-
Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!
You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!
Batma(n)fia 2 | Ever had your *** kicked by Batman?
- Thread starter #HBC | marshy
- Start date
Vote Count
Gheb_01 (3) - §teel, Bunglefever, Kirbyoshi
Kirbyoshi (1) - Gheb_01
Not voting (4): Nix2100, Macman, Omni, Ryker
Activity
3/4 - Omni, Gheb_01, §teel, Bunglefever, Ryker, Kirbyoshi, Nix2100, Macman
3/3 -
inactive -
----------
with 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch!
deadline = 3/13 midnight
Gheb_01 (3) - §teel, Bunglefever, Kirbyoshi
Kirbyoshi (1) - Gheb_01
Not voting (4): Nix2100, Macman, Omni, Ryker
Activity
3/4 - Omni, Gheb_01, §teel, Bunglefever, Ryker, Kirbyoshi, Nix2100, Macman
3/3 -
inactive -
----------
with 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch!
deadline = 3/13 midnight
Why would he be independent? If he is independent, what role would he be? He is obviously not a serial killer because there has been either one death or no death each night. If there is a lyncher, it makes a lot more sense for you to be the lyncher, and it makes a lot more sense for him to be your lyncher target, especially with how his claim said that there was a joker out there, and that YOU happened to claim that joker later, and you have been on him almost all game.
@macman, #918: absolutely not, if you are kidding, then you will read up anyways and help us. If you are not kidding and you are being barebones macman, plz catch up and weigh in.
Gheb #916:
That post is halfway right. If you are a lyncher, then it might make sense to avoid lynching either you or Kirbyoshi altogether and to hunt for someone else. This is because if we hit the scum before we get to 3-4man, we would win regardless of any lyncher situation (unless if the lyncher is still alive, the game continues, which is also possible.) The problems with that logic are
a) we don’t know for sure whether or not you are a lyncher... I could be wrong, and Kirby could be mafia. In that situation, you would continue to push his lynch, as he has directly conflicted with you. From your perspective, if you are town, Kirby is the last scum. So you should want to keep the attention focused on him, and you would understand why I would want to lynch you or him. This goes in with your earlier reaction of AtE self-voting.
b) if we ignore the situation completely, and you are a lyncher, that means kirbyo is not scum. Scum would know this, and they would keep both you and kirbyo alive until 3-4 man, when scum can claim and the two of you can put your votes on kirbyo and joint-win the game.
So I cannot simply ignore the situation for better (hitting mafia) pastures, or at least I have not yet come to a decision on what to do. This is exactly why I just suggested that we let the situation calm down, so we don’t have to make a decision now, and so our clear can weigh in.
“You don’t want to lynch me because you think I’m scum, but because it fits your situation,” do you want to expand on that, or do you want to keep being vague and using “wtf you guys actually think im lyncher?” as your defense?
Nix #917, you can answer this stuff too, because you seem to have co-signed Gheb’s post.
@macman, #918: absolutely not, if you are kidding, then you will read up anyways and help us. If you are not kidding and you are being barebones macman, plz catch up and weigh in.
Gheb #916:
That post is halfway right. If you are a lyncher, then it might make sense to avoid lynching either you or Kirbyoshi altogether and to hunt for someone else. This is because if we hit the scum before we get to 3-4man, we would win regardless of any lyncher situation (unless if the lyncher is still alive, the game continues, which is also possible.) The problems with that logic are
a) we don’t know for sure whether or not you are a lyncher... I could be wrong, and Kirby could be mafia. In that situation, you would continue to push his lynch, as he has directly conflicted with you. From your perspective, if you are town, Kirby is the last scum. So you should want to keep the attention focused on him, and you would understand why I would want to lynch you or him. This goes in with your earlier reaction of AtE self-voting.
b) if we ignore the situation completely, and you are a lyncher, that means kirbyo is not scum. Scum would know this, and they would keep both you and kirbyo alive until 3-4 man, when scum can claim and the two of you can put your votes on kirbyo and joint-win the game.
So I cannot simply ignore the situation for better (hitting mafia) pastures, or at least I have not yet come to a decision on what to do. This is exactly why I just suggested that we let the situation calm down, so we don’t have to make a decision now, and so our clear can weigh in.
“You don’t want to lynch me because you think I’m scum, but because it fits your situation,” do you want to expand on that, or do you want to keep being vague and using “wtf you guys actually think im lyncher?” as your defense?
Nix #917, you can answer this stuff too, because you seem to have co-signed Gheb’s post.
besides, town win condition is to eliminate all threats to town, and a lyncher most certainly counts as a threat to town, so im not sure the game would end if we killed all three mafia and the lyncher was still alive.
Kirbyoshi
Smash Apprentice
If I were to do a Steel-esque (color-coded) scumlist, from blue to red, Steel would be the color of Barney the Dinosaur.
I HATE Barney.
I HATE Barney.
what does that mean
Kirbyoshi
Smash Apprentice
i.e. purple, exactly halfway between blue and red, you're painfully neutral to me, just like Chibo always is -_-
who would be red?
the fact that u keep harping on the issue that i'm not basing this on scumhunting is making you lose credibility in your accusations. try to consider the fact that it could be a combination of both scumhunting and using scenarios to minimize damage. it's not that hard to imagine
hmm..
mac, proxy your vote over to me since you're not playing
i'll wait to see what Jungle has to say
Kirbyoshi
Smash Apprentice
Well, as of right now, everyone else is various shades of blue, so you're the "mafia-y-est" player, but Gheb is yellow, or indy.
Kirbyoshi
Smash Apprentice
Ninja'd: Above is directed at Steel.
lol
and yes im catching up. i actually feel like playing today. you guys posted a crapload
wow alot of stuff happened.
i doubt marshy would throw a lyncher into his game. complete mod meta.
but i also dont think kirbyo is scum. I think he's just been dumb. I am however getting an indy vibe from Gheb. But not much a scum one.
Last scum is between nix/jungle/steel.
i was feeling good about steel for a bit but i don't know now
we shouldn't end this day quickly.
and i love omni for not being dumb
i doubt marshy would throw a lyncher into his game. complete mod meta.
but i also dont think kirbyo is scum. I think he's just been dumb. I am however getting an indy vibe from Gheb. But not much a scum one.
Last scum is between nix/jungle/steel.
i was feeling good about steel for a bit but i don't know now
we shouldn't end this day quickly.
and i love omni for not being dumb
macman that was a bad post. "i doubt that there is a lyncher in the game but i think gheb might be indy," then what indy would he be?
i don't know steel.
indies other than lynches exist. I just dont think marshy would put one in his game.
indies other than lynches exist. I just dont think marshy would put one in his game.
macman are you actually playing
Kirbyoshi
Smash Apprentice
Well, it's not an SK, it's not a jester, it's not a survivor, it's not a ****ing politician, so what is it other than a lyncher? You tell me, mac.
also mac, Marshy hates Survivors with a passion, lynchers not so much. combined with only 1 or no kill a night, we dont have an sk and after that, the most likely thing is Lyncher I think, don't you?
ytf does this even matter?
Kirbyoshi
Smash Apprentice
Steel: It also helps that it says in the OP that there are no Survivors.
macman are you actually playing
what is your point steel?
My point is that you are being unhelpful. You say that you think Kirbyo isn’t scum, but Gheb is indy vibe but not so much scum vibe. But then you say you don’t think Marshy would put a lyncher in the game. So then what indy is he? He is not serial killer, he is not survivor, he is not politician, or jester. So why don’t you think Marshy would put a lyncher in the game?
If you think the last scum is between Nix, Jungle, and me, I guess you feel good about Ryker and Omni. That’s fine with me right now. So do you think you want to lynch for mafia, or do you think you want to lynch Gheb?
Why do you “love omni for not being dumb?”
My point is you are not helping and you are clear. You are really frustrating me.
If you think the last scum is between Nix, Jungle, and me, I guess you feel good about Ryker and Omni. That’s fine with me right now. So do you think you want to lynch for mafia, or do you think you want to lynch Gheb?
Why do you “love omni for not being dumb?”
My point is you are not helping and you are clear. You are really frustrating me.
but i am not scum so you should get over it.
la: just realized I could be indy lol. well im not tht either
so ya get over it
la: just realized I could be indy lol. well im not tht either
so ya get over it
How about you get off your high horse and actually play the game? How about you answer any of those questions I ask you? I’m not saying that you are scummy and clear and therefore I’m somehow conflicted. I’m saying you are clear but you aren’t helping at all.
