• Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!

    You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!

Official DLC Speculation Discussion Volume II

Status
Not open for further replies.

DarthEnderX

Smash Hero
Joined
Nov 10, 2014
Messages
8,412
I'm grateful he's even in, when last time he was nothing, despite being popular. I'm grateful the popularity amounted to acknowledgement, and a reinstatement. Being grateful doesn't preclude still pushing for more. It's not mutually exclusive.
I'm grateful Kunio got to be a Spirit and that Arthur and Goemon got to be Miis.

Do I wish they got more? Of course. But it's nice that Nintendo recognizes them. And maybe next time they'll get promoted.

And I'll certainly keep asking for them in the meantime.
 
Last edited:

Golden Icarus

Smash Lord
Joined
Oct 4, 2013
Messages
1,133
Location
USA
I mean, we did get a smaller character after them; Pyra. And besides, it's the representative of the biggest game every and the archetypal JRPG villain. There isn't much higher we can go anyways, so some smaller or mid-tier characters are perfectly plausible.
It is kinda wild how this Fighters Pass has gone. Steve and Seph are two of the most internet shattering characters we’ve ever had, while Min Min and Pyra are pretty much your standard promotional picks. If we’re following that pattern, then I guess we should be expecting our last two characters to fall under those categories. Something like Chief and Ayumi, or Crash and Cinderace. Yet for some reason my mind gravitates towards “middle of the road” for the end of the pass. Something like Lloyd, Arle, Hayabusa, Bandana Dee, Tails, Chun-Li. Characters who won’t quite rock the world in the way Steve or Sephiroth did, but also aren’t quite “shills” in the way Min and Pyra are.

This is definitely more of a gut feeling than a solid theory though.
 

SharkLord

Smash Hero
Joined
Jun 20, 2020
Messages
7,689
Location
Pangaea, 250 MYA
GS is a dead series though. Discussion of literally any character here comes with arguments against their chances. We can talk about Isaac endlessly if you keep bringing him up, but it’ll just never be what you want to hear.
And that too. There's a reason the likes of Isaac are considered risky. If they weren't risky, we'd be talking about them more. The thing is, everyone has their own standards, their own personal height of entry. There's always going to be someone who disagrees with you because they're just looking at it through a different lens. Disagreement is inevitable on the boards, but that's just how it is. Don't let that discourage you, because just as much as there are people who disagree, there's probably some like-minded individuals here and there as well.
 

N3ON

Gone Exploring
BRoomer
Joined
Jan 6, 2008
Messages
21,444
Location
Vancouver
I would like to, but I feel like there's going to be too much **** like "dead series" "too niche", "please just be grateful for what you have", "there's always when you're 35", etc.
It sounds like you just want to discuss it on your terms then. That's not really how an open discussion goes.

You were complaining that we don't discuss Isaac. Now we're discussing Isaac. Now you're complaining that we're not discussing it positively enough.

Well... hey. Isaac is an AT in a pretty dormant series wherein there's no indication of returning any time soon. I would love that not to be the case, but it is what it is. There are only two characters left. Things don't look good for him. Being optimistic about his chances at this juncture would require some real twisting of the situation. And I say that as an Isaac fan as big as anyone else around here.

The most positive spin I can put on things is that, despite the current lull, I believe Isaac will retain his fan popularity into the future. I believe he's going to stick around as a perennial fanbase pick like K. Rool and Geno.
 
D

Deleted member

Guest
I would like to, but I feel like there's going to be too much **** like "dead series" "too niche", "please just be grateful for what you have", "there's always when you're 35", etc.
1) It was more recently 'alive' than many other series represented (Ness says 'Hi')
2) Isn't Golden Sun an RPG? The genre so popular the idea of 'experience', 'levels', and new abilities gained through the former two aspects have appeared in almost every other genre at this point?
3) If Smash 'Ultimate' truly does get another game in the future, no matter who they add, it likely won't top the game it is now and the magic of having your 'most wanted' in the only game that featured icons from all around the industry makes hard to accept the comment 'wait till next game' and everyone knows it. Anyone who says that already has their 'most wanted' in already.
4) Do whatever you want; nobody but a mod can stop you and it'll never be more than just words that users throw at you, so who cares? It sounds more like you're creating excuses yourself as opposed to simply discussing him.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Slime Master

