Kirbyoshi
Smash Apprentice
Lawl, disregard that post
-
Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!
You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!
Batma(n)fia 2 | Ever had your *** kicked by Batman?
- Thread starter #HBC | marshy
- Start date
Vote Count
Gheb_01 (3) - §teel, Bunglefever, Kirbyoshi
Kirbyoshi (1) - Gheb_01
Not voting (4): Nix2100, Macman, Omni, Ryker
Activity
3/4 - Omni, Gheb_01, §teel, Bunglefever, Ryker, Kirbyoshi, Nix2100, Macman
3/3 -
inactive -
----------
with 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch!
deadline = 3/13 midnight
Gheb_01 (3) - §teel, Bunglefever, Kirbyoshi
Kirbyoshi (1) - Gheb_01
Not voting (4): Nix2100, Macman, Omni, Ryker
Activity
3/4 - Omni, Gheb_01, §teel, Bunglefever, Ryker, Kirbyoshi, Nix2100, Macman
3/3 -
inactive -
----------
with 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch!
deadline = 3/13 midnight
Way to completely prove your skimming.
Omni I did reread allready. You made good points about the two mafia kills tonight if gheb DOES flip vanilla and Kirby is indy, which I'll admit I did not think about. But Kirbyo is such obvscum that it's like..leave gheb for tomorrow and just get the idiot out of here.
unvote vote: Kirbyo If ghebs a lyncher and he gets his win then whatever.
Omni I did reread allready. You made good points about the two mafia kills tonight if gheb DOES flip vanilla and Kirby is indy, which I'll admit I did not think about. But Kirbyo is such obvscum that it's like..leave gheb for tomorrow and just get the idiot out of here.
unvote vote: Kirbyo If ghebs a lyncher and he gets his win then whatever.
The day just started. We don't have to quicklynch yet again.
i still dont see how the **** kirbyoshi is going to flip scum or indy but whatever
bad post from bungle imo
bad post from bungle imo
the day just started literally yesterday. relax, no point in lynching so quickly.
why the change up yo?
because I'm no longer confident
Would you like to elaborate more on your scum list of me nix and steel with more than a one liner
Kirbyoshi
Smash Apprentice
Bungle, I seriously hope you didn't use this as a point against me.
Mac is right, we shouldn't lynch Gheb or me yet. We still have 9 days. Is there any reason why we shouldn't use them?
Kirbyoshi
Smash Apprentice
Why don't we use these 9 days to figure out our strategy for after we catch scum in Gheb? We have those 9 days for a reason, and we shouldn't waste them.
Kirbyoshi
Smash Apprentice
Omni: idk, why don't you tell me? Like I said, my scumdar has been off pretty much all game long.
Gheb: I think I mentioned this before, but town lost in Scum Wars because we didn't lynch the indy. I don't want that lylo situation where lyncher/mafia can joint just by lynching me. You're the eventual play toDay.
Gheb: I think I mentioned this before, but town lost in Scum Wars because we didn't lynch the indy. I don't want that lylo situation where lyncher/mafia can joint just by lynching me. You're the eventual play toDay.
Kirbyoshi
Smash Apprentice
Has Marshy never used a lyncher before?
Kirbyoshi
Smash Apprentice
Ninja'd: How would I die toMorrow if you do flip lyncher? You could have meant by a scumkill, but why should I be afraid to be the one the mafia chooses? I think I've said before, me dying could be good for town this game.
Nix2100
Smash Rookie
- Joined
- Jun 3, 2009
- Messages
- 0
This day started with split votes between Kirby and Bungle, however Bungle was able to side-step most of the votes and eventually Kirby got put in a situation where he claimed HQ. Now if HQ was a safe-claim, I don't exactly get the feeling he would of also added the bit of info about the Joker. I slightly agree with Steel's logic that as a 13 player game, 9 town versus 3 mafia + a indy, makes sense. Based on that and Gheb's insistence on lynching Kirby almost all game past the Omni arguments I feel fairly decent in the fact that gheb is joker but Indy.
The rest of the day was spent arguing on who to lynch between Gheb and Kirby with MOST of us agree'ing in the possibility of Gheb being a lyncher and taking that into account...except 2. Ryker and Bungle.
Ryker - I don't like you...I don't really know why but you've been rubbing me the wrong way all game, hence why I am not saying we should lynch you mostly because I don't my feelings to cause me to lynch a inno just because I don't like them.
Bungle - You've been pretty adamant about lynching Gheb due to his "Hard Core" tunneling but then it seemed you "settled" for lynching Kirby. Makes me think you don't really care who gets lynched as long as it isn't you.
Steel - You really want to lynch Gheb, and from what I can tell it is because you want to lynch the lurker (even though you are still saying he is scum while saying he is a lyncher o_O?) I don't think town would care as much about it as long as mafia doesn't win.
Macman - You seem to be cleared....but your recent posts make me wish you weren't
Omni - Just because there is a contradiction, doesn't mean one of them HAS to be scum. Im worried that you are only lynching them just because they were on your "list". If it wasn't for the fact that you actually slowed this day down a bit and made some very insightful posts and what not I would probably consider you scum still.
Gheb - Omni, Omni, Omni, Kirby, Kirby, Kirby, Kirby - That's been you so far mostly. But like I said before, I do think you are Indy. Cause we all know the Joker doesn't like to share the spotlight with other villians =P
Kirby - I honestly don't know what to say about you really...to be honest I don't think I've paid much attention to you most game >_> Regardless, based on the fact that I am considering Gheb as the lyncher and you his lynch target I also have to assume that you are indeed a townie.
So, in my opinion I would rather lynch Vote: Bungle
Feel free to flame me now about something I said wrong =P
The rest of the day was spent arguing on who to lynch between Gheb and Kirby with MOST of us agree'ing in the possibility of Gheb being a lyncher and taking that into account...except 2. Ryker and Bungle.
Ryker - I don't like you...I don't really know why but you've been rubbing me the wrong way all game, hence why I am not saying we should lynch you mostly because I don't my feelings to cause me to lynch a inno just because I don't like them.
Bungle - You've been pretty adamant about lynching Gheb due to his "Hard Core" tunneling but then it seemed you "settled" for lynching Kirby. Makes me think you don't really care who gets lynched as long as it isn't you.
Steel - You really want to lynch Gheb, and from what I can tell it is because you want to lynch the lurker (even though you are still saying he is scum while saying he is a lyncher o_O?) I don't think town would care as much about it as long as mafia doesn't win.
Macman - You seem to be cleared....but your recent posts make me wish you weren't
Omni - Just because there is a contradiction, doesn't mean one of them HAS to be scum. Im worried that you are only lynching them just because they were on your "list". If it wasn't for the fact that you actually slowed this day down a bit and made some very insightful posts and what not I would probably consider you scum still.
Gheb - Omni, Omni, Omni, Kirby, Kirby, Kirby, Kirby - That's been you so far mostly. But like I said before, I do think you are Indy. Cause we all know the Joker doesn't like to share the spotlight with other villians =P
Kirby - I honestly don't know what to say about you really...to be honest I don't think I've paid much attention to you most game >_> Regardless, based on the fact that I am considering Gheb as the lyncher and you his lynch target I also have to assume that you are indeed a townie.
So, in my opinion I would rather lynch Vote: Bungle
Feel free to flame me now about something I said wrong =P
Nix2100
Smash Rookie
- Joined
- Jun 3, 2009
- Messages
- 0
Ignore that part >_> That was apart of another theory i was going through that didn't pan out that well for me. So i figured I would just get my thoughts together on the day and post my insights instead.
Nix, there is a contradiction. One of them has to be scum.
Kirbyoshi is claiming that he is Harly Quinn and his PM says that the Joker exist and he is not town aligned.
Gheb is claiming that he is the Joker and that he is town aligned.
One of them is lying therefore one of them has to be scum.
You're thinking to hard. Either Kirbyoshi or Gheb has to go toDay.
Kirbyoshi is claiming that he is Harly Quinn and his PM says that the Joker exist and he is not town aligned.
Gheb is claiming that he is the Joker and that he is town aligned.
One of them is lying therefore one of them has to be scum.
You're thinking to hard. Either Kirbyoshi or Gheb has to go toDay.
Kirbyoshi
Smash Apprentice
Well, technically, my PM does not state that the Joker has to be in the game, only that I am not aligned with him.
Wow, Nix's longest post of the game, and also his towniest. I agree with the sentiments behind what he says, although there's a couple things he's still kinda mistaken on...
I assume Steel is one of the players who refers to both mafia and indies as "scum." Someone else pointed out that town's wincon is, after all, to "eliminate all threats to the town." Lyncher's goal is go get a specific townie lynched, so therefore, lyncher is a threat to the town.
It's not that the Joker doesn't like sharing the spotlight, it's simply that he's ALWAYS trying to kill Harley. Why? Because he's psychotic. But the fact remains that he always tries to kill Harley.
Wow, Nix's longest post of the game, and also his towniest. I agree with the sentiments behind what he says, although there's a couple things he's still kinda mistaken on...
I assume Steel is one of the players who refers to both mafia and indies as "scum." Someone else pointed out that town's wincon is, after all, to "eliminate all threats to the town." Lyncher's goal is go get a specific townie lynched, so therefore, lyncher is a threat to the town.
It's not that the Joker doesn't like sharing the spotlight, it's simply that he's ALWAYS trying to kill Harley. Why? Because he's psychotic. But the fact remains that he always tries to kill Harley.
That's called WIFOM, Nix.
We can't dispute whether or not Gheb is lying or telling the truth. Therefore, it should be based on scumminess. You can't ignore the fact that there could be a town-aligned Joker.
We can't dispute whether or not Gheb is lying or telling the truth. Therefore, it should be based on scumminess. You can't ignore the fact that there could be a town-aligned Joker.
Nix2100
Smash Rookie
- Joined
- Jun 3, 2009
- Messages
- 0
Fair enough, but like I said the 9 v 3 + 1 Indy DOES make some sense. Ah....had a thought, would it be too much to ask if Gheb could role claim? Eh, it's probably a bad idea I know, but would it also be possible that its not Joker who is the lyncher but HQ instead? I suppose it could go both ways o_O Hmm...Need to think more on that too.
My turn.
I say we hit Gheb, but I want to Request VoteCount first, before I put us in a bad situation again.
Omni, you say that we risk messing up two lynches in Gheb and Kirbyo. You also take into account that this only happens if Kirbyo is Indy and Gheb is town. However, Kirbyo doesn't seem Indy at all in what I've read. Scum? Yes, totally. Indy? No. Gheb's playstyle itself doesn't lead me to scum as much because that hardcore tunneling was obviously not helping and we were calling him on it, so I figure Kevin and Cello would tell him to stop.
Anyway, Omni, if you are going to say that they aren't aligned, then I think Gheb minimizes the damage because he saves the more likely to flip town Kirbyo. If Gheb flips town, then we have our scum.
You obviously don't support this notion though, so I must ask why? Am I missing something?
I say we hit Gheb, but I want to Request VoteCount first, before I put us in a bad situation again.
Omni, you say that we risk messing up two lynches in Gheb and Kirbyo. You also take into account that this only happens if Kirbyo is Indy and Gheb is town. However, Kirbyo doesn't seem Indy at all in what I've read. Scum? Yes, totally. Indy? No. Gheb's playstyle itself doesn't lead me to scum as much because that hardcore tunneling was obviously not helping and we were calling him on it, so I figure Kevin and Cello would tell him to stop.
Anyway, Omni, if you are going to say that they aren't aligned, then I think Gheb minimizes the damage because he saves the more likely to flip town Kirbyo. If Gheb flips town, then we have our scum.
You obviously don't support this notion though, so I must ask why? Am I missing something?
I've stopped trying to determine whether Kirbyoshi looks like Indy or Mafia. I just know that he is extremely scummy and I'd rather lynch him over Gheb based on all of his previous posts made throughout the day.
I've already proven that voting Gheb incorrectly will give us the only case where scum will get two nightkills. Couple that with the fact that I like Kirbyoshi dead over Gheb and that's where my decision is based.
I'm not going to try to hypothesize if someone is Indy or Mafia. Scum is scum and I've found Kirbyoshi 10x scummier than Gheb.
I've already proven that voting Gheb incorrectly will give us the only case where scum will get two nightkills. Couple that with the fact that I like Kirbyoshi dead over Gheb and that's where my decision is based.
I'm not going to try to hypothesize if someone is Indy or Mafia. Scum is scum and I've found Kirbyoshi 10x scummier than Gheb.
Can you unvote/not rush the day?
Okay. It's a difference in opinions about the game itself that is leading to this. That's cool.
Request VoteCount
I noticed my other one was midsentence and hard to read.
@All Players - Without casting anymore votes, if we go Gheb or Kirbyo, who would you pick and why?
@Nix - Why Kirbyo over Gheb?
Vote Count
Gheb_01 (2) - §teel, Kirbyoshi
Kirbyoshi (4) - Gheb_01, Bunglefever, Omni, Nix2100
Not voting (2): Macman, Ryker
Activity
3/5 - Ryker, Macman, Nix2100, Omni, Kirbyoshi, Gheb_01
3/4 - §teel, Bunglefever
3/3 -
inactive -
----------
with 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch!
deadline = 3/13 midnight
Gheb_01 (2) - §teel, Kirbyoshi
Kirbyoshi (4) - Gheb_01, Bunglefever, Omni, Nix2100
Not voting (2): Macman, Ryker
Activity
3/5 - Ryker, Macman, Nix2100, Omni, Kirbyoshi, Gheb_01
3/4 - §teel, Bunglefever
3/3 -
inactive -
----------
with 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch!
deadline = 3/13 midnight
Nix2100
Smash Rookie
- Joined
- Jun 3, 2009
- Messages
- 0
There's nothing left to discuss. Everyone has had their say in the matter. There is a contradiction and whether its scum/town in which we would win, or lynchee/lyncher where one of them needs to go to prevent a bad lylo one of them HAS to get lynched.
@Ryker - *grumble*
Unvote
To prevent a quick-lynch since i suppose not everyone HAS had their say -_-
and sec, i'll answer the question, just wanted to Unvote first.
@Ryker - *grumble*
Unvote
To prevent a quick-lynch since i suppose not everyone HAS had their say -_-
and sec, i'll answer the question, just wanted to Unvote first.
Nix2100
Smash Rookie
- Joined
- Jun 3, 2009
- Messages
- 0
*waves* Hi Marshy! =P
@Ryker - Its 50/50 for me. I feel there is most likely a lyncher instead of scum. As such Gheb has really focused on both Omni and Kirby most of the game and after giving it some thought, I don't think a good lyncher would do something like that as it would completely give it away eventually.
At the same time we have Kirby who claimed HQ....but not just any HQ, a Vanilla Townie that just happens to have in its Role PM information about Joker not being aligned....Why in the world would a Vanilla Townie have that sort of information? Just seems a bit unusual for me is all.
@Ryker - Its 50/50 for me. I feel there is most likely a lyncher instead of scum. As such Gheb has really focused on both Omni and Kirby most of the game and after giving it some thought, I don't think a good lyncher would do something like that as it would completely give it away eventually.
At the same time we have Kirby who claimed HQ....but not just any HQ, a Vanilla Townie that just happens to have in its Role PM information about Joker not being aligned....Why in the world would a Vanilla Townie have that sort of information? Just seems a bit unusual for me is all.
bump sup nix