So why aren’t you helping? Is it just not important enough to you? Or do you seriously think that now that you are clear, you have no more reason to contribute, because you aren’t going to be lynched.
I will never get over it. Post #944 will forever go down as Macman’s *****-move.
So why aren’t you helping? Is it just not important enough to you? Or do you seriously think that now that you are clear, you have no more reason to contribute, because you aren’t going to be lynched.
I will never get over it. Post #944 will forever go down as Macman’s *****-move.
I caught up and gave my thoughts about the game, and you accuse me of not playing. How am I supposed to take that? You're spending your time asking me questions that don't matter instead of actually focusing on the matter at hand. You randomly asked me if I wasn't playing which is the dumbest **** ever, because if that was the case I wouldn't bother to read/post at all. So I didn't get why you were coming at me like that at all.
This point of conversation didn't matter because I agrees that gheb seemed like an indy. So we had similar reads which means it would be pointless to argue whether or not he's a lyncher or not. You keep asking me my reasoning and I've already answered by saying I don't think marshy would put in a lyncher.
I've been contributing the way I always do. So get this 'oh he's so unhelpful' crap out of here cuz it's not doing anything except derailing the focus.
This point of conversation didn't matter because I agrees that gheb seemed like an indy. So we had similar reads which means it would be pointless to argue whether or not he's a lyncher or not. You keep asking me my reasoning and I've already answered by saying I don't think marshy would put in a lyncher.
I've been contributing the way I always do. So get this 'oh he's so unhelpful' crap out of here cuz it's not doing anything except derailing the focus.
Then I guess your playstyle just makes you worst **** clear.
So how about you actually answer the important question I already asked, which is: So do you think you want to lynch for mafia, or do you think you want to lynch Gheb?
And to say that I’m “not focusing on the matter at hand” is bull**** because I’m currently trying to get your opinion on it and all you want to do is whine.
So how about you actually answer the important question I already asked, which is: So do you think you want to lynch for mafia, or do you think you want to lynch Gheb?
And to say that I’m “not focusing on the matter at hand” is bull**** because I’m currently trying to get your opinion on it and all you want to do is whine.
except for the fact that i've already given you my opinion and you are the one that has a problem with it simply because you disagree with me, so for some reason that makes you think I am not actually playing the game. what is the purpose of wanting my opinion if you are just going to ridicule me for not agreeing with it?
and I'd rather lynch someone I think is mafia than gheb.
and I'd rather lynch someone I think is mafia than gheb.
Kirbyoshi
Smash Apprentice
So who do you think is mafia?
l a
Kirbyoshi
Smash Apprentice
Wow, you've narrowed it down to 3 people.
Almost half the field.
And you wonder why Steel called you unhelpful?
Almost half the field.
And you wonder why Steel called you unhelpful?
alr ight
I don't think kirb/steel are mafia. Bungle would probably be my strongest candidate at this point. I have no thoughts concerning nix at all which bugs me alot.
No I just got back home from various shenanigans and need to catch up.
If you recall I made a post about gheb's super hardcore tunnelling on two players today even though he claims to not be tunnelling when he responded to steels post (this was post 669). I was getting a bad vibe but I couldn't make any more of it, since there seemed be no SK, there is no jester or survivor, so I didn't know what to do of it. It's scummy, but I'm getting bigger scum vibes from Kirbyo and I highly doubt BOTH of them are mafia. Then steel brought to light the idea that Gheb could be a survivor and things started to make sense, and felt that Gheb would be the best lynch today. That's all. This probably looks like parroting of steel at some point it's what I felt at the time.
If you recall I made a post about gheb's super hardcore tunnelling on two players today even though he claims to not be tunnelling when he responded to steels post (this was post 669). I was getting a bad vibe but I couldn't make any more of it, since there seemed be no SK, there is no jester or survivor, so I didn't know what to do of it. It's scummy, but I'm getting bigger scum vibes from Kirbyo and I highly doubt BOTH of them are mafia. Then steel brought to light the idea that Gheb could be a survivor and things started to make sense, and felt that Gheb would be the best lynch today. That's all. This probably looks like parroting of steel at some point it's what I felt at the time.
Yeah that's hwat i meant (as i clearly said there can't be a survivor) >_>
Kirbyoshi
Smash Apprentice
In fact, I believe Fever is the first one to bring up the idea that Gheb could be a survivor...oh wait, MARSHY SAID THERE ARE NONE.