My bad, you're right.
That being said, doesn't Sonic just kill himself when doing that if you grab the edge?
Also, I know it's stupid, but TOs really can't enforce it much, since players tend to argue it's too subjective, even when it's an obvious case, and that it's no different then platform camping (which is somewhat true in that that is also used to stall.)
I'm not so sure about that. I mean, yeah, he plays stoned a lot, but he doesn't seem to have problems when sober. He seems to sometimes have trouble when stoned, and sometimes not though.
Also, IsmaR, it's not that I want him S tier, it's that I think he warrants it. I personally hate Marth, both as a smash character and a FE character.