from work so idk the name, it's some guy with drug problems i think he plays a guitar or music something. He is nice and trying to be better than when he had drug problems before landing on the island.

I don't know the flavor so idk who he is or what he does in the show.

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

Still do not like mentos btw.

oh and KevinM is scum.

 

[Dooms]

It was when you called him town when his play was absolutely ****ing garbage, and you stopped pressuring him at the same time.

 

[#HBC | J]

J your case for me being scummy is meta off one time i played as scum, in majoras and megaman X, there is no difference off ****ty meta.

There are quite a few things wrong in this haha. ^^"

1.) Never did I make a case on you, just a little blurb on a vibe I had.
2.) One time = two games in this sentence.
3.) I didn't even bring up Majora's *which you weren't even scum in, I was* and Megaman X which I wasn't even in. I brought up Higurashi Mafia.

 

[Asdioh]

deadline in 4.5 hours, i have no idea who's scum, i won't care until D2, assuming I survive.

I will vote someone, but I obviously can't hammer.
What do?

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

joey I've been in every ****ing game he's played on this site in some shape or form and know him personally. Did you see him in higurashi, Housepets, moderagtor mafia? i did, it matches his omgus behavior and why he is pissed. He is extremely defensive, looking at his posts in brawl compeditive and the wolf boards is he off oppsing parties like chu33 and such.

Is he playing terribly? yes, is he scum? No, look at his intent and how he reacted, it screams town. Plus where has he been recently? Not posting or the little he has He never responded to me.

J your an idiot, higurashi was exactly how i posted in megaman X and Majora's.

You saw me posting like this against Dastrn on D1, I ****ing know you did in majora's. Your referencing Higurashi as meta for why I am scum. There is not legitimate second game, nor you blantantly lying about my meta.

Gheb has way more of a reason to reference it and intepret it, he knows my scum play better and my town play. You don't, so stop pretending you do.

 

[Rajam]

unvote

FoS: KevinM

Haven't been able to read the last 2~3 pages... headaches johns. Just saw RR's claim petition on mentos, and kevM attacking that... why? With around ~12 hours left I don't find that petition scummy... just something pretty normal on a wagon with real chances of transforming inTO a lynch (it was either that or no lynch)

 

[Rajam]

vote: KevinM

 

[Rajam]

And #702:

The thing Glyph is quoting there is something I found very scummy. If we sum to that that Gorf has been all D1 tunneling Auspher, then we can realize Gorf is scum. Isn't that so KevM?

 

[mentosman8]

Rajam, there are about 4 hours till deadline, two players at L-4, and you vote someone who doesn't have a single vote? I can understand commenting on him but it's a bit tight of a time to be going after someone who isn't even remotely a lynch option...

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

deadline in 4.5 hours, i have no idea who's scum, i won't care until D2, assuming I survive.

I will vote someone, but I obviously can't hammer.
What do?

Vote Mentos.