Reading threads like these always makes me feel better about my skill as a smasher. During school i'd be down about being behind the numerous top smashers in the MD/VA area. THen I'd go to a school club tournament and get lots of OMGWTFBBQ and an easy $50.
I don't have a problem with n00bs complaining. Sux for them. It'd be great if they take an interest and learn how to play, but that's a bit problematic. Lets say they see someone wavedashing and they don't immediately go GLITCH, or even if they do they still want to learn about it. How do they learn about it? All they know is thye every now and then see someone who can slide on the ground. How they search for how to do that? Unless there's a way to communicate between players, n00bs won't know about smashboards or sites where they can learn about this stuff. THey may get it by going to gamefaqs and posting and finding out, but maybe they're just the average casual gamer who searches "cheats" in google for fun and doesn't know jack about any gamer community.
My main worry is DCers. THere will always be DCer in an online game, but in a game like smash where nubs see "glitch hackers" DCing will be a major problem. I have MKDS and MP:H on the DS, and it's rare that you'll get through a game without at least one person dropping out. In MKDS, alot of the time I have to intentionally play badly and just barely win, or let others win a couple games just to keep them on for the duration of the match and get my points. The Connection Percentage in MPH doesn't work b/c when you get paired up with someone, you don't see that they have a 50% and this match will most likely be a waste of time. It subtracted from your ranking points, but nubs didn't care. Course, there are a TON of exploitable glitches MPH, which I generally quit out of if for instance they pick the rock gu(haven't played in a long time) and glitch themselves into the rocks. THat's just bull****, and it's banned from tourneys. In MKDS, you got aloss, but you could get several wins per match (based on how many people you played against), so it wasn't intimidating. I hope there's a ranking system. THey should make it so after shutting the power off to the system, you can't go online for a random match for 24 hours and keep the one loss penalty. That way if the n00b just loses, he only gets a loss. But if he DCs to save time and take away your win, he can't play for the rest of the day. If there's no ranking system, you shoudl stll have the 24 hours punishment,, but then the way around that is that they'll just suicide after you've killed them once and they've seen how good you are. Which would be like waiting for a connection and the match to start just o play one fast stock. and given nintendo's wifi service, you'd be waiting around like 4 times as much as playing.
The solution, as some of you said, is friend codes and only play people you know.
But If you just keep playing the same people, you won't see more than those people's playstyles and characters. Then when you go to a tourney and see someone new, you may not have the ability to adapt to them.
and I like playing against new people. I like the rivals system in MPH, b/c it meant i could find new people who are good and meet them again later. It's boring to always play against the same people.
You guys don't want a ranking system, but without it random matches will hardly ever get you against a good smasher.