Also, if somebody used a high tier, won, but then lost using a low tier, would you say the other person won the second match because they were using a high tier? consider that.
I believe the results of the match is simply down to how both players played. If they played extremely well with the low tier character but still lost, i wouldn't think any less of them if they had won with a high tier character. I think we should be watching how people play more than who beat who. But i wont take this argument further as it's not a big part of the point i'm trying to make.
What TC says varies from player to player. He's not necessarily wrong, but he's not flat out correct.
In these kind of games, most players don't choose a character based on their "fanboyism". If I had, I would use too many characters.
It's not overall loyalty i have so much of a problem with, if you liked the playstyle of a character in one game, but not so much in another, then that cant be helped.
The point is, people play what they enjoy the PLAYSTYLE of. Most low tier users understand this, and so do not complain about the other persons choice of character.
The bold area is what i have most of a problem with most people. Most of those who main MK do so not because the playstyle suits them or anything, but because it is considered the best. What they enjoy about the playstyle is the fact that it towers above all others, and of course winning is a good feeling. So they can get away with saying they "enjoy MK's playstyle" more than others, when really wanting to win plays more of a role in their decision to choose him.
Anyone saying people should remain loyal to their character from melee to brawl need to learn alot about melee.
For the most part, most returned characters feel similar to how they played before so sticking with them is something to be expected. But again, if you didn't happen to like the changes made then it can't be helped.
The reason most people in the UK didn't make the switch is because the games are that significantly different. You can not blame somebody for not enjoying playing a character in brawl after playing them in melee. They enjoy them in melee, so when they get to brawl, it's completely different and quite often not as enjoyable.
A lot of reasons play a role in why UK players "didn't make the switch". I'd list the ones i feel are the biggest reasons but this discussion would just steer off course and I'd come off as very insulting. I do agree though that the biggest reason would be how different both games are. Of course, they are more similar than some people may think.
Anyone who complains about the use of characters in relation to tiers still has alot to learn.
This could go either way. Many people do choose characters in direct relation to tier lists. Forgive me (and correct me if i'm wrong), but being a MK main yourself... i don't think you're at liberty to state something so black and white.
If Snake was top of the tier list you would be hating on Snake mainers. Stop moaning about MK and any other top tier for that matter. Like Cal said a Low/Mid tier can beat a High if the person using him is skilled enough. Go train moar.
NO! We are not attacking the character known as "Meta Knight" (Trio3 might be, but i'm not) , it's the players who have chosen to main MK as a result of his tier position that we have the biggest problem with. If any character was in MK's position i would be saying the same things, and i'd be saying them because people would be maining them and using the exact same "playstyle" excuses. Ganondorf is a slow, sturdy character, Meta Knight is a quick, not-so-sturdy character; however, if Ganondorf was at the top and MK was at the bottom, people would instead be using Ganondorf and still throwing around the same reasons they have for maining MK right now. The core of the problem is not with the character, it's people's attitude that i find outrageous.
Ugh, why am i even bothering to disect posts and explain. As much as i hate to admit it, we are not the japanese, we do not have the kind of integrity or respect that they do. Priority #1 over here is winning, how this is accomplished matters not to most UK gamers, nor does diversity or trying to accomplish other tasks at the same time.
EDIT: Willz, how goes the uploading?