Boondock Saints Mafia(Day 5 begins)

[#HBC | Mac]

prolly wudda hammered anyways if i knew tht he'd get modkilled

but i mean, i understand the suspicion but i can't really say anything else that I already haven't been said

 

[CT Chia]

doesnt make sense

if u would have known he would have gotten modkilled, then u know he would have been a confirmed townie, and yet you would have hammered anyway?

 

[Blue Yoshi]

Well, first off, sorry for the few posts on my part (though thinking about it, there is very little conversation, so everyone is guilty of this I suppose?). I just don't have as much computer access as I would have liked (for dumb reasons).

Anyways, the deadline is 4 days away (Feb 4th). I know Macman's hammer is strange, but I think we should move on and discuss other stuff as well. Is there anyone or anything else that people find suspiscious that's worth discussion (while we still have the time before the day is over)?

I'm not saying we should forget what he did, I'm just saying that for the purpose of getting somewhere, we should move on. Because as far as I can see, discussing this anymore will get us nowhere fast.

 

[Trillion]

doesnt make sense

if u would have known he would have gotten modkilled, then u know he would have been a confirmed townie, and yet you would have hammered anyway?

I'm not sure what I think of Macman.

But I understand what he is saying. He wouldn't have let Ryker's claim influence how he would have otherwise acted as a principle of ethical game play. A similar issue has come up on other places I have played, such as some players who think that all reveals violate game ethics.

 

[#HBC | Mac]

im not down with modkills tht don't end the day, so i wud have hammered just to make it a lynch.

but tht didn't even go through my mind cuz i didn't immediately register the color.

can't believe deadline is 4 days away

what do people think about SS?

 

[Moronik]

Vote Count!
Cacti: Moronik, Rainezumi
SquirtleSquad: Macman, Gheb_01
KevinM: magnificentmarth
Macman: ChiboSempai, SquirtleSquad
Bunglefever: Cacti, Blue Yoshi
Blue Yoshi: KevinM

Well, deadline's a few days away, and this votecount is waaay too spread out. Raine, I no longer want to lynch Cacti. So who will you vote? MM, we're not lynching Kevin today. Blue Yoshi, are you serious? Vote someone else. I also think Bunglefever is a bad lynch today and don't see why people are going for him at all.

Offhand, I want to say that my suspicions align with Kevin's meaning Blue Yoshi or SquirtleSquad can go today. I'm going to speak with my other half and place a vote down soon. Marshy, you can feel free to place our vote elsewhere if you'd like. Nonvoters and spread-out voters step it up to give us time should we need to switch our votes.

I also feel like we won't get much from Macman's lynch if he flips town and think we can do better.

Unvote Cacti

~Ronike

 

[Moronik]

2. The players may majority vote for a deadline extension. This can only be done once.

And don't forget about this rule. Others down use it today?

~Ronike

 

[Trillion]

MM, we're not lynching Kevin today.

I honestly don't see why not. He hasn't done much at all this entire game. Now that I haven't been turning the town's eyes back to him, he has been lurking and not at all saying anything new.

 

[Trillion]

still down with ss. Didn't really like his post since it didn't give us much of anything. [admittedly, I didn't look into this Gheb thing, so maybe ill do that now] Not tht suspect of raine anymore. Think jungle is town. Moronik twn, kevinm town. Chibo is iuno, its hard for me to ever pin down is alignment. i wanna lean scum, but i feel like its the same scumvibe i got from him in monster. BY i don't think i can ever really think he's suspect. everyone else, probably scum cuz i don't remember them

/useless post

I would also like to point out that nobody jumped all over MacMan's back when he made a suspicion list.

He gave a flat out opinion about SS, Raine, Jungle, Moronik, Kevin, Chibo, BY, and to some degree Gheb. That's 8 names and then he made a generality statement about everyone else.

To those of you who attacked me based on the suspicion list that I made on Day 1, why are you not doing so to Macman as well? Surely the same argument that was leveled at me should also hold true here if that is truly your belief about game strategy.

 

[CT Chia]

Lol Macman, rly? You say you would rather hammer than have him be modkilled and yet you had no idea that he could potentially be modkilled since you claim the color didn't even register to you. You can't use the potential modkill point as a cover up for your hammer either. As I just mentioned the color didn't register to you, meaning you had no reason to think that he might be modkilled, and the first mentioning of that possibly being a modkillable offense wasn't until Kevin mentioned it multiple posts after you hammered Mac.

Deadlines close, and I personally haven't seen a slip up bigger than this yet, so my vote's not budging.

 

[Cacti]

Unvote Vote: Macman

 

[Moronik]

I would also like to point out that nobody jumped all over MacMan's back when he made a suspicion list.

