Epic... Rap... BATTLES OF HISTORY!!! OVER GUESS WHICH SIDE WON

[#HBC | Gorf]

K so it's time to bulldoze through this and get you guys a votecount...

...

But seriously... 12 pages man? That's mean.

 

[#HBC | Gorf]

Through my skimming, I'm thinking this is the lynch, but I will check now to assure so.

 

[Jdietz43]

It is assuming Marshy's "Stop Lynch" was a bluff. Otherwise idk what the ruling is.

 

[Ramen King]

I fake voted.

 

[Ramen King]

@ Gorf

 

[#HBC | Gorf]

Show me the fake vote?

 

[#HBC | Gorf]

Okay, if it is what I think you're talking about, then I find justification in what you mean by a fake vote, and I will explain why once you quote what exactly you mean by your fake vote.

In the mean time,

Deadline is set for 6/1 at 11:59 EST! With 9 alive it takes 5 to lynch!

Circus (0)
JDietz43 (0)
Ranmaru (0)
JTB (0)
Inferno (0)
JayKay (0)
marshy (0)
Kataefi (0)
No Lynch (0)

Not voting (9) No Lynch, Kataefi, marshy, JayKay, Inferno, JTB, Ranmaru, JDietz, Circus

 

[Inferno3044]

NL might have just done a genius move. So many clears just happened.

Marshy I have a question for you but I wanna hear of the fake vote counts as a fake.

 

[Jdietz43]

So... wut happen?

 

[#HBC | ѕoup]

JTB/JDietz

let's roll

 

[Jdietz43]

(and that's nice of you to try and take the credit Zen... but if Gorf accepted "Ditzy" and "Kit kat" as official votes previously, "JKar" is going to fit the bill. We owe Marshy the save, not you)

 

[#HBC | ѕoup]

Vote: JTB

This is your only option JDietz, take it or leave it.

 

[#HBC | J]

Vote: Ditzy

Why are you giving him an out? @_@

 

[Jdietz43]

I like living. Get rid of the inactive and at least I'll get to try and protect someone toNight.

Vote: JTB

 

[#HBC | ѕoup]

Vote: JDietz

 

[#HBC | ѕoup]

J, did you just see that? Scum of the month.

 

[Jdietz43]

Ok then.

Unvote

 

[#HBC | ѕoup]

JDietz what did you accomplish there at all. Why did you just vote JTB like that without consideration of your mundo scumreads?

 

[Jdietz43]

We'd get rid of an inactive and I'm pretty sure everyone is angling to make me the next choice so I don't have many options if I want to stay useful. Getting rid of a giant null is never a bad thing if it's me or him.


Why did you actually find it necessary to pull that weak stunt? Shouldn't you have enough material on me as one of your scum reads already to justify a vote without finding a petty reason first?

 

[#HBC | ѕoup]

Getting rid of inactives at this point have cost us two mislynches, I wouldn't risk another inactive lynch over something I have actual meat to. It's not even about the weak stunt I pulled, it's more about seeing how you would react and what you would do. Seeing you instantly vote JTB like that will give me more to work with on your flip.

Learn to understand priroity.

 

[Jdietz43]

I really don't care.

Everyone either kill me or don't.

 

[Jdietz43]

I'm kinda serious.

If anyone has a better suggestion than me I'm all ears. Otherwise I'm probably the pick, I don't have the effort in me anymore to fight this just to give town one more save.

Vote: No Lynch
Slot is still whack, and has always been whack. Omgus 4 life.


If I'm going to go though, I'm going to make it worthwhile:

How sure are people of JK's townitude after them being saved from being lynched? I want both everyone's opinions on their current standing as well as their full read on me if I'm going down with the ship.

 

[#HBC | ѕoup]

It was very genuine and I don't think J would risk letting townies clear themselves like that. Mind telling me what you might have in mind?