Smash Ace
Joined
Jun 16, 2019
Messages
560
Location
Boingburg, SL
I think one reason Isaac isn't discussed too much is that he has been a hot topic in the past. It's a lot harder to come up with a new angle for a character that's been discussed so much previously, and if you don't have that new angle less people are going to be interested in it. This is more so the case if the character is already seen as not too likely, though I'm not really sure why. I think Adol is another good example of this, for a while there Ys was a pretty hot topic on this thread, but I haven't seen it brought up much lately because we explored it pretty well.
 

RGFS

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Jun 25, 2020
Messages
294
Location
Los Santos, SA
I don't wanna be when Ridley fans weren't grateful they got a boss, K. Rool fans weren't just grateful he still got a trophy and a Mii costume in the most modern-focused Smash game ever, that being 4, and Chrom fans weren't just grateful he still "got his chance" in Robin's FS. "Being grateful" clearly isn't the way when they got their fighters.

Ironically while I say this I would be fine simply for having the option to hear some of GTA's original radio songs in Smash, fighter or not.
Yeah, sure bro you can hope for him and ask for him... but acting like he's an incredibly likely lock and not keeping your expectations in check is seemingly only frustrating you man. It doesn't seem like a good mindset to be in. Remember ALL those characters you mentioned did get into the next game. All those characters could've gotten in, but time restraints or a creative disagreement stopped them from getting in the first time. You also gotta realize and consider how those characters have always been significantly more popular than Issac as they're tied to bigger series too.

He could just also never ever get in as a fighter, and you have to mentally accept that outcome and you'll enjoy speculation more. I know that about all the series I care about who don't have anything. And hey, if Issac does get in, you'll feel way better in the long run if you take your hopes with a grain of salt. Aim low and you'll never be disappointed.

I'd be fine and grateful with my favorites series getting literally anything. Even if they never get a fighter.
I want them to get something specifically because I feel they're notable enough first and foremost but even something small would be incredibly appreciated. I would be over the moon if they actually put these four specific GTA songs in Smash. I believe that GTA objectively deserves way more in Smash but it's still cool and infinitely better for the series to get something rather than nothing.

Specifically these four tracks:





Well put. My most wanted franchise doesn't have all that much of a chance to begin with, and everyone we've gotten is a huge blast to play, so I'm content with whatever comes next.

Also, I totally thought your PFP was Nogla's GTAV model because of the green shirt. I'm sorry.
Yeah, I'm mainly just happy we've gotten so much DLC, to begin with. Speculation is the icing on the cake for me.

Ha! It's still from GTAV so you were close. It's Franklin's friend Lamar, but someone used one of those camera apps to make him smile.

 

Guynamednelson

Smash Legend
Joined
Dec 17, 2014
Messages
13,148
NNID
Nelson340
3DS FC
2105-8742-2099
Switch FC
SW 4265 6024 9719
but acting like he's an incredibly likely lock and not keeping your expectations in check is seemingly only frustrating you man
I'm not necessarily considering him a lock, hell I still talk about various third-parties just in case I am wrong about the potential decline in hype this late in the reveals, but you are definitely right about the frustration.
 

Louie G.

Smash Hero
Joined
Aug 21, 2013
Messages
9,795
Location
Rhythm Heaven
If Smash 'Ultimate' truly does get another game in the future, no matter who they add, it likely won't top the game it is now and the magic of having your 'most wanted' in the only game that featured icons from all around the industry makes hard to accept the comment 'wait till next game' and everyone knows it. Anyone who says that already has their 'most wanted' in already.
I mean, my MW is still absent but I've also accepted some time ago that there's little incentive for them to be added as DLC currently. So I've already adopted the "wait til next game" mentality all by myself. Unfortunately DLC doesn't seem very welcoming toward dormant Nintendo series and will rather favor Nintendo characters from more recent memory - my MW falls under this as well, from a more relevant series than Golden Sun but a currently absent-from-Switch series nonetheless.

