BC Melee Rankings: Late Fall 2012

[SpaceFalcon]

Tony, the next time you see sion play you will probably change your list.

I think his better then daltsy/matt and almost as good as me and evan.

 

[Metà]

Tony, the next time you see sion play you will probably change your list.

I think his better then daltsy/matt and almost as good as me and evan.

The problem I see with Sion though, is that he mains Link. I know his Falco is also good, but I think he focuses a lot more on Link. All I have to do to beat Link is pick Sheik and d-throw. I think he'll only go so far with Link before he has to switch mains.

 

[Sion]

Manuel needs to stay on.

Evan, a lot of characters have chain grabs over other characters; chain grabs are something i can overcome. I was playing characters other than Link when i was fighting Roby, Adam, and Manuel, so it's not impossible for me to switch if i 100% have to.

 

[Patooty]

meh, I like his Link.

Don't judge him based on what he potentially can't do.

...
If you do that, PR = tier list. Just sayin'

 

[Hitsugaya]

Lol when do I like low tier?
But doubles and RPG is correct. I do like those.

 

[SpaceFalcon]

John do you any balanced HR ro servers?

Tired of joining them to only find out sinx dominates everything.

 

[Sion]

John do you any balanced HR ro servers?

Tired of joining them to only find out sinx dominates everything.

That's only occasionally, Roby. I've seen some good LKs/Snipers out there.

 

[xXx-NoobKing-xXx]

i got my list from playing people, watching them play, and seeing how other people did against them.

manuel stays on PR. if hes off im off

Sorry Tony, that's not how it works. If manuel stops coming out then he becomes inactive and gets removed. You're as active as anyone.

EDIT: Also, can you post your most up to date PR list plz.

 

[SpaceFalcon]

LK is only good with elemental scrolls.

Sniper is pretty much my gg char, I would play him to counter sinx but now with all these new ****ty *** items, sinx can run around the pvp room gg'ing everything. (Well when I played)

Sion wanna find a ragnarok server and ****?

John (Hitsugaya) is really good to, maybe he'll start playing again. I think his a LR player though unless we find a balanced hr he might join.

 

[Sion]

LK is only good with elemental scrolls.

Sniper is pretty much my gg char, I would play him to counter sinx but now with all these new ****ty *** items, sinx can run around the pvp room gg'ing everything. (Well when I played)

Sion wanna find a ragnarok server and ****?

John (Hitsugaya) is really good to, maybe he'll start playing again. I think his a LR player though unless we find a balanced hr he might join.

Not sure if this is a good place to discuss RO, but.. I do play on a LR called Eternity. The rates are 7/7/5 i believe and I'm like a 7x/2x alchemist. I half quit, but you try finding a good server.

I have a friend IRL that owns anyone and everything with an LK in a HR. His build is whack, but he has ~2mil hp and hacks DPS.

 

[Hitsugaya]

LOL HR server for the lose. My last server was a 2/2/3 server. And I only play LK and Paladins.
Tanking 3 guilds in the emp room with Paladin FTW.

Also people who request to be off should be off and sorry to the people who are on the PR now but once Manuel leaves the PR is a joke because 3-4 of the top players wont be on it.

 

[Patooty]

Don't see why his most up-to-date list would be any different from his last post...

Am I missing some fests?

 

[Sion]

Don't see why his most up-to-date list would be any different from his last post...

Am I missing some fests?

I don't think you're missing much, but I'm pretty uninformed about things. Jack recently got pissed at us, so I'm just about as lost as you are.

 

[SpaceFalcon]

John I don't think you should bash HR before you give it a try. In a lot of ways it's as competitive as DotA, but 80% people fail to realize and just dress up they're characters like anime shows all the good players are spread out through tons of servers...

HR is top level skill with more mico then chen or mudball, I had 27 different hotkeys in bm, several different armors and bows, and different muffs and boots/headgears, not to mention the skills and usable items. PvPing with top equips and levels is just so much more amazing then competing with people who play 11 hours a day.

LR is just who ever plays the most dominates the rest, it doesn't matter how much you know about the game or how fast you are.. you simply can't beat that guy thats farmed poring island for months.

