Golden Sun: The Lost Age (of) Mafia -Game Over! Indy Alex wins!

[rid****ulous]

rake's order is fine with me.

 

[Shun Goku Satsu Rake]

course it is.

I am a bro.

Tcat proving she has a brain by being the only one to question the mind read thing is of more interest than the fact she still voted on that wagon.

 

[rid****ulous]

lol, i never questioned the mind read thing because ryu had claimed it as a gambit by the time i saw any of it.

 

[rid****ulous]

in fact, i believe the day was over by the time i was reading.

 

[Kantrip]

I am also fine with Rake's order.

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

Tcat > Ryker > Furio > Ridic > Potassium > RR

Ding ding ding.

Start it.

I wanna lynch TCat at this point btw.

 

[Shun Goku Satsu Rake]

Ryker for me.

There is however that kevmo kill hoverin in my head and I'm thinking maybe another redirect could be a thing.

What's a strongman again ?

 

[Shun Goku Satsu Rake]

wait wait wait.

kantrip, what is your read on me now ?

I still don't understand how I was a scum-lean on Gheb scum. What was with that ?

 

[Kantrip]

I think I forgot about your claim and went off of something I was seeing on that page. You're a town read for me right now.

 

[Shun Goku Satsu Rake]

We probably win just by lynching Ryker then Furio honestly.

But w/e.

Think about it, why is Ryker alive still ? because he's scum fits nicely.

 

[Shun Goku Satsu Rake]

Plus Bardull is all lurkey and not posting so that must mean something.

It's not liable I'm going to carry us btw. We'll see how goes.

 

[rid****ulous]

the only problem with the claim order is that we have to wait for the two most inactive players to go before the rest of us can.

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

Tcat is the most likely to fit scum right now rereading D1-3.

If she doesn't claim in the next post we lynch her.

 

[Shun Goku Satsu Rake]

wouldn't be a problem if we could just lynch them.

We will wait, discuss other things.

Tcat, while your at it, tell me why you voted Inferno, seeing what Ryu had claimed ?

How do people feel about Ryu ?

Indy reads ?

 

[Kantrip]

Ryu's guilty claim on Inferno was cool.

Want the inactives dead, then Furio, then ridic.

So that's the order I like for our claim. There's really not much more to talk about. I have the setup pretty pieced together so far, just need to see how everything else fits.

 

[Furio Tigre]

Kantrip is poop and probably blue scum. Or it's one of the nulls. I haven't looked everything over yet. Why does my other half neglect to mention Kantrip who has done virtually nothing all game except defend himself or OMGUS?

Rake, BarDulLscum = lurking? Where's the meta substantiation coming from?

Got tired of Furio accent because, while it was humorous in concept at first, is rather MEH in practice.

 

[rid****ulous]

lol, we're not dying this game.

 

[rid****ulous]

I should probably bring up that I would much rather have kantrip claim before us, if nobody has any objections.

 

[Furio Tigre]

TCat, Ryker, Riddick, Kantrip, would love to hear who you think scum are. Get your hands dirty.

 

[rid****ulous]

Either Ryker or TCat. Not sure which one I like less, really.

 

[Kantrip]

Whoa there, whoa. I'm offended now. I have done a fair bit of defending myself, but where does the OMGUS come into play? My vote on IR early on? That was legit and they were scum (not with BSL). My reasoning on them was some of the only legit reasoning thank you very much.

 

[Kantrip]

TCat, Ryker, Rid****, Kantrip, would love to hear who you think scum are. Get your hands dirty.

"Want the inactives dead, then Furio, then ridic."
-Kantrip, a couple posts above you

 

[Kantrip]

I should probably bring up that I would much rather have kantrip claim before us, if nobody has any objections.

We'll compromise on this one. I'll claim half before you and half after

 

[Furio Tigre]

"Want the inactives dead, then Furio, then ridic."
-Kantrip, a couple posts above you

That's a lynch order, not scum reads. First two are obvious, but where's the distinction between Ridic/Furio? Are you reading TCat/Ryker as scum?

 

[Furio Tigre]

We'll compromise on this one. I'll claim half before you and half after

You're probably going to claim first.

 

[Shun Goku Satsu Rake]

It was a jab at you, I don't think I recall scumBardull as lurky.

Your reaction was more or less expected, although I'm surprised your not still as iffy on me. I was expecting something else but what can you do.

I don't think Ridick, you , RR or potassium is scum right now.

That leaves Ryker and Tcat. between the two, ryker for indy and TCat for blue scum.

I have a working theory on why BSL played as he did towards the end and it favors the idea of a inactive partner who needs a clean slate.

Plus, Tcat's follow up on RR's gambit doesn't add up with her vote and yet I want to call that a town tell. Does blue scum Tcat come into the thread after being dead inactive and draw attention to herself that way ? My gut says no , meaning I'm left with Ryker, and he can't be both, unless their is no indy.

But that doesn't add up either ,I don't see many people from town, using a town redirect(i've only ever heard of this from OS all-stars) to redirect inferno of all people.

