This is just a generalization, you cannot automatically lump all scumslips into one group and bad town play into another. Yes, there are similarities, but saying they're all the same is taking it a bit too far.
Actually, a noobtown read is generally rather easy.
It was a bit difficult when I had your posts shoved down my throat right off the bat. I posted all of my thoughts upon entering the game, but no one seemed to take notice.
The fact that you drew limited commentary shows that you didn't produce enough content. It wasn't like people started agreeing with my case immediately, you had an opportunity to open up your own cases and counter-balance the read. But you were too passive, and like summoner, THAT'S ultimately the mistake that reveals you as scum.
You said that you feel that Summoner's post regarding OS potentially busing Chaco to be especially scummy. I think we both know that the suspicion itself is really nothing out of the ordinary; he simply stated his thoughts on what was going on in the game. You also stated that his lack of evidence behind this claim was one of if not the main reason that you found it scummy. But is it not unlike noobtown to leave out evidence or provide inadequate evidence to back up claims? Whether it is because of the lack of evidence to back up the claim (meaning an empty claim such as this) or evidence that isn't as concrete as one would hope, noobtown suspicions are often not backed up as well as they could be, which is shown in Summoner's play.
I'm going to sleep soon so I can go into the rest of what you found suspicious about him tomorrow.
Except that even passing it off as merely being suspicious is shaky at best, Summoner's phrasing was not anything along the lines of "this seems like a bus attempt".
If he had said something along the lines of "I think this might be a bus attempt", ok, I could see that.
But his phrasing was "back off OS, if you actually catch scum, everyone will think it's a bus".
I'm sorry, that's a clear attempt to manipulate town, and manipulation attempts that are too obvious are a noob-scum mistake, not a noob-town mistake.
I'll let my play determine that.
You have, it hasn't helped.
@Everyone: Deadline is less then 24 hours away, let's seal the deal with a lynch here.
yo, i should really get lynched. I haven't done anything all day. **** is not acceptable.
but catching up now, been puttin this off for way too long
Lynching obvios scum>lynching inactives/useless people.