 

[Jdietz43]

I literally don't know, it's why I'm asking. J was apparently town, Marshy was governor, You're still you, Circus won't claim, JTB is still lurking, Ran is... I don't even know anymore

I should probably just sleep on it instead of being burnt out in thread.

 

[ranmaru]

Nvm.

vote: jd

 

[Jdietz43]

KK, bye guys.

Always remember me as I was... devilishly handsome.

 

[ranmaru]

Jd can u vote yourself?

 

[Jdietz43]

That seems unnecessary. It'd just give more people a free pass to say "I wasn't there and wasn't a part of it".

 

[#HBC | Gorf]

Btw, the flushing of votes is from SHEER laziness of the mod. Nothing more. This is info I feel should b confirmed.

 

[Jdietz43]

Btw, the flushing of votes is from SHEER laziness of the mod. Nothing more. This is info I feel should b confirmed.

...Really?

(Ok first off that's terribly lazy modding and I'm uber dissapointed in you...)

But more importantly can we get confirmation of if you took NL's vote as genuine or not? It's important for us to know if Marshy is really governer.

 

[ranmaru]

JD who are your scumpicks now?

 

[Inferno3044]

Vote: Jdietz

My vote was on him before and he has been scummy all game. Also pretty sure he was against the DSH lynch although that was an inactive and scummy slot, but is all for lynching JTB due to inactivity. No me gusta broski.

@Marshy - Are you actually a governor?

 

[#HBC | marshy]

but of course

also jdietz is -1. dibs on hammah. anyone who drops it like its hot who isnt me is automatically scum

 

[Inferno3044]

unvote

 

[Ramen King]

Wait I'm dumb.


Yeah lessgo

omi god

Vote: Jkar


Marshy. Follow me. Set me free. Trust me and we will escape from the city.

Gorf this is what I was referring to. But no, I'd be cheating to say that was my intention at the time so it counts.

 

[JayKay]

Gorf this is what I was referring to. But no, I'd be cheating to say that was my intention at the time so it counts.

iight ive given you enough grief kary

NEVER thought id actually use this ****ty role but

stop lynch

Btw, the flushing of votes is from SHEER laziness of the mod. Nothing more. This is info I feel should b confirmed.

Still don't know whether I'm dead
This could just be the strangest twilight I've seen

 

[JayKay]

If you take a closer look at the first quote that's in relation to the early vote patterns at that point in the game. Look at what it was in response to:

Uh, what?

This is why I feel the start to this Day seems almost rushed/invasive... the honing in on players here makes me think there is something underlying that wants to build momentum on a wagon quick and I'm concerned about this.

Don't see why this still stands as being a reason not to commit to a waggon.

When you warned me, I wasn't here. Sorry about this as it's not much of a defence as it is just bad circumstances. If I saw momentum building up I would have unvoted considering this was something I've been attentive to. 24 hours is a reasonably short time to me. There was like 6+ days until the deadline and plenty of time to look into things and I wasn't sold on you being the 100% pick. Suddenly people decided to quicklynch again, despite talks of mylo. I didn't expect this -> I expected Dietz/J-side/Circus to answer me and things to progress.

FWIW I voted at the time because I was leaning toward you being the scummiest getting frustrated by the promises J made to answer me and he still didn't, despite posting other ****. Made me think he was intentionally ignoring me here and I wanted answers to stuff I grew concerned about to progress so wanted to pressure here (mainly stuff detailed below). I also voted to see if marshy would join me despite "knowing" dietz is scum. I felt that was an opportunity to look into him - he didn't and I felt more content with him here.

Uh, what?

i'm still here but i'm going on lunch. i'll be back in like an hour. mariah kary can i get a breakdown of your reads? who's looking scum to you? how are you and j dealing with conflicting reads?

This is after I warn you, and after marshy votes for JDietz, rather than following you.
Also, this:

And somehow you don't seem to be looking at JDietz at all anymore. Dislike.

Comes from the post where you vote for us.

Well... I think you make it sound unimportant here. Our scum reads were the same.