Which adds up to me being less a scum read and needing an idea spark.

This kantrip thread isn't doing it though. I don't know how to explain, but kantrip just isn't scum in my eyes at all right now. maybe i'm blind but it's just too easy to be legit.

 

[Shun Goku Satsu Rake]

I could maybe be persuaded to see kantrip indy, but that's about the extent I'm willing to play with here.

TBH , Furio, I'm still uncertain on why I'm town reading you. You need to come up with more than Kantrip I think.

What do you think about Ryker as scum ?

 

[Furio Tigre]

It was a jab at you, I don't think I recall scumBardull as lurky.

Your reaction was more or less expected, although I'm surprised your not still as iffy on me. I was expecting something else but what can you do.

I don't think Ri****, you , RR or potassium is scum right now.

That leaves Ryker and Tcat. between the two, ryker for indy and TCat for blue scum.

I have a working theory on why BSL played as he did towards the end and it favors the idea of a inactive partner who needs a clean slate.

Plus, Tcat's follow up on RR's gambit doesn't add up with her vote and yet I want to call that a town tell. Does blue scum Tcat come into the thread after being dead inactive and draw attention to herself that way ? My gut says no , meaning I'm left with Ryker, and he can't be both, unless their is no indy.

But that doesn't add up either ,I don't see many people from town, using a town redirect(i've only ever heard of this from OS all-stars) to redirect inferno of all people.

Which adds up to me being less a scum read and needing an idea spark.

This kantrip thread isn't doing it though. I don't know how to explain, but kantrip just isn't scum in my eyes at all right now. maybe i'm blind but it's just too easy to be legit.

There are a few things bothering me. Didn't like your response to the redirect claim from Inferno for some reason, for one. Contemplation of how cards will be played is still ongoing, if you haven't already guessed.

Who in the what how why is Traveling Cat? Hard read.

Kantrip Town isn't staring me in the face for some reason. Isn't Kantrip better than this?

As for your working theory on BSL, the only player who truly profited from his flip was you. I'd say you have balls for trying to turn his would-be inevitable lynch into a good hand. It's actually not entirely unlikely considering BSL's claim actually doesn't make much sense at all in a Fire and Ice set up.

 

[Furio Tigre]

Like, if we actually sit down and look it over, why in the name of Gorf would BSL do that in a Fire and Ice set up? What even in the ****.

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

Kantrip is first after inactives claim.

Rakes knows I am town because Swiss I'm guessing told him my role?

 

[Furio Tigre]

Someone satiate this Tiger's tummy. Who's the scum that came up with that god awful plan to have his partner claim a role that wasn't safe?

IR's claim of Garet verrifies that scum have safe claims. So why claim Ivan?

 

[rid****ulous]

So we want our claim order to be

Ryker > TCat > Kantrip > Furio > Riddick > Ryu > Rake

Yes?

 

[Furio Tigre]

Sorry if I'm flooding the thread with a plethora of posts. But are you guys seeing what I'm seeing, or is this just a dream? Someone pinch me.

 

[rid****ulous]

Someone satiate this Tiger's tummy. Who's the scum that came up with that god awful plan to have his partner claim a role that wasn't safe?

IR's claim of Garet verrifies that scum have safe claims. So why claim Ivan?

I believe this was addressed by S&C. Like, this is the reason we lynched IR

BSL claimed what he did because he was drawing out a CC, under Gheb's orders.

 

[Furio Tigre]

I believe this was addressed by S&C. Like, this is the reason we lynched IR

BSL claimed what he did because he was drawing out a CC, under Gheb's orders.

Riddick probably Town. This seems too clueless to be fake.

 

[Furio Tigre]

Riddick, did you not notice that we're in a Fire and Ice set up? BSL was not aligned with IR.

 

[rid****ulous]

lol, oh crap, you're right. That was S&C's case though, or at least part of it. The fact still remains that he could have been doing that under someone else's orders. Not necessarily Gheb's. He could still, in fact, have been drawing out a CC.

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

So we want our claim order to be

Ryker > TCat > Kantrip > Furio > Rid**** > Ryu > Rake

Yes?

Nope I am last under every situation.

 

[Furio Tigre]

lol, oh crap, you're right. That was S&C's case though, or at least part of it. The fact still remains that he could have been doing that under someone else's orders. Not necessarily Gheb's. He could still, in fact, have been drawing out a CC.

But here's the problem: why? Why draw out a CC when you consist of a 2man scum team? And on Day 1 no less? With a claim that was awful and had no guarantee of catching Cop when someone could have just CC'd Ivan?

 

[rid****ulous]

But here's the problem: why? Why draw out a CC when you consist of a 2man scum team? And on Day 1 no less? With a claim that was awful and had no guarantee of catching Cop when someone could have just CC'd Ivan?

I dunno man. Do you think when you figure out the answer to this question, it will lead you to scum? Cuz if it doesn't, just chalk it up to "BSL is bad".

It's still entirely possible that he went for the CC fish because he's not confident in himself, and he figured sacrificing himself to potentially gain valuable info for his teammate would be better than what he could do alive.