Boondock Saints Mafia(Day 5 begins)

[mentosman8]

Vote Count!
Forever Zero(4): Moronik, Blue Yoshi, Macman, Gheb_01,
Activity:

Feb 6
Blue Yoshi

Feb 5
Moronik
Magnificentmarth
Macman
Bunglefever
Gheb_01

Inactive
Forever Zero
Cacti

Cacti and Forever Zero have been prodded! Deadline is Sunday, February 14, at 11:59PM central!

 

[~Radiance~]

yup, no arguing with jurisdiction like this.
kill me and get your day over with.

 

[DtJ Jungle]

not even going to claim to save youreslf?

vote F0

 

[~ Gheb ~]

Vig shoot scumfever if F0 flips town plz.

 

[Moronik]

/endor se

 

[Moronik]

Night 1 was Rainezumi.

really? why?

 

[Trillion]

It was a guess at who the wolves might target. Raine had been somewhat town looking to me and so I figured that there were people who looked more town that would probably get doc protection. The wolves in attempt to avoid a failed night kill would hit someone who looked somewhat pro-town instead. Thus, Raine seemed like a decent choice.

 

[#HBC | Mac]

why scumf over cacti?

 

[#HBC | Mac]

oh wow, it took 5 to lynch.

not a scummy hammer at all JF

 

[mentosman8]

Final D3 Vote Count!
Forever Zero(5): Moronik, Blue Yoshi, Macman, Gheb_01, Bunglefever

Not voting: magnificentmarth, Cacti, Forever Zero

The group made their decision quickly this time. With both brothers dying from the groups decision the day before, they decided to make those who didn't agree their focus. They quickly turned on one, and began questioning them, and when they put the pressure on, there was a crack.

"I won't argue. You took away my sons. Just kill me."

The group recognized the face of Il Duce, also known as Noah McManus, the father of the brothers, the Boondock Saints. The group quickly converged on Noah and put a bullet through his head. As Noah fell to the ground, the group still didn't feel at ease.

Forever Zero(Noah McManus, mafia goon) has been killed!

"There's still an enemy among us... We may have taken out those Irish bastards, but it appears there's still someone who was working with them, or at least not for us."

The group retired for the night, deciding to make sure there was an enemy still among them before progressing.

Night 3 begins! Actions due Tuesday, February 9th at 11:59 PM central!

 

[mentosman8]

The group convened in the room again. Everyone looked excited as they walked in.

"We've done it! those bastard Saints are done for!"

They begin to chat idly about their success, when they notice someone is missing.

"But... How!?"

They sweep the room trying to figure out who is missing. With a shock, they notice the one they had been calling Macman was missing.

They went to the room that had been in use, and find Macman(Rosengurtle Baumgartner, town doublevoter) dead on the floor. The kill wasn't as clean as when Augustus had died, but quite clearly someone was still a threat.

"Well, time to finish this everyone."

Day 4 begins! With 6 alive, it takes 4 to lynch! Deadline is Saturday, February 20th at 11:59PM central time!

 

[Moronik]

MM, report now. Also, anyone who hasn't been scum before, I want to know that too. If you have been scum tell me where, and if it was here, with whom.

~Ronike

 

[#HBC | Mac]

lalallllala

 

[DtJ Jungle]

Scum in Monster Island and HP.

 

[Moronik]

thats nice. whos scum?

 

[Trillion]

MM, report now. Also, anyone who hasn't been scum before, I want to know that too. If you have been scum tell me where, and if it was here, with whom.

~Ronike

My view of Gheb was not successful. I actually really considered viewing Macman, but I figured that people had suspected him over the Ryker hammer thing enough that the mafia would leave him alive so that they could push his lynch.

Why does it matter about people who have and haven't been scum where and etc?

I've been scum several times on AiB and BoardGameGeek.com. I suppose you probably know Mayling and Delvro (and a few others maybe?) who I have noticed have played here on SWF and also with me on AiB. I played one game in particular with both of them where I was mafia.

 

[Moronik]

are you serious? people would consider macman as scum even though like every scum flipped cast suspicion on him over that hammer and tried to get him lynched?

and it matters for meta purposes

and your action failed even though a scum flipped roleblocker. and you watched raine n1 even though he was scummy as hell...what

 

[Trillion]

are you serious? people would consider macman as scum even though like every scum flipped cast suspicion on him over that hammer and tried to get him lynched?

and it matters for meta purposes

and your action failed even though a scum flipped roleblocker. and you watched raine n1 even though he was scummy as hell...what

I didn't remember who cast suspicion on him. I supposed I should have checked. I thought Gheb was a better person to watch though. Yesterday, he was the first person to pick out the 4 people who were not part of Day 2's lynch and that ended up resulting in a mafia lynch. IMO, that made him look pretty much town and I figured the mafia would think so too making him a great target.


