1. Fair knocks your enemy back, if they shield it. They are unable to respond if you cancel it into a Down tilt. I've done it before. If you knock them back far enough with Fair, your Dtilt should land right under their shield, or at least damage it. Sure, Ftilt in most cases is better, but I'm thinking of different options, not the norm. Saying this is a completely idiotic way to play is just telling me that you've never really tried it yourself. =/
2. Agreed. Although when glide tossing, usually I double slap, or just grab them. However when prediction catches on, I notice that after a few successful glide tosses, pressure kicks in and they roll away, assuming I'm going to land something. It's then, when I would Foward B. It's a great move, works wonders. Especially if you Jam back and then forward B, you do a little dashdance before you do it. Hehe.
3. I still think that Turnip Canceling is moar techy. But I've actually never seen a successful footstool- Fair. That's interesting.
I personally think the key to winning anything, is Toad. <3 I don't use him, but I really should.
It brings R.O.B's and GaW's to their knees, and mentally mind F*cks them up. So I'd just say, incorporate moar toad.
1. You just proved my point, it knocks the enemy back and if you didn't know, F-Tilts hitbox does a huge scoop, so big that if your standing on a platform of BF, the enemy directly below you will get it. F-Tilt has more range than d-tilt, is faster, and still hits the same spot that D-Tilt does. This is why I said D-Tilt is a good mix up. Mix ups are meant to keep you unpredictable. I never said it was idiotic, you're just throwing words in my mouth.
2. Again, this is why I said it was a good mix up. Though, what if they roll behind you? You're caught in the most obnoxious landing lag ever which, against many characters will lead to your death. Also, a competent opponent should be able to deal with pressure without retreating. I'm positive a number of characters can buffer grab the instant a turnip hits their shield before you can grab them.
3. Turnip cancelling only consists of three actions.
Dashing towards the edge(Forward A)
Pulling a turnip (Down B)
Dashing again (Forward A)
Footstool Fair is a lot more complicated.
You have to
Footstool (X)
Float (Down + X)
Retreat (Continue holding X + Back)
Fair (Forward A/C Stick Forward)
All before the footstool lag comes to and end. Just throwing this out there for those who don't know how to do either.
It kind of seems like you think I'm picking apart your post because of the silly PR list. I'm just justifying why I think your advice is a little bit unsafe and posted a couple of alternatives to help out. After all, the more advice the better.