I love talking about all the possibilities, but it's not hard to understand why someone like Isaac or, in my case, Chorus Kids are not in the best shape right now. Doubly so for golden boy because in addition to his series being out of commission he's clearly an Assist Trophy and has substantial competition within that category as well. Anything can happen but I don't think the lack of discussion toward someone like Isaac can really be blamed on the prominence of discussion toward big third party characters and "relevant" Nintendo characters because, whether I like it or not, that's the precedent that has been set right now.
 
Last edited:

Pillow

Smash Lord
Joined
Jan 20, 2013
Messages
1,268
Location
Los Angeles
Yeah, sure bro you can hope for him and ask for him... but acting like he's an incredibly likely lock and not keeping your expectations in check is seemingly only frustrating you man. It doesn't seem like a good mindset to be in. Remember ALL those characters you mentioned did get into the next game. All those characters could've gotten in, but time restraints or a creative disagreement stopped them from getting in the first time. You also gotta realize and consider how those characters have always been significantly more popular than Issac as they're tied to bigger series too.

He could just also never ever get in as a fighter, and you have to mentally accept that outcome and you'll enjoy speculation more. I know that about all the series I care about who don't have anything. And hey, if Issac does get in, you'll feel way better in the long run if you take your hopes with a grain of salt. Aim low and you'll never be disappointed.

I'd be fine and grateful with my favorites series getting literally anything. Even if they never get a fighter.
I want them to get something specifically because I feel they're notable enough first and foremost but even something small would be incredibly appreciated. I would be over the moon if they actually put these four specific GTA songs in Smash. I believe that GTA objectively deserves way more in Smash but it's still cool and infinitely better for the series to get something rather than nothing.

Specifically these four tracks:







Yeah, I'm mainly just happy we've gotten so much DLC, to begin with. Speculation is the icing on the cake for me.

Ha! It's still from GTAV so you were close. It's Franklin's friend Lamar, but someone used one of those camera apps to make him smile.

I personally don't really care for any of the GTA protags as playable characters (I'd rather have Saint's Row for wacky M rated sandbox guy), but yeah I'll take the soundtrack. Soviet Connection in Smash would be so sick.


You're guaranteed to get your character in Smash. But you must sacrifice Luigi.
Would you do it? :luigimelee:
Luigi's ****ing dead.
 

Cutie Gwen

Lovely warrior
Joined
Jul 1, 2014
Messages
63,872
Location
Somewhere out there on this big blue marble
Man, this is making me want a character of my own to just start championing out of the blue. I know a while back I started a Junpei thread and everything, but I think I'd want my legacy to be something a little more personal to me. As a Nintendo kid through and through, though, most of my MWs are already pretty well-established.

...Maybe I should become the De Blob guy...
Junpei? You mean 999 Junpei? **** yeah dude, 999 has my favourite story in video games and literally cannot be recreated in any other media, a true ****ing masterpiece in every way, I have no clue what the **** Junpei would even do but I can never forget how I stayed up until 2AM on a workday after I beat 999 as I kept realizing how the story made so much sense and what was foreshadowing, a feeling only replicated by Virtue's Last Reward, a top tier game despite it's flaws
 

Merengue

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Feb 23, 2021
Messages
357
Pretty much me, I’d take KOS-MOS over Byleth in a heartbeat. Only thing is I’d personally swap out Porky for either Octoling (1st party) or Ahri (3rd party)
I respect your choices! However, I highly recommend learning about and playing the Mother series. It's a niche series that could use some more attention.
 

Technomage

Smash Champion
Joined
Jan 18, 2019
Messages
2,289
A fully playable AT upgrade would make the entire community lose their collective mind. It'd be the Smash equivalent of tearing a hole in the spacetime continuum. None of the age-old "rules" would apply anymore
Except for the "video game characters only" rule.
WELL. Took long enough, but I finally calculated some of Fighter 10's potential background colors! Of course, keep in mind the standard "this is math" yaddi yadda... (but I'm sure you've heard that plenty of times lol.) Anyways, here's what I got for my minimally extended colors!

View attachment 312090
Okay, potential newcomers with that color scheme: Amy Rose, Sakura Shinguji, Birdo, Tiki
 

ahemtoday

Smash Ace
Joined
Oct 30, 2020
Messages
874
All this talk about Isaac, but no talk about the real Golden Sun grab:

1618943490745.png
1618943499833.png


Seriously, though, my experience with GS was watching the first few episodes of an LP and then forgetting to watch the rest, but Saturos and Menardi still stuck in my head. Also, they turn into a two-headed dragon, and that's awesome. Not that my opinion counts for much as someone with limited GS knowledge, but if you ask me these two are the next stop after Isaac.

Junpei? You mean 999 Junpei? ** yeah dude, 999 has my favourite story in video games and literally cannot be recreated in any other media, a true ***ing masterpiece in every way, I have no clue what the * Junpei would even do but I can never forget how I stayed up until 2AM on a workday after I beat 999 as I kept realizing how the story made so much sense and what was foreshadowing, a feeling only replicated by Virtue's Last Reward, a top tier game despite it's flaws
Heck yeah I mean 999 Junpei! I feel obligated to, at this point, plug his support thread. Maybe I should get back into RTC to rack up noms for a rating on this guy...
 

RGFS

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Jun 25, 2020
Messages
294
Location
Los Santos, SA
I personally don't really care for any of the GTA protags as playable characters (I'd rather have Saint's Row for wacky M rated sandbox guy), but yeah I'll take the soundtrack. Soviet Connection in Smash would be so sick.
Eh... That's like adding Rayman before Mario or Sonic to Smash. If you're looking for a wacky M-rated sandbox guy, Trevor would likely be your best bet personality-wise compared to Saint Row's generic super-powered avatar named "The Boss". He really isn't even close to likely if you compare the impact and popularity (Though the SR games are on Switch lmao!). After GTA, I would be interested in seeing a moveset for The Boss with Johnny Gat as an alt. Though I'm unsure if classic SR fans would even like the moveset considering most of them have hated the series since the third game in my experience.

Also, if you really want a whacky M-rated sandbox man, your best bet would Garry's Mod. It would use different Half-Life skins and make no sense but I'd be so down for a gm_construct stage.
 

Wunderwaft

Smash Master
Joined
Mar 21, 2019
Messages
3,500
Look I know Martin is just ****posting with his math. But the color background made me think deeply about some characters and then I realized, I've been sleeping on the mother****ing Octolings. Splatoon 2 was a big hit for the Switch, and it fits with Nintendo's strategy of promoting successful first party Switch titles as DLC in Ultimate. The squid sisters miis might seem as a deconfirm at first until you realize it's a splatoon 1 mii costume and not a splatoon 2 mii costume.

They ain't no locks obviously, but if we get another first party character I'd keep my eyes on the little octopuses.
 

Pillow

Smash Lord
Joined
Jan 20, 2013
Messages
1,268
Location
Los Angeles
Eh... That's like adding Rayman before Mario or Sonic to Smash. If you're looking for a wacky M-rated sandbox guy, Trevor would likely be your best bet personality-wise compared to Saint Row's generic super-powered avatar named "The Boss". He really isn't even close to likely if you compare the impact and popularity (Though the SR games are on Switch lmao!). After GTA, I would be interested in seeing a moveset for The Boss with Johnny Gat as an alt. Though I'm unsure if classic SR fans would even like the moveset considering most of them have hated the series since the third game in my experience.

Also, if you really want a whacky M-rated sandbox man, your best bet would Garry's Mod. It would use different Half-Life skins and make no sense but I'd be so down for a gm_construct stage.
Oh, I didn't mean to imply that I think the Boss should be in Smash, just that I personally would prefer him. I'd still say GTA is the frontrunner for this sort of game, but these type of series in general don't fit the "feel" of Smash to me. It's not so much the violence or vulgarity so much as it is the lack of a fantasy element in them.
 

Louie G.

Smash Hero
Joined
Aug 21, 2013
Messages
9,795
Location
Rhythm Heaven
Look I know Martin is just ****posting with his math. But the color background made me think deeply about some characters and then I realized, I've been sleeping on the mother****ing Octolings. Splatoon 2 was a big hit for the Switch, and it fits with Nintendo's strategy of promoting successful first party Switch titles as DLC in Ultimate. The squid sisters miis might seem as a deconfirm at first until you realize it's a splatoon 1 mii costume and not a splatoon 2 mii costume.

They ain't no locks obviously, but if we get another first party character I'd keep my eyes on the little octopuses.
The argument against them seems to mostly be founded in the idea that we got Splatoon costumes already earlier in this pass.

Personally though, I think you've got a little more flexibility with Nintendo costumes to release them whenever you please. Nothing stopping them from just bundling Octoling with some unrelated stuff from an unrelated company like we saw with Byleth and Pyra / Mythra. If anything there's more precedent for that at the moment.

In other words I don't think it's so damning, but it's something to keep in mind. I do think Octoling remains a pretty strong candidate for an additional first party seeing how Octo Expansion came too late to have any impact on base game, Splatoon 3 is gonna be a heavy hitter for Nintendo moving forward and it remains one of Nintendo's big ticket series atm appearing in promos and stuff right alongside Mario, Zelda and Animal Crossing.
 
Last edited:

RGFS

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Jun 25, 2020
Messages
294
Location
Los Santos, SA
Look I know Martin is just ****posting with his math. But the color background made me think deeply about some characters and then I realized, I've been sleeping on the mother****ing Octolings. Splatoon 2 was a big hit for the Switch, and it fits with Nintendo's strategy of promoting successful first party Switch titles as DLC in Ultimate. The squid sisters miis might seem as a deconfirm at first until you realize it's a splatoon 1 mii costume and not a splatoon 2 mii costume.

They ain't no locks obviously, but if we get another first party character I'd keep my eyes on the little octopuses.
I'm still holding out hope for a whole echo pass right at the end man... Octolings, Impa, Dixie, Shadow, Big Boss, etc I feel would make a lot of people happy. As they're DLC, they could also get small touchups and tweaks to be more like Ken echos. Seeing them right at the end would fit how we base game usually makes semi-clone and echo characters by the end of normal development.

I kinda want this a little more than a whole new bonus character at the end. I feel like the echo thing would end up making more fans happy in the long run as it would be more than one fanbase getting something.
 

Cutie Gwen

Lovely warrior
Joined
Jul 1, 2014
Messages
63,872
Location
Somewhere out there on this big blue marble
Heck yeah I mean 999 Junpei! I feel obligated to, at this point, plug his support thread. Maybe I should get back into RTC to rack up noms for a rating on this guy..
Perfect timing, I started nominating him
Look I know Martin is just ****posting with his math. But the color background made me think deeply about some characters and then I realized, I've been sleeping on the mother****ing Octolings. Splatoon 2 was a big hit for the Switch, and it fits with Nintendo's strategy of promoting successful first party Switch titles as DLC in Ultimate. The squid sisters miis might seem as a deconfirm at first until you realize it's a splatoon 1 mii costume and not a splatoon 2 mii costume.

They ain't no locks obviously, but if we get another first party character I'd keep my eyes on the little octopuses.
I don't know what I consider worse, Pass 2's Nintendo characters continueing to disappoint me or the fact you mispelled octopi
 

Technomage

Smash Champion
Joined
Jan 18, 2019
Messages
2,289
I'm still holding out hope for a whole echo pass right at the end man... Octolings, Impa, Dixie, Shadow, Big Boss, etc I feel would make a lot of people happy. As they're DLC, they could also get small touchups and tweaks to be more like Ken echos. Seeing them right at the end would fit how we base game usually makes semi-clone and echo characters by the end of normal development.

I kinda want this a little more than a whole new bonus character at the end. I feel like the echo thing would end up making more fans happy in the long run as it would be more than one fanbase getting something.
Plus, an Echo Pass of 4 characters could easily make a full Character Select Screen, both with stacked echoes and separated echoes (though that would exclude Classic Mode's CSS and the online's CSS). Plus, it could also fit the "CSS Limit" theory.

Also, maybe that "bonus fighter" from the URL theory actually shows ONE of the bonus characters and is still able to keep the other 3 hidden? That'd make the theory even cooler if it were true. :D
 

Rie Sonomura

fly octo fly
Joined
Jul 14, 2014
Messages
19,720
NNID
RieSonomura
Switch FC
SW-4976-7649-4666
Plus, an Echo Pass of 4 characters could easily make a full Character Select Screen, both with stacked echoes and separated echoes (though that would exclude Classic Mode's CSS and the online's CSS). Plus, it could also fit the "CSS Limit" theory.

Also, maybe that "bonus fighter" from the URL theory actually shows ONE of the bonus characters and is still able to keep the other 3 hidden? That'd make the theory even cooler if it were true. :D
Aren’t there three empty stage spots after this pass finishes tho? One of them would have to come without a stage or even be individual DLC
 

Technomage

Smash Champion
Joined
Jan 18, 2019
Messages
2,289
Aren’t there three empty stage spots after this pass finishes tho? One of them would have to come without a stage or even be individual DLC
Ah, there's a similar theory for stages, too? That sounds cool, though who's to say those three stages have to come with any of the bonus echoes? Maybe they could just be free standalones (it's been done in Smash 4)?
 
Last edited:

Yoshi-Thomas

Smash Champion
Joined
May 11, 2014
Messages
2,420
I don't have any real argument against Octolings' inclusion.
But I have a feeling that we won't get more than one unique newcomer per franchise.
Which is why I don't expect another: Mario, Pokemon, Metroid, Donkey Kong, Splatoon, Xenoblade, Arms and Animal Crossing characters (also add the third-party that already got one).
What I would really love at this point (besides Porky and Rayman) is another Zelda character that is not Link. Please.
 
D

Deleted member

Guest
Look I know Martin is just ****posting with his math. But the color background made me think deeply about some characters and then I realized, I've been sleeping on the mother****ing Octolings. Splatoon 2 was a big hit for the Switch, and it fits with Nintendo's strategy of promoting successful first party Switch titles as DLC in Ultimate. The squid sisters miis might seem as a deconfirm at first until you realize it's a splatoon 1 mii costume and not a splatoon 2 mii costume.

They ain't no locks obviously, but if we get another first party character I'd keep my eyes on the little octopuses.
Yeah Octolings fly under the radar because they’re commonly thought of as Echo candidates instead of unique fighters when they could easily be either. Octolings and Tom Nook are some of the first parties that are a bit slept on imo.
 

Technomage

Smash Champion
Joined
Jan 18, 2019
Messages
2,289
I don't have any real argument against Octolings' inclusion.
But I have a feeling that we won't get more than one unique newcomer per franchise.
Which is why I don't expect another: Mario, Pokemon, Metroid, Donkey Kong, Splatoon, Xenoblade, Arms and Animal Crossing characters (also add the third-party that already got one).
Interesting theory, though is Ken unique enough to make Street Fighter qualify for that list?
 
Last edited:

Louie G.

Smash Hero
Joined
Aug 21, 2013
Messages
9,795
Location
Rhythm Heaven
So let's talk Octoling a little bit more - if they did happen, what do you think that would entail?

For starters I imagine we'd get a Splatoon 2 stage, maybe one based on Octo Expansion. And since Splatoon 2 does have a solid amount of music in Smash as is, they could focus on Octo Expansion (obviously) and supplement with some tracks that were added later via updates.

Fly Octo Fly missing from Ultimate is a damn shame. That almost justifies Octoling on its own.

Moveset wise, I can't really say. I feel like you'd have to push Octoling to be pretty distinct from Inkling to warrant a full DLC slot, particularly with how distinct they've made every character thus far. Fortunately Splatoon offers a bunch of potential loadouts and Inkling doesn't cover any of the weapons that would be introduced in Splatoon 2. I'm not really an expert on that game, but I know the Dualies were new to Splatoon 2 and that could already make Octoling stand out quite a bit. Any other ideas?
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom