Anthony Higgs isn't even part of this discussion! Man, how do you expect to take you seriously like this? I already said: Anthony Higgs was just FAR MORE likely than Ridley, NEVER more deserving. Ridley, in fact,
never was likely since the moment Pyro Sphere came up.
And I also said: Anthony Higg's chances have basically been killed off once the Gunner Miifighter showed up. So long for a Metroid newcomer!
Ghirahim is as much of an one-off as Anthony Higgs is. I cannot keep on a discussion about how a long lasting, soon to be playable character in the franchise >>> a one-off villain in a series that has a
10.000 or so of these. Example: Majora, Yuga, Nightmare, Zant, Bellum...
However, Anthony Higgs has one advantage: Metroid has an EXTREMELY ****ty supporting cast. And seeing as side-kicks often make it in before villains, and Ridley was in an extremely bad situation (and still is), what is a man to do who would like to see a Metroid character? Support the Mysterious Black Man. Especially since Samus is in Other M design.
*sigh* Why do I have to explain
logic?
Impa is not as re-occuring as Ganon, no of course not. But there's a reason they went with Ganon
DORF in the first place : it's Ganon but in humanoid form. It just suits much better as a fighter, and Ganon has been Ganondorf's Final Smash since Brawl. IT WILL VERY LIKELY REMAIN HIS FINAL SMASH. I won't explain why, as I also already did this before.
Then there's also the 2 Links, 2 Zeldas, 2 Ganons fiasco. It just looks ugly.
Impa is easily the best Zelda character suited for Smash left. She wasn't announced in Hyrule Warriors as a 2nd character for nothing! In fact, Nintendo has shown interesst in having a female protagonist in Zelda. With the rate Impa is going now, it might very well be her one day. Especially if Hyrule Warrios is to become a success. And with playable Zelda, and the return of Ganondorf... I think a lot of Zelda fans would really love to play it! It's like the ultimate fan-service game for Zelda fans. Canon or not, it's popularity is the only thing what will count in the end.
Also the fact they seem to go for a more stabilised design for Impa is a good sign for her as a re-occuring character in Zelda. Just check this image:
Impa has had a revival role in Skyward Sword, and is likely there to stay. I say she should be welcomed in Smash because of this!