DAY 4: POLL-- Do you want Shiek as a Seperate Char. or as Part of Zelda?

[Meta_Sonic64]

Then I want you to clearly explain what the title of your thread implies or what is your definition of a separate character.

 

[Zevox]

#2 - Shiek should definitely remain a Zelda transformation.

Zevox

 

[Fatmanonice]

Then I want you to clearly explain what the title of your thread implies or what is your definition of a separate character.

This isn't my thread... Oh and what I mean is that Shiek should continue to be a part of Zelda and not be made into a seperate character or eliminated altogether.

 

[Zero s Zamus]

Sheik should be part of Zelda!!!!

 

[Wiseguy]

Option 3. Definitely, definitely, DEFINITELY option 3. Sheik sucks on every level imaginable. Death to Sheik!

 

[Zero s Zamus]

why he/She is a quick fighter ??

 

[InvincibleAgent]

I like ZekeThePlumber's idea, have them switch at the Final Smash, like Zamus. In the theoretical situation in which Sheik dominates (again), it would deny the Sheik player the ability to do a FS, or they would have to deal with being Zelda half the time.

 

[Voyager]

Sheik should be out. Just the character though, the play style and moves could be given to a new character.

 

[vesperview]

How is Zelda going to do damage transforming into Sheik? It's a terrible idea, Zelda deserves her own FS.

 

[Meta_Sonic64]

How is Zelda going to do damage transforming into Sheik? It's a terrible idea, Zelda deserves her own FS.

It's possible, though I'm too lazy to explain at this point in time.

 

[Diddy Kong]

Sheik should be out. Just the character though, the play style and moves could be given to a new character.

Like Zero Suit Samus..?

 

[KAFOR]

Sheik should be out. Just the character though, the play style and moves could be given to a new character.

I don't understand the blind hatred for Sheik. She is rather unique and deserves to return. Moreso than Roy, Dr. Mario or Pichu.

 

[EPX2]

I don't want Zelda to change at all. I can't understand why people would actually desire a unique veteran being excluded from Brawl.

 

[smashbro29]

#2 all the way!

 

[BananaNut]

Sheik shouldn't be in brawl. -- That's my vote.

I vote #3

 

[Iris]

Take her out of Brawl please. Zelda shouldn't be dependent on a 10 year old alter-ego, she's too classic.

Retain the moveset, lose the character.

 

[Mini Mic]

Separate character, she shouldn't be brought down by Zelda's suckiness

 

[Meta_Sonic64]

Separate character, she shouldn't be brought down by Zelda's suckiness

NO!!! She doesn't need to get her own space neither. That space could go to Olimar or other deserving reps

 

[dynamic_entry]

sheik is part of zelda.

i vote 2.

sakurai will make the right (#2) decision.

 

[XCWarrior]

Keep Sheik as part of Zelda. it's what made her fun to play. You could change back and forth. Gave her unique play. Definitely stay together with Zelda.

Plus Sheik by herself isn't all that cool

 

[Drake3]

Removed.

Spoiler

10chars

 

[Mad555]

should be part of zelda, it would be a waste of space if sheik got his/her own spot

 

[2.72]

Option 3, I choose you!

If they want to try to reimplement the general concept of the transformation - that is, probably, a character with one form that can combo and one that can kill - they should do it with

Spoiler

Tetra

. There are way too many good Zelda reps to waste space on Sheik. WW Link, Midna, Wolf Link, Midna + Wolf Link, WW

Spoiler

Zelda/Tetra

(not a popular choice, but I actually think that it would be good), Zant (another unpopular choice), and Vaati. Oh, and the Skull Kid.

Notice that I didn't mention Tingle there. That was intentional. I would rather have Saria than Tingle. For that matter, I can come up with all manner of things that would be better playable characters than Tingle. My alarm clock, for an example.

 

[vesperview]

Option 3, I choose you!