Hardest part is finding a good server without ridiculous donations or major un-balanced classes. I dunno hope that was convincing I'll it be nice to have some players to start a guild with me though.

sorry for blabbering off topic so much,

add me msn pacmanoncrack89@hotmail.com start some ****

 

[Patooty]

I was thinking of setting up my own server, but all that work and I didn't know enough people who played to make it worth while.

 

[xXx-NoobKing-xXx]

LOL HR server for the lose. My last server was a 2/2/3 server. And I only play LK and Paladins.
Tanking 3 guilds in the emp room with Paladin FTW.

Also people who request to be off should be off and sorry to the people who are on the PR now but once Manuel leaves the PR is a joke because 3-4 of the top players wont be on it.

If you quit you quit. PR will always reflect (as accurately as possible) the top 10 ACTIVE smashers in BC. I don't see where the joke is >__>

 

[dieslow]

adams just happy cause hes 2nd now

 

[SpaceFalcon]

I was thinking of setting up my own server, but all that work and I didn't know enough people who played to make it worth while.

Well if you do decide, I could probably help but when I did it was old school TXT eA.

All servers today have super computers with 4-7 skilled scripters.

 

[Dynamism?]

k when I get a new computer I want someone to show me how to get Dota or whatever so I can at least be usefull next time I come up for something.

Also, SC ftw

 

[SpaceFalcon]

I'll help you get started.

We should start sticking to talking about melee here and other games on MSN. (Or pretty much just me lol)

 

[xXx-NoobKing-xXx]

adams just happy cause hes 2nd now

Lol, and I've been doing this **** for 7 years, jesus christ.

 

[Zero_P]

No jones

^-^

 

[SpaceFalcon]

Most of our names are engraved on that PR forever, like a stonehenge *****!!

 

[firexemblemxpryde]

good idea, but keith kinda inactive. i havent seen him for a long while. even if he played well at evan's tourney still not enough to say hes better than so n so. we all know hes busy but 1 day smashing just not enough to say hes better than someone even if he beats them say a set. but if he was to show up at a couple of smashfest and hes doing well constantly then you can say keiths good.

people can usually tell if someones being dum and tries to lose. that means when people play smash they are average good, even if they're not doing their best, their style of playing won't change much. their best and average good wont have a big difference.

he might have beaten matt/evan couple times b4 i saw their matches, but if he was to play a round robin from 6-10 + sion + quinn over a spam of say 50 games, the result might be different. this is why theres smashfest, games stack up overtime and show how well people do against one another. in this case keith got one of the least in number of games played, so i would say evan and matt is better than he, for now.

I think this is utterly ridiculous. Keith is not kinda inactive. He's gone to every major tournament that I can think of in the last 4 months at least. He's not gone to a few smashfests, so what, he's inactive? And Tim isn't inactive, then? How about I play Keith all the time, and I can guarantee you he's top 10, does that mean nothing? If Ken came to one single tournament and did well and was living here, you wouldn't say "we all know hes busy but 1 day smashing just not enough to say hes better than someone even if he beats them say a set". Of course you would take his skill into consideration. Why not do the same for Keith?

Thanks for the +rep, Manuel. I plan to get a lot better throughout the days, so I guess I must practice.

You are ****.

There should just be 'inactive but good' and 'honourable mentions' sections beneath the actual rankings. Both would be unranked, but I think it would give a better indication of where people in this community are at. It just doesn't feel right being ranked so many points higher just because John, Manuel, and Eric aren't listed anymore, because I know they're still better than me. It also makes sense to give a mention to those who are actually very close to being on the list, but barely fell short.

I agree

1rd: tony
2th: manuel
3nd: ryan
4rd: adam
5th: me
6th: tiep
7th: evan
8th: sion
9th: matt
10th: daltsy

Manuels not allowed to quit so his staying on the PR.

>_o

Lol, and you are going to drag me to tournaments >.>? Or "well, if manuel were here, he probably would have come 2nd, brought it to last stock, so yeah he should stay at 2nd."

