Another character that I have been thinking would be absolutely killer in this type of tourney is DK! He seems like one of the faster slow characters to me that would be able to get items quicker than say Ike and DDD but still packs a punch, what do you guys think?
I don't know much about Brawl DK, but from what I hear he has been improved slightly, and he is supposedly pretty good. It's hard to say with so little details; however, if you were good with DK in Melee then you are set, cause he plays very very similar to how he used to.
[NEW OFFTOPIC PORTION OF POST]
What you don't realize, rather, what you REFUSE to realize, is that tournament play is NOT, and WILL NOT EVER make one person better than another.
*sigh* Let me spell it out to you again. If you don't go to tournaments you will never be the best. Competitive players go to tournaments all the time to play new people, learn new things, and learn how to handle stress better. If you were friends with a group of smashers who went to tournaments all the time and played with them a lot and kept up with the metagame and stuff, you would get good, but you wouldn't be as good as you could have been if you went to tournaments. Even still, one reason why the group you were with got that good was because of the tournaments they went to, and one reason one could theoretically get good like in this example is because that experience would rub off onto them.
Tournament play is simply a way of proving the skill you already have. Can you pick up new methods and skills this way? Yes, its possible. But without playing with the person you are competing against for an extended amount of time, its not likely.
I've never been to a tournament that didn't have friendlies prior to, during, and after the tournament. Now I have already spelled out how the actual matches themselves are training, due to the fact that you have to focus, keep your cool, and still perform at your best, you don't learn that much in an actual "match," but these things aren't what I'm talking about. The friendly matches you play with all the people accumulated at the tournament, the advice you get from better players, the first hand experience with others of a different playstyle, these are all things that come from attending tournaments.
Another thing you assume is that unless you compete in a tournament environment, you'll never meet another high calibur player.
I don't assume this, it's just that it's highly unlikely. Also, if you aren't very good, they probably wouldn't play with you all that much, because of the skill gap. So if they did play with you, it would be either **** and leave you be, or they would try to give you advice and help you out. I tend to do the former, and have been to the people of my area that were new to smash.
This is another grave mistake on your part. I don't know what get togethers you attend, but every year at Anime Weekend Atlanta we have a Melee tournament and a room devoted to the game that's used for more casual matches before the tourney starts. Many of the absolute best players I've been around don't even compete officially, and last year I beat 2 of the people who went on to place 2nd and 3rd.
I found a list of players who have won AWA's Melee tournament:
AWA history of champs-
Brian-Samus
Aura-Fox
Kiba-? DocMarthCF????
Mike G
Of these I know Aura and MikeG. MikeG was one of the best Peach players of all time. AuraFox was a fox player from TN that was really ****ing good that nobody really knew about. I don't know who Brian and Kiba are admittedly; however, I would assume that they were some lesser known players in the area that were competitive. I don't know much about the Atlanta scene as I used to, as I was really close to those guys when my crew was active. Since then there have been tons of new guys. They also could have been some of the earlier winners too, which is understandable.
I dunno where the guy who placed 1st was, I guess he didn't come until later. But I faced off against a group of 3 others who didn't compete either and we had one of the fiercest 2v2 I've ever played in my life.
Personal experience without any names isn't much evidence to support any argument.
This is what I'm talking about. You deny coming down on those you deem casual, but in a roundabout way say that only those that choose to play the tourney style are the upper echelon.
What? I said people who consistently go to tournaments are better than those who aren't. They are in the upper echelon of smashers. If you took a random sampling from any other community and placed them with a random sampling of competitive players the competitive players would win. It's such a basic concept that has been proven over and over and over that it just isn't funny.
All I can say is you're wrong. Your method of thinking is wrong, and as such you are going to miss out on the majority of what Brawl really has to offer.
You have provided no real actual evidence to support your claims. You use personal experiences and stuff... that is far from conclusive, and there is no way you can support that data other than your word. Meanwhile, this site is chocked full of tournament results from all over the globe showing top players winning consistently, and the only upsets come from other competitive players. Why is my way of thinking wrong? Why do you think so highly of people who aren't actively seeking competition to the point of at least trying to attend a few tournaments every now and then?
That said, why the hell would I miss out on Brawl for thinking this way? The craziest thing that could happen is that there are some new players that make some upsets, but because of this community even I would know about it and I would take what those guys have to offer and add it to my skillset.
Thinking about it now, I don't hate you so much as I pity you.
That's nice, I don't care enough to pity you. I'll play you when Brawl comes around, and apparently you have been to AWA, so why don't you come to Momocon? It's on the weekend after Brawl comes out. Search it in google, you can find it's site very easily. I'd like to see you there, then we can fight out our different points of view in a good match. Up for a $10 money match?