He gave a flat out opinion about SS, Raine, Jungle, Moronik, Kevin, Chibo, BY, and to some degree Gheb. That's 8 names and then he made a generality statement about everyone else.

To those of you who attacked me based on the suspicion list that I made on Day 1, why are you not doing so to Macman as well? Surely the same argument that was leveled at me should also hold true here if that is truly your belief about game strategy.

tbqh i dont like macmans game to start. hard to read for me and often plays some weird *** moves. that being said hes been around a long *** time and if he hasnt changed his style yet after being told other times i dont see why i should waste my time. i was telling you and ryker in hopes of changing your style at least here not in order to point out you were scummy.

i disagree with my other head that we should use the extender. want to save it. would rather just go off a lurker who even when he posts gives me bad vibes.

Vote: SS

i encourage you all to follow suit. at the very least maybe we can get them posting.

~marshy

 

[#HBC | Mac]

ill clear myself if i get to l-1

not drunk

 

[Blue Yoshi]

Agreed. SS needs to speak up.

Vote: SS

 

[KevinM]

I sure do like wagons :D

Unvote
Vote SS

You guys done being wurst **** town/scum ever?

 

[Moronik]

ScumSquad's -1. Hold that hammer. Claim time.

~Ronike

 

[Trillion]

I sure do like wagons :D

Unvote
Vote SS

You guys done being wurst **** town/scum ever?

You were the first to tell me that making lists is bad. Why didn't you say anything to MacMan?

 

[~Radiance~]

sorry i havtn been on in a while gais. school has been eating my life like a fat kid eats cake. will post later, have class in 5 mins -_-

 

[KevinM]

You were the first to tell me that making lists is bad. Why didn't you say anything to MacMan?

Stop being bitter he didn't do what you did.

 

[Trillion]

Stop being bitter he didn't do what you did.

Again, with the name calling. I'm not being bitter. You are again trying to tear down my argument with an ad hominem attack. When a player does not behave the same way towards people, then there is obviously something strange going on. He did the same thing as what I did and you have not said anything to him. IMO, if MacMan is lynched and flips mafia, then it is just even more reason to believe that you are aligned with him.

 

[Blue Yoshi]

Just pointing it out... Since January 14th (where Squirtle Squad made 7 posts that day), Squirtle Squad has only made 2 posts in this game... one on Jan 20th, and one on Jan 29th. It's already been more than 2 days since they last posted.

 

[mentosman8]

Vote Count!
Cacti(1): Forever Zero
SquirtleSquad(6): Macman, Gheb_01, Moronik, Blue Yoshi, KevinM
KevinM(1): magnificentmarth
Macman(3): ChiboSempai, SquirtleSquad, Cacti
Not Voting: Bunglefever

Activity:
Feb. 1
Magnificentmarth
KevinM
Forever Zero
Moronik
Blue Yoshi

Jan 31
Macman
Cacti
Chibo

Jan 30
Gheb

Inactive:
Bunglefever(sickness noted as temp V/LA)
SquirtleSquad

The group debated amongst themselves. They first turned their fingers toward the man who had made the final decision to kill Vladdy the day before. He argued that he didn't notice the point that made others think it was obvious he wasn't one of the Saints. As time wound on more and more support grew on him. Suddenly, it shifted to another. A man who had kept in the shadows the majority of the time the target this time. People supported taking him out in force, and before anyone knew it, they were attacking him. The man stayed silent as the group attacked him, and eventually he lay on the floor dead. The group looked closely at him, to realize he was, in fact, one of the Saints.

As the group got excited about the turn of events, and taking out one of the Saints, they heard a rageful roar from the back of the room. They turned in time to see Connor's brother, Murphy, drawing his guns with tears in his eyes. Everyone jumped behind cover as bullets started flying wildly. Murphy was clearly so distraught his usual ability was gone. When he ran out of bullets, falling to his knees, a man stood and fired one of his own right through Murphy's head.

Connor McManus(mafia thief, sibling)(SquirtleSquad) has been lynched!
Murphy McManus(mafia roleblocker, sibling)(ChiboSempai) has died in a vengeful rage!

Night 2 begins, all actions due by 11:59PM central time on Wednesday, February 3rd!

 

[mentosman8]

D3 Start!

The morning greets you as you hear from another room the words "Spiritu Sancte" followed by the sound of gunfire.

Everyone rushes back into the main room.

"Time to get back to work... Wait a minute, we're missing someone."

They begin to take stock of who all is there, and realize that the man they had been calling KevinM was missing. They hurried to his room. Inside they found his several bodyguards laying on the ground, each with their arms folded across their chest and pennies placed over their closed eyes.

