FFS I wanted Gotenks to make it clear who he wanted to lynch.
I've been waiting on a responce from PM to decide where I want my vote.
I think Gotenks would probably be the best choice and Licky would love if you joined us with this. vote: Gotenks
Licky doesn't think Moriarty should be the play. Licky would be fine with Spag or Regal or PM, but would like Gotenks the most. But not Moriarty because Licky thinks there is a high chance of lynching scum based on scumminess today. So please join us FFS.
Also FFS what do you think of Chuckie??
Ok, time for me to be a bit more old-school and make some big responses in a quote wall and all that good stuff. Lot's to comment on.
First of all, you say you wanted us to be clear on who we wanted to lynch? I've been out for Moriarty as one of the first two to go after him, for slightly different reasons than FZ was at him for, and he has been my focus(and therefore that of the hydra, as BSL agrees), so I'm pretty sure it's clear who we want to lynch.
You say you've been waiting on PM's response before voting, then in the next line vote us? What changed your mind so suddenly?
You say there's a high chance of lynching based on scumminess, then go on to list a third of the game. It's not exactly a high chance when there's no one standing out largely enough to where you're comfortable with a good chunk of the game dying.
You've been wishy-washy all game. No direct scumhunting. And even though you have given your thoughts on a few people, you haven't given much. And you're taking the easy wagon.
First of all, I had probably the earliest hard stance saying at the end of the RVS that I would be more than happy to lynch Moriarty if he didn't step it up. That has held up the whole game. Not wishy-washy there. What do you mean by "direct scumhunting"? How do you interpret that scumhunting is not what is occurring as I read the game? Do I have to post every little thought I have to be scumhunting? Or am I missing your meaning?
just went back and looked through your posts. this vote seems kind of unwarranted.
you have only mentioned Gotenks twice before just now. first one, you said we were kind of suspicious and that we mentioned the RVS thing, second one you just said
i couldnt really figure out exactly what you were answering here. if the part concerning Gotenks was also responding to xsword.
and then just now you came out with wishy-washy.
both me and mentos havent really said too much. right. we cant really find the time to communicate as much as we should be able to, and i dont really like posting without talking to him first.
bsl pulls the noobcard
i really really dont want to do it, but i mean, i guess i kind of have to, so that i can explain. this is only my second game. first game, i came in as a replacement (town), and was NK'd night 1.
i want to talk to mentos and get a real explanation as to why we havent done any scumhunting, lol.
so i guess maybe, since we havent done any scumhunting, we might look scummy?
but why would you choose to vote us over moriarty, who hasn't even made a real post? at least we have taken stances, and have been sort of useful.
moriarty has been asked before to post real posts, and hasnt.
i contacted mentos when xsword asked us to post more views, and am waiting on that.
Eh, hate to see the newb card being played here. From the outside I can see where people are coming from not liking this post. Let me try to explain what the point of this was. We were called out, and BSL felt that something should be said to respond to the accusation, not knowing when I would next be available. Therefore, he came in to at least offer some response, despite not having full details on what he was responding to, which is hard for any player to attempt.
BSL - you posted to explain even when you knew playing the noob card would get you flak? Is this correct?
Mentos - How do you feel about that?
Eh, it's a mix how I feel about that. On one hand, as I said above, if I was someone else I can definitely see the problem with it, which makes me dislike it a bit. On the other hand, I've been able to talk to BSL since then, and can tell exactly why he felt the need to post it. He felt a sense of urgency about the pressure on us. In fact, when he contacted me tonight to make sure I was on top of reading the thread, he literally said we were the target lynch. After reading I think we're in better shape by far than he implied, but from my talk with him I understand him making the post. So, I don't like it due to the fact that the post is to some extent suspicious, but I understand what he was thinking when he made it, so it's not too bad from my POV.
@mod: Licky's vote is on Gotenks
@Gotenks. Licky doesn't buy it. Licky can see right through.
care to explain?
what dont you buy? what can you see right through?
and why?
I agreed with this question 100%. My exact reaction to that post.
Licky does not buy that you are noob town. Licky can see through your act. Why? Because I can. As Licky has said, you have done no scumhunting and have been on the sidelines. This half has never played with mentos before, but Licky would think he knows how to scumhunt.
First of all,the person who was posting at the time is noob, it's not an act he's putting on, so your first part is just wrong digging. Then you move back to scumhunting. Once again I'll ask, how do you know there hasn't been scumhunting going on? Not to mention the times I have said I had some solid townreads, which are achieved through scumhunting. Just because I'm not posting every little suspicion doesn't mean I'm not scumhunting, it just means I don't feel like pointing out every thought process>_>
licky, please go look at the other game, then. i am playing this game pretty much exactly as i did Majora's Mask. i flipped town there.
again, i havent discussed scumhunting with mentos yet, so i dont know his reasoning behind not doing it.
Not a big fan of this post, just so y'all know. Meta defense is extreme WIFOM(not to say I haven't used it before, but I don't like when I do it eitherXD), except in occasional rare circumstances, and the second part agrees with a baseless accusation that, well, I've already responded to.
Well it's interesting that you pointed that out because you were actually playing better in that game, from my perspective. You and Mentos have not been using a quicktopic? Weren't you guys the ones that proposed people use one? It would make things much easier in terms of communication if you used one, since you don't necessarily need to be on at the same time to express your thoughts to one another.
Uhm anyway, what are your current thoughts on Chuckie, bsl?
We have made one, but it's not much easier to have a conversation checking in a few hours apart, and both be up to date when we're using it than to wait until we can converse live. It's being used, but it's better to be in realtime, and with how spread out it would be otherwise it doesn't yet make a great alternative.
so lets say yu guys lynch mory and he flips town
then what
all yu learn is that like every1 was wrong
do yu guys actually think hes scum or are you just policy lynching him. its ********. cuz unless yu actually think morys scum you shouldnt vote him [and i dont believe most ppl think hes scum but just wanna get rid of him cuz they cant deal with it]
i voted you cuz longass cases out of nowhere = always scum. its like the most obv scumtell ever. yu srsly need to die toDay.
@mod my votes on the man. please change it
:/ Whichever of you posted that, how do you not see Moriarty as being a good lynch? They can't ever be as easy or as clear to read posting the way they are, do you really want to deal with pictures only being alive on mylo or lylo? There's not a clear standout scum candidate right now, and Moriarty is not only very much a non-presence today, but is also in the most anti-town game right now.
@Cheese: I don't think that one post in particular should counter out the negatives. And from my perspective that post is more null than townie. I think it looks more townie from your perspective since it was directed at you.
@FFS: bsl had a bit of suspicion on Chuckie earlier so I want to know what his thoughts about him are now. And I'm still interested in Chuckie o.o
I agree with Spag, we get nothing from Moriarty and we have no legit scum tells on him. I feel we could get a head start in the game by lynching spag, the-man, PM, Gotenks, FZ, or Chuckie >____________>
I think 2 or more scum is in this group.
I feel like FZ hasn't posted in a while. I know OS is V/LA but Frozen why haven't you been posting? Also Gordito it seems like you haven't been posting as much either.
Smarboy can I have your current thoughts on FFS, Regal, Gotenks, and FZ?
Ok, so you still think we have a better chance to hit scum by lynching any of HALF THE GAME that makes it a legitimate better choice than getting rid of a player who's going to be impossible to fully read late game? Not to mention you agree with spag, but think he may be scum? And his top suspect you're ok with too? This post is essentially no better than saying you don't know who to lynch. It also kind of makes me think of scum taking the "Defend Moriarty" stance to keep him alive and a distraction moving forward. You have no reason to believe we have a great chance of hitting scum based on suspecting half the game.
Soz wrong account but I'm on my iPod. And I don't know how to log out of swf mobile lol.
Me and kat are both pretty vla ATM, but we agree with the spaghetti that lynching mor for the sake of it is dumb. But we don't want a no lynch.... anyone wanna lynch the man or gotenks instead, let us know, will bbl before deadline... But I can't remember him posting in the last few days so actually I'm probably down for mor... But
.
Swiss: I dunno if were just disagreeing over dumb stuff. If you're scum and just intentionally doing this imma hate you forever :D
Oh lick is voting gotenks that's good enough for me
Unvote vote: gotenks
Thanks for posting any substance to justify that vote. Even if you're on your phone, if you're gonna make a post pointing suspicion and voting for someone you should back it up.
Gotenks- I'm really not liking him. I don't want YOU to tell us to meta you. That can mean that you're purposely trying to mirror your town style. His 366 and 380 were just... LAUGHABLE. I mean, come on Mentos. You gotta teach BSL how to play as scum! I, as Gordito, am down to vote for him if our other option doesn't go through (it's a surprise!). Kinda like my second choice.
Yeah, definitely, unfortunately that'd be kinda tough to do in this game. Maybe next time. I'm not gonna go into the WIFOMy response I'd have against that, but really you seem opportunistic jumping on with me as an option with nothing but those two posts to base things on.
@FZ: Where'd you guys get off to? Towniest of town for a while, then you both just disappeared. Look forward to more by you guys.
I think that's all I've got right now and it's gettin late. We're not gonna be the play today, that's left for Moriarty. Can't take risks on potential, we need to get rid of something that'll be an easy push for scum at mylo/lylo if town, or is going to skate by without effort as scum.