Additionally his analysis on Garg's play was literally identical to mine: #1001

Now look here:



I said I found Zen's thoughts weird. Also note the bolded: I was one of the only players to point out Soup's weird play D1. The fact I was the only one would have made J go "ahhh Kata noticed this too".......... if he genuinely read D1 that is

He also had issues with the Detective wagon as did I.

With many similarities across key events in the game, I think it's reasonable to question how/why I became his top pick and why this kept throughout with no reconsideration on me whatsoever considering he saw "gems" that made him "hesitate" on me... but then immediately turns on me as the player who definitely has to be lynched as if he was riding on the influence No Lynch created.

Why wouldn't I consider all of this something in need of looking into? I looked into this mid-D2 only to be repeatedly ignored.


Yo, shut the duck up. Just because both J and NL vote for you doesn't mean J is playing off of NL. I also cannot get it in my head why the duck you think that J having you as a top pick is scummy early Day 2, even if there might not be a lot of reason to it.
Why the hell is J your top scum pick, still, just for having you as top scum pick D2? Stop ignoring everything that doesn't contribute to your scumread on us, bro.

Apparently you can't even slim it down to a few key questions either...


But there are a lot questions tho. Also it's not so much you think me and no lynch aren't buddies, just that you're lining us up back-to-back in a situation J stated could be Mylo... which means he's forced to make the best decision, and has hardly engaged with us to achieve this...

Like, again with the duckery. You've leapt to this conclusion that we'll be gunning for you or NL once the other is dead, which is, like I said, JUST A MOTHERDUCKING LEAP. We have question marks over both of your slots, and your interaction with one another. Deal with it. Maybe we're not pushing on you today- deal with that as well.

Regarding confused, I think I mentioned this in relation to your reads on myself and marshy. J stated I had been shadow-bandwagonning, yet so has marshy and he's a near-100% Town read to J... so why is this exclusive to me? It's even a wrong observation, because D2 my vote wasn't anywhere near shadow-bandwagonning lol... The reads look confused.

No, shut up. Seriously, how the duck could being confused be a scum tell anyways. The point is that there is no way marshy of all people is shadow bandwaggoning; he's been like 300% more obvious with his vote than you have. Like, how would you describe your vote on us this Day phase? Oh look, you've come in and explained how you couldn't have known we might get lynched, how you weren't here... blah blah blah. Seems a bit like shadow bandwaggoning to me.

Gun-ho was exaggerated. I think moreso opportunistic is a better term.

Uh, what? I asked you to back up these kind of accusations, instead you just change the way you're going to phrase them? Dislike.

Curiously where did the bold come from? I had just got into the thread commenting about Marshy's potential governor ability. I didn't really engage with any of my top picks at this time so i don't think i was ignoring anyone.

See above, it's with reference to the post where you vote for us.

_

Gonna do a srs reread of everything as I feel out of the loop and can look at this at work tommo.

unvote for now ladies and gents

p.s. i'm actually Town.

uhhh,

#1001

This is a good start. ^Dietz/Circus can you go into details as to my questions here plz?

No Lynch I don't see anything scummy in that post I made.

So less tunnel-Kata please? Less hyper-defense Kata? That'd be great.

 

[#HBC | marshy]

to quell your fears kary: i indeed gave you life

 

[JayKay]

I believe you, bro.
But it's my opinion it'd be better if that was confirmed for all to see.
Can you maybe explain how the ability works or something?
I was expecting it to force a No Lynch or something.

 

[#HBC | marshy]

at this point were just waiting for gorf. basically all i was told to stop the lynch during twilight to just post that command. thats all i was told and while i probably shouldve asked gorf for more details i think you guys are town enough that i dont give a **** about the consequences

that said i believe your top choices are no lynch --> jdietz? also throughout this game ive STRONGLY believed there to be at least one scum between jerkus and jdietz. what do you make of this? and can you please pm j for his answer to the same question (youre allowed to do that as a hydra)