Okay, so here we go. I'm going to kind of be working through the information I have as I type so I apologize if some of this looks a little jumbled.
I'm Gandalf, Town Cop (finally!). On N1, I investigated J and learned he was not mafia. On N2, I investigated No Lynch and learned that he is mafia. Last Night, I investigated JTB and learned that he is not mafia. If anyone honestly doubts me on this, I can provide you with crumbs.
Anyway, so I tried to push No Lynch hard yesterDay. Ideally, I was going to get him lynched, but my main objective was just to make my Night results clear in case I flipped. I didn't intend on full-on claiming unless I somehow became the primary lynch candidate, just for the sake of leaving scum guessing (and maybe even managing to survive to see D4. I thought that was a bit of a stretch, but here I am!). That, of course, did not stop certain people *coughZencough* from openly speaking about me as if I had claimed Cop.
This post was originally going to be much longer, but before I launch into any other issues and theories, let me get some feedback.
No Lynch, why did you and your scummates choose Marshy over me toDay? I can think of a couple reasons, but if I can get it straight from the tap, then even better.
No Lynch, give me one good reason to believe that what you are currently doing shows any pro-town intent at all. Why would a townie (especially any townie who is not a Cop/Watcher/a role that can supply a definitive result) be comfortable risking an alpha strike on another player in lylo regardless of how "sure" they are that they are voting for scum (this is where I remind you that you have been a driving force behind both the J lynch and the Sherlock lynch, at least)?