If you guys are going to drag on someone for not finding it worthwhile to discuss a character, you could at least add something once they do so as to not prove that person right.
Sorry my points weren't positive but at least I'm adding to the topic. On the plus side I hear people say this is it for Isaac, bar a new GS, and while that may or may not be true, I don't expect Isaac's popularity to remain where it is now. People are judging the popularity of ATs based on the demand that arose after they were seen to be deconfirmed, but many of them will regain popularity once the cycle resets. And Isaac seems to have worked his way into the rarified niche where the popularity is self-sufficient regardless of having active appearances, like K. Rool and Geno and such.
Though Crash is there, which is nice.
Alright, fine. I suppose I'm the one fearing risks all along.
- GS's music situation currently is similar to that of base game FFVII: Only having two tracks that were the ones from previous Smashes, plenty of signature songs like Isaac's battle theme and Venus Lighthouse missing.
- AT seems to be shoddily made (the moves all use different hand models even though they look exactly the same) and don't showcase how Psynergy isn't just summoning giant hands. This could be so Garet can take over as the AT since he's not alt material the same way Felix is.
- Lowkey nature of later reveals: Even if E3 has to have something bigger, they obviously don't think the final character has to be.
- The thing that was strange about FF is it only had two songs as a series with a playable character. I agree that GS has a wealth of music, including notable ones like Isaac and Saturos' themes. But it's also not that strange that a series without playable representation or a stage has relatively minimal music.
- I mean, Isaac's AT has never showcased how psynergy is more than waving a giant hand around. I think if they really didn't care they wouldn't have expanded what the AT could do when they brought it back. Unfortunately if they didn't get to reuse hand assets for Isaac I don't think he would've been as fleshed out as he was, frankly. I just don't think ATs are that high a priority that asset reuse, when possible, is avoided.
- I agree the last reveal will probably be lower-key, but I think that would only be helpful if there was more of a reason to expect Isaac. Like if there were a new GS game or something.
Sorry my points weren't positive but at least I'm adding to the topic. On the plus side I hear people say this is it for Isaac, bar a new GS, and while that may or may not be true, I don't expect Isaac's popularity to remain where it is now. People are judging the popularity of ATs based on the demand that arose after they were seen to be deconfirmed, but many of them will regain popularity once the cycle resets. And Isaac seems to have worked his way into the rarified niche where the popularity is self-sufficient regardless of having active appearances, like K. Rool and Geno and such.
I think I would prefer this roster for who was removed versus who was added.Alright, time for a hypothetical:
HYWR if this was the newcomer lineup for Ultimate?
Base
Fighters Pass Vol. 1
- (Echo)
- (Echo)
- (Echo)
- Crash Bandicoot
- Shadow (Echo)
- (Echo)
- (Echo)
- Solgaleo
- Ashley
Fighters Pass Vol. 2
- Sakura Shinguji
- Arthur (Ghosts 'n Goblins)
- Edelgard
- Bandana Dee
- Dr. Eggman
Though Crash is there, which is nice.