If Vinyl was scum, Vinyl would have pushed for Kantrip's lynch after the Census Taker ability was used because he would have known that Kantrip was the Indy after Kantrip claimed jailer; he would have known that Kantrip was the liar in the entire dilemma because Kantrip had no reason to still be alive after being shot if he was really the jailer. Furthermore, Vinyl's Census Taker ability was too accurate; no one counter claimed machine when there was only one machine in the game (Rake), thus we can safely assume it is a legit role. Finally, if you analyze the role itself, you'll notice that scumVinyl would have ended up putting 194 at risk because 194 was an animal. This could have severely hurt scumVinyl's own faction because there was a good chance that 194 would have been forced to be lynched before Kantrip, forcing a theoretical domino effect that would result in lynch after lynch until the non-animal was caught. Really, the role is meant to capture scum and is the definite town investigative of this set up. Anyone still thinking Vinyl is scum after his ability use is either scum or dumb...or both.
I haven't decided where I want to go yet after JD's flip, but if JD flips scum and the game isn't over, BSP/Riddle/RR are obviously on my hit list, RR/BSP before Riddle. Reasoning is that Riddle isn't that scummy despite the "connections" claim he made earlier about my slot. Seemed more like he was talking out of his *** because frankly I don't see myself really being connected to 194 in a scummy way, but I'm guessing he was just trying to fuel his own paranoia of my slot more than anything else. Either way, I still want Riddle to explain himself in that regard. Riddle also isn't scummily connected to JD/194, so I feel comfortable with this route. RR would be the first one I'd hardbody because he's trying to stall the lynch again just like he did with 194, he's also scummily connected to 194 and man I'd just love to hardbody that slot. BSP has more or less been sitting on his hands and not being pro-town for a majority of the game, but I don't really see him as being connected to JD in a scummy fashion. I'd probably go RR > BSP > Riddle once push comes to shove.