If they want to try to reimplement the general concept of the transformation - that is, probably, a character with one form that can combo and one that can kill - they should do it with Tetra. There are way too many good Zelda reps to waste space on Sheik. WW Link, Midna, Wolf Link, Midna + Wolf Link, WW Zelda/Tetra (not a popular choice, but I actually think that it would be good), Zant (another unpopular choice), and Vaati. Oh, and the Skull Kid.

Notice that I didn't mention Tingle there. That was intentional. I would rather have Saria than Tingle. For that matter, I can come up with all manner of things that would be better playable characters than Tingle. My alarm clock, for an example.

You think Sheik shouldn't return but you think Skull Kid and Zant are better Zelda reps?

 

[bigman40]

Shiek needs the be a part of Zelda. Having her own space is a waste, and her move set fitted with zeldas. Plus, that would mean one less different character if that happens (meaning that someone won't get their character in ssbb).

 

[2.72]

EDIT[in response to Vesperview]Yes, I do.

Sheik is not even terribly important to her own game, nor to the storyline over all, nor is she terribly interesting mechanically. Skull Kid has one game as the main villain and has serious potential mechanically speaking. That's not much, but more than Sheik ever had. At this point, he/she/it is more a representation of the disfunctional parts of SSBM than the Zelda franchise. Zant is just a personal favorite of mine. I doubt that he'll be playable, and I can't really explain why I like him, but I think that he would be better than Sheik.

This is more my preference than anything else. I understand that.

 

[vesperview]

Skull Kid is not the main villain in Majora's Mask is the Mask who the main villain is, Skull Kid would be more a waste than Sheik, and Sheik is a waste.

 

[Iris]

Bad 2.72, bad! No more opinions or honest preferences for you!

I don't see how Sheik is at all a part of Zelda. It happened in ONE GAME. That's like saying Tanooki Suits were vital to Mario's development. Hopefully Sakurai realizes that her character extends far beyond a one-time alter-ego and will give her something a little more fit for the universal Zelda.

 

[Collective of Bears]

Shiek sucks, and he/she/it shouldn't be in brawl.

 

[Katy Parry]

#2 All the way. Zelda=Shiek.

 

[Iris]

Really? Just for the record, have you played any Zelda games in the last century?

 

[celsosalo]

Midna:

Was besides Link, the main character of Twilight Princess. Warning for those who haven't played TP yet, this will contain some spoilers! The game was basically called after Midna, her being the princess of the Twilight Realm and all. Through the game, Midna's personality is changing a lot, and she even does some fighting in cutscenes. As proven a lot of times by people who have a more creative brain / more time to spent on SWF Midna could easily have a very unique moveset solo or riding Link in wolf form. Besides, she's a character that would add some diversity in the cast in something the series in lacking in; magic users.

I think having MIdna would be better than having shiek basically because I love Midna and because she could have tons of moves based on Twilight Princess.

 

[UberBob]

#2

First of all, shiek as a seperate character would be wasting a space for a different character, possibly a good Legend of Zelda representative (Zant, WW Link, Midna). Also, shiek and zelda are the SAME PERSON. It wouldn't make sense to have two different characters. Yes Link and young link might be the same person, but they're in two different points of time.

 

[Mogrika]

Number 3, I feel Sheik has had her time.

 

[Katy Parry]

Really? Just for the record, have you played any Zelda games in the last century?

Last century....I believe OoT came out last century...I believe SSBM is this century, too.

 

[celsosalo]

#2

First of all, shiek as a seperate character would be wasting a space for a different character, possibly a good Legend of Zelda representative (Zant, WW Link, Midna). Also, shiek and zelda are the SAME PERSON. It wouldn't make sense to have two different characters. Yes Link and young link might be the same person, but they're in two different points of time.

thats true and anyways why don't they do one of those Final Samsh attacks or whatever you call them and then make her tranform into shiek or some thing, like the did with Samus.

 

[Mogrika]

Sheik is still wasting space in the disc memory, she should be cut altogether.

 

[celsosalo]

I know but if they're going to keep shiek then they should probably do that. Thats what i think

 

[Timekeeper]

Shiek should be cut.

 

[celsosalo]

I doesn't matter to me if Shiek is cut or not because BRAWL is going to be the best game ever