The problem I see with Sion though, is that he mains Link. I know his Falco is also good, but I think he focuses a lot more on Link. All I have to do to beat Link is pick Sheik and d-throw. I think he'll only go so far with Link before he has to switch mains.

This is ridiculous logic. No one is placing him above you, though I personally think he gives anyone below Adam a run for their money. His link *****.

Most of our names are engraved on that PR forever, like a stonehenge *****!!

:O

What ridiculous discussion is taking place. If my opinion matters:

1) Tony
2) Adam
3) Ryan
4) Roby
5) Tiep
6) Evan
7) Sion
8) Daltsy
9) Keith
10) Matt/Nathan

And of course, honourable mentions.
And of course, inactive rapers.

 

[SpaceFalcon]

That list looks good, don't understand what your trying to prove by taking yourself off (Well actually I do) but the decision is up to you.

 

[Patooty]

I don't like honourable mentions and mentioning inactive people.

As we have it now, being on the PR means something.
As you want to have it, not being mentioned anywhere means you suck.


sigh.. i'm going too low lol. I told Eric I would play next tourney. Should be fun

 

[dieslow]

my theory is manuel wants off the PR cause hes not #1.

Why? after cast4 he argued to become 1st on PR (even though he already said hes 'quitting', but failed and remained 2nd.

what would have happened if we agreed to him being 1st? =S
now hes resorting to just leaving the PR altogether. luls

 

[Patooty]

meh, people tend to quit after not being 1st

 

[Rusty Shacklefurd]

How about I play Keith all the time, and I can guarantee you he's top 10, does that mean nothing?

Why, because after playing against you all the time he does okay against you? I play against Evan all the time and when we go against eachother in tournament sets it's always just shy of even, but he does way better than me against other players. If you play with someone way more than everyone else your say should mean less, not more.

 

[Dynamism?]

my theory is manuel wants off the PR cause hes not #1.

Why? after cast4 he argued to become 1st on PR (even though he already said hes 'quitting', but failed and remained 2nd.

what would have happened if we agreed to him being 1st? =S
now hes resorting to just leaving the PR altogether. luls

At CAST he said he wanted to be off the PR.
Just sayin.

meh, people tend to quit after not being 1st

When people know they're 1st and lose it.
Eric John

well, I guess it was kind of a loss of 1st and a leaving for everz type of think. lol

k

 

[Patooty]

Eric never quit...

 

[Zero_P]

james >_>>_>_>_>_>_>>_>__>

 

[Dynamism?]

Eric never quit...

That's what I said...read the post again

james >_>>_>_>_>_>_>>_>__>

<_< <_< lazy van doesn't even reeed

 

[Sanu]

The drama in this thread is making me nauseous =S

 

[Hitsugaya]

The only reason I didn't want to be on PR was because of useless drama and because I'm moving on in my life. I'll play smash just for fun and casually now.

 

[Patooty]

That's what I said...read the post again



<_< <_< lazy van doesn't even reeed

No, the layout of your words was just confusing -_-''
*reading the post again at your request*

When people know they're 1st and lose it.
Eric John

- stating Eric as an example of being 1st and losing it
- note that you state John as your second example

well, I guess it was kind of a loss of 1st and a leaving for everz type of think. lol

- Eric didn't "lose" 1st...?
- Eric isn't leaving forever
- The subject you're referring to is logically the last person that you mentioned








Sorry, I have nothing better to do right now

 

[Zero_P]

John, if you say you're playing casually and for fun then that means you're active right? PR are the top 10 active players in BC so shouldn't you be on PR? also the drama doesn't seem so bad...just that deciding the last few spots are a bit more difficult now. but it's your choice, it'd be cool if you were back on PR though : D

 

[SpaceFalcon]

What drama? This is competition what do you expect.

 

[dieslow]

What drama? This is competition what do you expect.

YES. dont get butt-hurt get bet-ter

 

[Sanu]

What drama? This is competition what do you expect.

What drama? This PR is a list made up of arbitrary rankings for a game that will never reach high enough velocity to escape and become an international phenomenon; a list that essentially exists to stroke the ego of it's users. A list defined by a competitive gaming community will ultimately never amount to anything in it's own respect. It's drama over nothing, plain and simple.

What drama?