"Yeah, it was the work of Saints. Let's go make sure they got their target."

They walk around the room, and find KevinM's body laying in his bed. His eyes have both been shot out, and like the others, his eyes have been covered with pennies. Upon closer inspection, you discover that this man was Augustus(vanilla townie).

"Whatever is carrying on their plans, we're going to take them down!"

Day 3 begins! With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch! Deadline for Day 3 is Sunday, February 14th at 11:59 PM central time!

 

[Trillion]

Last night my action failed. Night 1, I was specifically told that I was hit with the toilet seat and was knocked out resulting in me missing my action. This time, I simply failed.

My first guess is that I failed due to a person's role. Perhaps, the person I tried to watch was an individual third party of some kind? I find it unlikely that I would have been stopped by anything else since the thief and role blocker are both dead.

Thoughts? Should I reveal the person I attempted to watch? Does anyone have a better explanation of how I failed?

 

[Blue Yoshi]

I don't know eactly how the watcher works, but if you tried to watch KevinM, he got nightkilled... maybe meaning watching him fails? (since he's dead)?

Just a guess (which is probably wrong...)

 

[Trillion]

I don't know eactly how the watcher works, but if you tried to watch KevinM, he got nightkilled... maybe meaning watching him fails? (since he's dead)?

Just a guess (which is probably wrong...)

It wasn't Kevin.

 

[Blue Yoshi]

ok then. ignore my post

 

[Blue Yoshi]

Well then... time for a post that actually has some use.

Seeing as voting SS resulted in the death of two mafia members, I find it very unlikely that a mafia member would have been voting SS. So that said, here is the list of everyone still in this game who did not vote for SS:

Forever Zero (voted Cacti)
magnificentmarth (voted KevinM)
Cacti (voted Macman)
Bunglefever (did not vote).

So, in my opinion, one of these four would be the best course of action (I just posted these people in the order they appeared on Mentos's last votecount, so there is no bias in the order).

 

[#HBC | Mac]

id rather go with cactus

vote: cacti

 

[Blue Yoshi]

uh... ronike... where did your post go?

 

[Moronik]

mm im calling you out. i dont like that youve now had 2 nights of no info no matter if it does make sense. id like to know who you have investigated. id also like to know who you think is suspicious as well as who you think has been sabotaging your night actions.

BY not a bad idea but id like to know who you are most suspicious of besides those four.

in the meantime, im going to lay down a vote on raine/forever zero for pretty much the same reasoning as by.

Vote: forever zero

~marshy

 

[Blue Yoshi]

lol ok. I know 10000000% that ronike made that post lol

 

[#HBC | Mac]

lets quicklynch cacti. whose with me?!!?!

 

[Blue Yoshi]

Actually, I'm going to go with Forever Zero as well. Of the four I listed, I think he's the scummiest. For part of my reasoning, look at his last post, and look at his recent posts... major contradiction. I came across that while trying to see his posts in this game... (I usually go to "view all posts by username" to see past posts of a particular person in mafia games I play). No, I'm not proud with the way I find him scummy, but either way, I find him scummy.

Vote: Forever Zero

 

[DtJ Jungle]

BY you say 'for looking at my vote, look at his posts' but htat doesn't really tell us why you find them scummy or where the contradiction lies. you are aware of that right?

Is cacti still riding his vanilla claim and not doing anything?

at BY: there might've been a chance that those two mafia members that died together didn't know they wree siblings, which isn't uncommon, so a mafia member bandwagoning without knowing that those two are sibling'd is very plausible.

 

[#HBC | Mac]

oh cacti claimed vanilla?

jungle, what do you think of F0?

 

[DtJ Jungle]

Vinne, Vanilla Townie.

Still ok with a ryker lynch.

here you are mac.

ALso, it seems to me like F0 is sort of 'going with the flow.' tbh i forgot he was in the game, ill have to do a reread and watch out for his posts

 

[Moronik]

hint ronike: dont use contractions or any kind of punctuation. if you got any tips for me im listening lets give the tricksy posting another go now that were outed

there might've been a chance that those two mafia members that died together didn't know they wree siblings, which isn't uncommon, so a mafia member bandwagoning without knowing that those two are sibling'd is very plausible.

ive never seen this. where have you?

ALso, it seems to me like F0 is sort of 'going with the flow.' tbh i forgot he was in the game, ill have to do a reread and watch out for his posts

this this this good post buddy

looking forward to your reread findings

~marshy

 

[#HBC | Mac]

lol it was obvious from the get go

 

[~ Gheb ~]

Lynch Pool for toDay:

Blue Yoshi / Forever 0
Cacti
Scumfever

Will go into more detail later.