finalark
SNORLAX
I do and don't agree with you on different points.
Thoughts on some of the mentioned series:
Thoughts on the scene at large:
Although honestly, it seems to me like you're suffering from having high standards and fatigue from the medium.
EDIT: That ended up being longer than I intended so it's been edited for readability.
Thoughts on some of the mentioned series:
In regards to Death Note, I personally enjoyed it over Higurashi (more on that in a minute) I'd have to say that it's honestly one of the better manga series I've read. The artwork is good, the story is very engaging, it isn't vomiting anime-isms at every turn and it's one of the few series I've read where I felt like the characters were exactly that, characters. Interesting, engaging and well written characters instead of easily identifiable archetypes that fill the scene today. This is talking exclusively about the manga, however. The anime adaptation shoves the religious symbolism down your throat tenfold (which is astounding given how much the manga did this) and takes every single scene in the manga to ridiculously over dramatized levels. It's almost like the producers of the anime thought that the manga was too subtle and that most viewers would have a hard time picking up on things.
On the note of Higurashi, I tried reading the manga years ago and quickly got sick of trudging through tired, standard harems tropes and archetypes before getting to the horror that the series is known for. The anime might be better, but I'm not convinced. I hear that From the New World is pretty good, but the hyper sexualized aspect of the manga is really turning me away from it. I'm not immediately against fanservicey series, but when you try to mix it with heavy subject matter it doesn't click for me. I had the same issue with Elfin Lied for all five of you out there who have been into anime long enough to remember that series.
Moving on to LN adaptations. I'll agree that they get really, really overhyped. Black Bullet was far from being anything special and No Game No Life loses its uniqueness if you've ever read any gaming manga ever written ever. I have to disagree with you on Log Horizon, however. I found it to be a very refreshing taking on the "trapped in a game" story. Most tend to just convert them into a video game themed survival story while Log Horizon took a very unique approach in favoring politics and social issues over combat and death. I thought the first season was fantastic, but the second season is where the show's flaws really became apparent. Plot threads that don't go anywhere, a lack of focus, poor pacing and the interesting characters who should get attention don't.
On the note of Higurashi, I tried reading the manga years ago and quickly got sick of trudging through tired, standard harems tropes and archetypes before getting to the horror that the series is known for. The anime might be better, but I'm not convinced. I hear that From the New World is pretty good, but the hyper sexualized aspect of the manga is really turning me away from it. I'm not immediately against fanservicey series, but when you try to mix it with heavy subject matter it doesn't click for me. I had the same issue with Elfin Lied for all five of you out there who have been into anime long enough to remember that series.
Moving on to LN adaptations. I'll agree that they get really, really overhyped. Black Bullet was far from being anything special and No Game No Life loses its uniqueness if you've ever read any gaming manga ever written ever. I have to disagree with you on Log Horizon, however. I found it to be a very refreshing taking on the "trapped in a game" story. Most tend to just convert them into a video game themed survival story while Log Horizon took a very unique approach in favoring politics and social issues over combat and death. I thought the first season was fantastic, but the second season is where the show's flaws really became apparent. Plot threads that don't go anywhere, a lack of focus, poor pacing and the interesting characters who should get attention don't.
Thoughts on the scene at large:
Honestly, I've mostly been ignoring mainstream opinion since (time for me to get into grumpy old man mode) the new generation of anime viewers and manga readers seem to be satisfied with one note archetypes and self-insert/invincible protagonists as long as there's a vaguely interesting story to follow. It doesn't help that many of these stories aren't even all that unique when you've been reading manga and watching anime for a long time.
High School DxD? That occult themed harem series with a surprising amount of action and story? That would be impressive if I hadn't read Rosario + Vampire back in the mid 2000s.
Sword Art Online? The series about a player trapped in an MMORPG and the people he meets there? Did everyone just kind of forget about .Hack//SIGN?
No Game No Life? A series about a world where games have dire consequences and the world's magic revolves around them? Cool, too bad Yu-Gi-Oh (manga) exists and has the added benefit of not using an eleven year old girl for fanservice.
Anyway, as I previously stated, the 10s generation of anime/manga fans seem perfectly fine with the bare minimum. And just like any other medium, that's not going to change until the new generation starts demanding more out of their entertainment.
Wow, that came out way more negative than I had intended. I don't actually hate or dislike everything recent. There's actually a lot of it I like. Magi, Fairy Tail even with it's myriad of flaws, Chunibyo and Food Wars are all recent series that I enjoy. For me, it's more of a frustration in the direction that the scene at large is moving.
High School DxD? That occult themed harem series with a surprising amount of action and story? That would be impressive if I hadn't read Rosario + Vampire back in the mid 2000s.
Sword Art Online? The series about a player trapped in an MMORPG and the people he meets there? Did everyone just kind of forget about .Hack//SIGN?
No Game No Life? A series about a world where games have dire consequences and the world's magic revolves around them? Cool, too bad Yu-Gi-Oh (manga) exists and has the added benefit of not using an eleven year old girl for fanservice.
Anyway, as I previously stated, the 10s generation of anime/manga fans seem perfectly fine with the bare minimum. And just like any other medium, that's not going to change until the new generation starts demanding more out of their entertainment.
Wow, that came out way more negative than I had intended. I don't actually hate or dislike everything recent. There's actually a lot of it I like. Magi, Fairy Tail even with it's myriad of flaws, Chunibyo and Food Wars are all recent series that I enjoy. For me, it's more of a frustration in the direction that the scene at large is moving.
I watched Ergo Proxy years and years ago and I liked it well enough. It's worth taking a look at if you're in the mood for some solid cyberpunk. It gets pretty grim IIRC, but it's worth a watch if you're fine with that.Anyone here like Ergo Proxy? Was gonna try that and see if it can restore my faith in this godforsaken medium.
Although honestly, it seems to me like you're suffering from having high standards and fatigue from the medium.
EDIT: That ended up being longer than I intended so it's been edited for readability.
Last edited: