I do want to bring up some discussion with the thread here since there isn't going to be anything particularly notable for a while now.
We are now currently at the point in the meta where it is now pretty up for debate on who exactly is the best character in the game. Not "who is among the best characters in the game". Who is the best character in the game.
If we were talking about late 2021 and January 2022, we would easily say Aegis, but it seems that the era of fearmongering Aegis domination has ceased ever since. Ever since then, there has been debate on who exactly is #1 in the game.
There are many different ways to look at this:
We have characters that has been statistically strong for a long time.
and
have been by far the most historically statically strong characters since the post-quarantine era, with not only strong tournament representation, but some very notable top player presence as well. The latter thing was a glaring issue with R.O.B. results for a long time, but now we have players like Zomba and BigBoss placing highly in national tournaments.
Do note that there are also other statistically strong characters as well, such as
,
, and
, the former of which is currently ahead in the #1 position in the TTS, but unlike the above-mentioned two, no one is really arguing that these three are best character contenders. You could argue top 5 contenders (in which I think Palu potentially is), but not #1.
This brings up another way to look at: the strong point characters. The main two I want to talk about is
and
. These two characters, while they definitely have a good amount of reps, definitely is not quite as popular as other top characters, as Fox is #13 in the TTS and Wario is #16 (w/ PkMn Trainer) in the TTS. However, the absolute domination that Light and Glutonny has demonstrated the past several months is immaculate. It is no secret that Fox and Wario has been already proven to be very great characters historically throughout Ultimate's life, but both characters has been pushed further than ever before (post-nerf in the case for Wario).
At one point, MkLeo and Glutonny even agreed that Wario is in a better spot in the meta than Aegis even is. Not sure if that opinion has changed since, but that is fairly notable.
That being said, these two characters being very strong in the current meta is not an unpopular opinion. Them being potentially character in the game worthy is a very unpopular opinion, however, especially in Fox's case.
Now we turn to our third way to look at it: those with a mix of both. Now we look at
. The character hasn't dominated major events the way people projected them to much earlier this year, with other characters showing stronger dominance. At the same time, the character hasn't topped the result charts statically the same way characters like R.O.B., Roy, and Palutena has. What the Aegis brings to the table here, is still being among the upper echelon of both categories.
While Leo and Sparg0 mostly dropped the character, the character still receives very good high level representation from players like Cosmos and Shuton, while still being a very popular character in tournaments (especially in mid-level play).
And we can look beyond what they have been doing in tournaments to see that they fundamentally have the tools needed to succeed in any level. That is what makes them a popular candidate for #1 in the game, especially back during the character's glory days. That being said, the character definitely felt a bit of a drop off in terms of presence, thus the position of #1 in the game have once again became muddled.
Our fourth and final way to look at it is characters that we know that may be #1, but hasn't shown that right now.
is still a very strong character in competitive. While his high level representation has gone down since 2019, we will have good top level representation, namely from Zackray. There is of course other good Joker players, but he currently leads the charge. The character is also very popular in mid-level play, in a similar vein to the above-mentioned Aegis. #11 in the TTS is nothing to scoff at.
However, Joker's case is quite unfortunate. The characters major drop-off in the results came with MkLeo, for the most part, dropping the character after Smash Con: Fall Fest. This is not because the character has gotten much weaker in Leo's eyes (he believes Joker to be very strong too), but he simply doesn't find enjoyment with the character anymore.
Back when MkLeo dominated most of 2019 with Joker, there was no other character in the game's history that as undisputedly #1 as Joker.
At the same time, it is hard to argue that the character has definitely seen better days, especially in lieu of characters that has far exceeded him in tournament presence ever since.
As you can see overall, there are numerous different factors that determine who will claim the coveted #1 title in the game. A lot of it ends up resulting in which of these factors you value the most.
And it is something I like quite a lot. In the previous Smash games, it was quite clear who was #1 in each entry.
In Smash 64, Pikachu was the #1 character since the beginning.
In Melee, Sheik dominated early Melee with the chaingrabs, but ever since numerous tech-skills has been discovered and implemented, Fox became the undisputed #1 character to this day. There has been talks the past two years of Marth or Puff potentially surpassing Fox, but I don't think that really got anywhere.
In Brawl, outside of the first month of the game, it was quite clear that Meta Knight has the god of the game.
In SSB4, throughout the numerous balance patches of the game, there has always been a clear #1 in the game. When we left the goofy 3DS era, Diddy was seen to be the #1 character easily. After he got nerfed, Sheik was the undisputed queen of the game. After Sheik got nerfed in 1.1.5, and Bayo shortly afterwards in 1.1.6, SSB4 entered a time period where the title of #1 was very up-in-the-air, but it was only really narrowed down to Diddy or Cloud. Once Bayo reclaimed the throne over a year later after the nerfs, she was there to stay.
Now in modern Ultimate, we have now entered an era where it really is up for grabs. We had the Joker era back in 2019, and briefly the Aegis era in late 2021 and January 2022, but both eras have passed. I would like to see what you guy's two cents is in this topic, because I think it really comes down to what the individual values the most. Of course, your individual opinion on the character will also come into play as well.