I figured you meant for meta purposes, I was just checking.

Yes, my action failed again. 3 nights in a row now. The first day I didn't think Raine was looking very scummy. My suspicions had him relatively dead center on my list.

 

[Blue Yoshi]

Well, here is who voted for who at the end of each day. Blue means voted for town, red means voted for scum, yellow means voted for unknown (still alive), white means did not vote.


......................................... Day 1 ......................................... Day 2 .......................................... Day 3

Blue Yoshi: .......................... No vote ...................................... SS ............................................. F0

Bunglefever: ....................... Ryker ......................................... No vote ...................................... F0

Cacti: ................................ Ryker ......................................... Macman ....................................... No vote

Gheb: ............................... Cacti ........................................... SS ............................................... F0

magnificentmarth: .............. KevinM ...................................... KevinM .......................................... No vote

Moronik: ............................. Ryker ........................................ SS ................................................ F0

I only included people who are still alive.

So according to this, the only two who have not voted for scum yet are magnificentmarth and Cacti, and both have voted for now confirmed town twice.

So that said:

Vote: magnificentmarth

Three nights in a row where you were apparently roleblocked, when the scum roleblocker has been removed. I would say that your claim is fake at this point.

 

[Blue Yoshi]

Actually, thinking about it, I think it would be useful to see who scum voted for as well.

......................................... Day 1 ......................................... Day 2 .......................................... Day 3

SS: ...................................Ryker ...................................... Macman

Chaco: .............................. Ryker ......................................... Macman

F0: ................................... Cacti ......................................... Cacti ....................................... No vote

Same legend as before.

Well, this semi-clears Cacti, meaning I'm fully in support of a magnificentmarth lynch.

 

[DtJ Jungle]

hmmm

would anyone else be down for a mass claim?

 

[Blue Yoshi]

what do you mean by mass claim? Like everyone says who they are?

 

[~ Gheb ~]

Why would we massclaim now of all times? We already have a claimed watcher who got roleblocked every night so far and a dead doublevoter. Assuming MM tells us the truth about being blocked then I don't see why we would reveal other PRs? There's been no signs whatsoever of a doctor or other investigators. It's better to not out them.
Additionally I'd like to mention that we already lynched 3 scumbags and we're not lacking any information so a mass claim would not help at all.

Vote Cacti

 

[Moronik]

I didn't remember who cast suspicion on him. I supposed I should have checked. I thought Gheb was a better person to watch though. Yesterday, he was the first person to pick out the 4 people who were not part of Day 2's lynch and that ended up resulting in a mafia lynch. IMO, that made him look pretty much town and I figured the mafia would think so too making him a great target.

i guess youre talking about ghebs 280? can you please tell me how the **** naming like half the game for a scumlist is more pro-town than the momentum us/blue yoshi pushed towards f0s lynch before that post? plus gheb was near the end of the wagon?

this is getting hard to believe which is terrible since youre the only claimed investigative role meaning you should be easy to trust but youre not

also n1 you watched raine cuz he was middle of the road and a convoluted thought process where youre trying to outguess the doc...then why didnt you do that nights 2 and 3?

vote cacti

~marshy

 

[Trillion]

Three nights in a row where you were apparently roleblocked, when the scum roleblocker has been removed. I would say that your claim is fake at this point.

I admit that it seems really unlikely, but all I can say is that I am the only player who has claimed a detection type role so far, so I am the obvious target for roleblockers. I agree that it seems incredibly unlikely that there are multiple roleblockers, but if that is not the case, then I have no idea how I am still failing.

 

[Trillion]

i guess youre talking about ghebs 280? can you please tell me how the **** naming like half the game for a scumlist is more pro-town than the momentum us/blue yoshi pushed towards f0s lynch before that post? plus gheb was near the end of the wagon?

this is getting hard to believe which is terrible since youre the only claimed investigative role meaning you should be easy to trust but youre not

also n1 you watched raine cuz he was middle of the road and a convoluted thought process where youre trying to outguess the doc...then why didnt you do that nights 2 and 3?

vote cacti

~marshy

The bandwagon didn't really start until after Ghebs made his post. So, I figured, since he seemed to have been the main turning point where the lynch really picked up, that he would be a good target. Plus, you said something about my failure being confirmed.

As for the Raine thing, it was Night 1, I didn't have as much to go on, but I wasn't trying to outguess the doc, I was trying to outguess the wolves and guess their target. I figured they might go for someone who didn't look to be for sure town to avoid the doc, but didn't look entirely mafia that they couldn't push his lynch the next day.

Night 2, I thought you because you seemed to be making progress for the town and might be a good target for the wolves, but then you said that my failure to see you was somehow confirmed??

Night 3, I figured that they might hit Ghebs for reasons explained and since you seemed to think it made sense that I failed when viewing you, that I would try someone else.

I know that I am hard to believe after 3 failed nights in a row. All I can say is that you said something about my failure on viewing you making sense and that I've been the only investigator to claim, so I'm the obvious role blocker target. How there is still another role blocker out there is beyond me, unless this is some kind of lasting effect, but other than that, I have no idea.

 

[Moronik]

Wait, so you have been roleblocke every night? Are you sure>

~Ronike

 

[Trillion]

detect immune roles arent common here mm. your claim checks out tho. whod you watch n1?

You said my claim checks out, why?

 

[Trillion]

Wait, so you have been roleblocke every night? Are you sure>

~Ronike

I've not yet received a result for my role. I've been told in three different ways that I was not receiving a result.

N1 - I was hit with a toilet (sorry I said toilet seat before, but looked back and it was the whole toilet, not that I think it makes that big of difference). It left me unconcious

N2 - It failed to complete

N3 - It was not successful


From the 3 different descriptions, it almost looks as though I was blocked in 3 different ways or something. UNLESS, and this is a possibility that just occurred to me, it could mean that some of the times I failed were not because I was blocked, but because the person I watched did not have a night action.

 

[Moronik]

hmmm the night 1 & 2 results makes sense to me but i got nothing for n3. the n3 result might be that no one visited your target but id expect "no one visited x" as opposed to "it was unsuccessful." shave away the claim and i wanna say that youre not aligned with scum considering how they pounced on you day 1. this is just from memory though and me/ronike badly need to reread. i dont want to explain why your n2 result makes sense to me yet. more later after i talk to mentos and my other half

also what character are you?

blue a massclaim is everyone stating their role and character

bungle why did you hammer without a claim and why arent you letting everyone where your head is at? youve been depriving us of good info

*waits half a week for a cacti post*

~marshy

 

[Moronik]

holy **** cacti didnt post once during d3

 

[DtJ Jungle]

yup, no arguing with jurisdiction like this.
kill me and get your day over with.

he was conceding to die, if he wanted to claim he could've right here.

 

[Moronik]

ok. also for like the third time whos scum?

also were down for a massclaim and call dibs on going last and picking first since we prefer popcorn

so whos /in or /out for it?

~marshy

 

[DtJ Jungle]

I'm down for it.

For your scum question, i'd have to relook over everything, but first people that pop to mind is Cacti. Cacti because he's coasting hardcore, generally useless when he does post.

MM's claim concerns me a little, but not really enough to call him scum

Gheb seems town to me right now. Blue Yoshi..I don't know here. I can't tell if he's just really new or he's scum, but I'm feeling new right now.

 

[Blue Yoshi]

Well, I guess I'll start the mass role claim (and to save Cacti).

I am the cop (funny Man Rocco).

N1, I checked Macman (dead now). Obviously, he was not scum.

N2, I checked Cacti. He was not scum.

N3, I checked Gheb. He was not scum.

Last night, I semi-mind-gamed myself. Before the night, I had me, Macman, and Cacti all confirmed not scum, and if Gheb was also town, that would be four people confirmed not scum in a 6 person game. But unfortunately, Macman got nightkilled, meaning I'm at 3 v 3.

If people want proof of me being the cop, check day 3. People were split between F0 and Cacti. I said right away that I would prefer a F0 lynch (since Cacti was not scum).

So, the three people who are still here who I have not checked are Moronik, magnificentmarth, and Bunglefever.

So going back to my voting chart, here are the three left:

......................................... Day 1 ......................................... Day 2 .......................................... Day 3

Bunglefever: ....................... Ryker ......................................... No vote ...................................... F0

magnificentmarth: .............. KevinM ...................................... KevinM .......................................... No vote

Moronik: ............................. Ryker ........................................ SS ................................................ F0

Re-thinking it, bunglefever voting F0 was probably an easy way to not look scummy. mag.marth has yet to vote for scum. Moronik voted for two scum people, so I think it's safe to say he's out.

So now I would say it's between magnificentmarth and Bunglefever (though Moronik is still slightly there).

 

[Blue Yoshi]

thoughts?

And I think people should unvote Cacti before we get a mis-lynch.

 

[Moronik]

pretty sad you investigated macman

hm cacti was a good choice but im surprised you picked gheb n3 when he was early on the sibling wagon

we think bungle should claim in his next post

unvote for now

~marshy

 

[Blue Yoshi]

As I said, I didn't think it through properly, and hought if I had another town check, I'd have 4 of 6 confirmed town... which didn't end up being the case (I wanted a town read).

 

[Moronik]

mod: is cacti in range of being modkilled? he hasnt posted in like 10 days and hes probably missed the "post within 2 days" rule other times as well

~marshy

 

[DtJ Jungle]

I'm Ivan Chekov, vanilla townie