First ever NSW crew league: rules, organisation and discussion

[Bjay]

I don't think Pokefloats and Rainbow Cruise should be a part of that list.

 

[M]

Corneria, Poke Floats and Rainbow Cruise are all best left out of the list imo.

 

[isthattim?]

list will be as stated 3 posts up ^^^

 

[luke_atyeo]

sounds good

 

[idontgottaname]

awesome list, though in melee most people just play fd lol.

 

[isthattim?]

I think you'll find its random tickle me elmo (with one stage cancel per person)

 

[S.D]

awesome list, though in melee most people just play fd lol.

News to me.

I sort of like the idea of having at least one of those moving stages in there. It adds a little to the stage cancel strategy. This coming from an IC main so you know there's no bias That being said traditional nuetrals would suit me too.

Hmmm

 

[idontgottaname]

k, im dumb. whatever.

 

[S.D]

Nawwwwwwww, don't pout tickles XD

 

[idontgottaname]

im not lol.im just saying i shoulda thought before i posted. didnt think about the rules.

 

[luke_atyeo]

I would just always play dreamland 64 anyway, that song gets stuck in my head so bad

 

[Gords]

Much better looking list. I'd have RC as a possible addition to the nuetral list but never Corneria.

I'm not a big fan of having both RC and PF. I say one or the other, one moving stage is enough.

I move for RC and no Pokefloats.

yeah as you can see my melee stage knoledge is pretty limited, so a few questions.
i would never put corneria as a neutral but why is RC and PF better than corneria

also why do you prefer RC to PF

I don't think Pokefloats and Rainbow Cruise should be a part of that list.

Corneria, Poke Floats and Rainbow Cruise are all best left out of the list imo.

why wouldnt you leave any of these counterpicks in the crew matches stage list.

 

[Bjay]

Corneria, Poké Floats, and Rainbow Cruise all have something in common.

 

[Gords]

so whats in common?

also i would like either PF or RC in as well, for reasons mentioned already by SD.
although my preference is for PF over RC

however I prefer corneria over both of those. why wouldnt you put corneria in?

 

[I LAG]

PERFECT STAGE LIST (brawl)

Stages:

* Battlefield
* Final Destination
* Smashville
* Yoshi's Island
* Delfino Plaza
* Battleship Halberd
* Lylat Cruise
* Pokémon Stadium (Melee)

* Brinstar
* Castle Siege
* Distant Planet
* Frigate Orpheon
* Jungle Japes (Melee)
* Luigi's Mansion
* Norfair
* Pokémon Stadium 2
* Rainbow Cruise

If you just wana go with neutrals them go with the green stages and maybe you can add one or two but if you want to go with all stages then go with green and orange. But thats just my suggestion. Its up to you to decide.

 

[luke_atyeo]

no spear piller 0/10

 

[unreon]

Lol most Melee people hate playing FD. Especially against me =(

We should make Pokefloats>Rainbow Cruise in my opinion. It's less 'movey' than RC.

 

[luke_atyeo]

and its a cooler more fun stage imo

 

[Dedu]

Jase that's coz of ur character.
Big Blue kgo <3

Imachargingmahlaserrrrrrssss!

 

[ComboTurtle]

I'm not a big fan of having both RC and PF. I say one or the other, one moving stage is enough.

I move for RC and no Pokefloats.

they should both be in so icies have a stage that u can beat them on right sam? else and icies player (sam) bans the one that is left in and doesnt have to play on the weak ice climbers stages edit: he's in my team so do whatever

also i wouldnt even mind just playing neutrals

 

[CAOTIC]

Aren't crews awesome?

 

[Berimbau]

yea id rather not have any of those moving stages, but if u were going to put one in RC > PF imo.

 

[ComboTurtle]

people with no crew dont get a say pat.

 

[S.D]

so whats in common?

also i would like either PF or RC in as well, for reasons mentioned already by SD.
although my preference is for PF over RC

however I prefer corneria over both of those. why wouldnt you put corneria in?

Mainly because Corneria = camping, and nobody likes that. Usually someone just camps the fin or the bottom section of the stage and both players try to bait each other to either come up or go down. Then of course you can hug the fin and tech endlessly so you never have to die. Throw in the random blasts from spaceships and the rather small blastzone you've got yourself a notverynuetral stage. You'll note that all the nuetrals have no wall. There is a reason for this.

Eg: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ziCR4Jwcpz4 second match of this set XD

 

[Bjay]

I still say just leave all that "legal stage" stuff with Brawl.

Melee's 6 neutral stages is fine the way it is, in my opinion.

 

[S.D]

Bjay is probably right.

Traditional nuetrals are pretty much always the best option for melee.

 

[I LAG]

any confirmed stage lists?

 

[isthattim?]

Bump

Since crews have been finalised this thread will now be for discussion and results, i will post the results later today, also the initial post will be changed to show how many times each crew has to play other crews in order to complete the season and how much money each crew has been contributed

TY
Tim

Brawl
the **** +17
Fake scar and the rest of his unfortunate crew +13
4 ****ing MKs **** **** +8
Hunters and collectors -3
somebody set us up the gong-19


Melee
The **** +27
4 ****ing MKs **** **** +8
Hunters and collectors+6
Fake scar and the rest of his unfortunate crew - 8
somebody set us up the gong -17


Overall
The **** +49.33
4 ****ing MKs **** **** +18.66
Fake scar and the rest of his unfortunate crew +9.33
Hunters and collectors +2
somebody set us up the gong -42.33

Anyone wants to try correct my maths go ahead, these results are with applicable bonus points added

 

[SummonerAU]

Ohhh awesome.

inb4 The **** vs Hunter crew melee results ;___;

 

[isthattim?]

Results are up for first meet of the season, however round 1 is still not finished
please check the first post to find out who you still have to play, (this can be done whenever, wherever)
also

Brawl
the **** +17
Fake scar and the rest of his unfortunate crew +13
4 ****ing MKs **** **** +8
Hunters and collectors -3
somebody set us up the gong-19


Melee
The **** +27
4 ****ing MKs **** **** +8
Hunters and collectors+6
Fake scar and the rest of his unfortunate crew - 8
somebody set us up the gong -17


Overall
The **** +49.33
4 ****ing MKs **** **** +18.66
Fake scar and the rest of his unfortunate crew +9.33
Hunters and collectors +2
somebody set us up the gong -42.33

 

[ComboTurtle]

Results are up for first meet of the season, however round 1 is still not finished
please check the first post to find out who you still have to play, (this can be done whenever, wherever)
also

the **** is dominating as expected

 

[S.D]

Woah, how many bonus points did we earn?

We're winning brawl too?

lol.

4 MK's need to pick their game up XD

 

[isthattim?]

Woah, how many bonus points did we earn?

We're winning brawl too?

lol.

4 MK's need to pick their game up XD

4 MKs only played one match

 

[SummonerAU]

waitwut Hunter played 4 MKs

 

[isthattim?]

waitwut Hunter played 4 MKs

if they did, it wasnt recorded

 

[tedeth]

Did we play hunter in brawl? I remember playing them in melee. I remember taking like... many stocks...

 

[Toby.]

it was never finished.i lost 0 stock against gords but still have to play EA.

edit: im talking about brawl.

 

[tedeth]

Ahhh ok fair enough.

 

[M]

Wait, but I remember playing summoner and taking his last stock... don't remember playing anything after that... =/

 

[SummonerAU]

I remember playing luke and Meteor in brawl.
Also Tedeth in melee (I was stomped pretty hard)