I would be interested.
I don't know why you quoted me as someone who doesn't play melee, I'm 100% sure I would whoop you pretty hard, as I play melee like 1-5 times a week depending on people hosting/w33d having.
Brawl singles IMO, is better than melee singles so long as you aren't getting CG'd. For people talking about how gay brawl is, melee singles is just as gay and has more gay things (CC, ledge shield gimps) and you can play just as campy in brawl as in melee, and you get punished harder.
Melee doubles IMO, is better than brawl doubles. I don't have an example for this, though, this one is just personal taste.
FPS's are bad, it's not just Halo.
New fighters are bad. Like current gen sports games, the companies haven't figured out how to make the games look/feel competent. Last good SF was 3S. I'd argue Tekken 5 to be the last good fighting game, and that was PS2.
I don't play RTS so I don't have an opinion.