Awkward Moments Mafia - Game over! Scum wins! Will a SD game ever see a town victory?

[Fynal]

read asdioh and kantrip, kantrip is fine by me, asdioh is really town. his play feels really genuine and i like a lot of the stuff he does, for example his daykill gambit

I think that's wifom. Actions while drunk may vary. I do still think kuz is town, though.

also i agree with this. he could even be faking drunkenness or something. kuz is still town to me but i wana read a bit on this one.

this leaves J, RR, and Felipe...

back to reading

also i just watched like 20 mins of megamind, i forgot how much i enjoyed that movie

 

[Fynal]

@asdioh, do you think kuz is scum this game?

also poptarts are goood man

 

[th3kuzinator]

fynal do YOUYU Think im scum this gamw?

 

[th3kuzinator]

yeah thats what i thought you pansy poodle

 

[Asdioh]

the fact that i'm alive, and kuz is also alive, and being all friendly toward me, means kuz is keeping me til lylo.

(hmm)

(maybe)

(like i said i'm gonna be rereading)

 

[th3kuzinator]

i look forward to analysizing your analysis on my analyeses, captain

 

[#HBC | J]

@J: how exactly does yer role work? like, do you choose one person per night to eat or is it automatic? like if a PR dies you auto-get their results?

also, just out of interest, are you supergood at reading kuz or something? i thought you said something about you dying implicating him (i realize you prolly weren't that serious)

But I already explained my role 3-4 times. ;____; Basically I just get the dead PRs results and are able to tell them if they didn't get the chance too while alive.

I don't auto-get, I have to use my night action to get em.

No, not super good. I'd say adequate at best. I can read him when he's an indy but I'm still trying to figure him out whether sometimes if he really is that scummy and the like. Funny thing is, I was kind of joking with that statement but kind of not at the same time. It's a weird thing coming back when you have already died because your mindset is different. You got that thought of, "Why did the mafia NK me? Who would gain the best from killing me?" sooooo weird.

 

[th3kuzinator]

yeah dudes j is super good at reading me when im indy. he like called that **** to me in ichat during dkr and touhou

but j, am i an indy this game???

 

[#HBC | J]

And in FF9 but Ryker didn't wanna listen to me and thought Hilt was the entire time.

Idk atm. I don't even think there is an indy in this game.

 

[Asdioh]

Like I said, I came into this game expecting 2 mafia, 1 indy.

 

[Kantrip]

If not an indy, I think scum is just a stacked 2 people. Indy seems more likely to me. I can't see scum having three people just from a numbers standpoint.

 

[#HBC | J]

Well even if that's the case I like this

Fynal
Kuzi
RR
Felipe

of holding 3/4 scum and I like Felipe's slot because of Gova. Kuzi/Fynal/RR then would have to make up the rest of the scum because I really doubt it's Kanty/Asdioh. So for me, it's just a thing of who goes first. xD I'm trying to pick which one of Fynal/Kuzi.

 

[Kantrip]

You're going to need to provide reasoning, please.

Reasons why felipe looks town (because I see no difference between his play here and his play in the recent newbie game he was scum in) as well.

 

[#HBC | J]

Well I died around the same time Gova replaced out in which i had a town read on that slot and now Felipe just isn't caught up, not really posting so there is nothing to change really from my Gova read yet. What's scummy about Felipe Kanty? Is it because he just isn't doing much oooor?

I will try and provide reasoning for why I think one of Fynal/Kuzi go but I caaaaaan't really be bothered at this current time to do extensive cases on either slot because I am heading to bed early tonight. I have homecoming tomorrow. ^^

Plus with my reads it's PoE; I like Myself/Kanty/Asdioh as town so that leaves the other four slots as scum candidates, I liked Gova-Felipe and I don't really see scum with RR because I haven't seen reasoning for why he should be lynched toDay so it just leaves Kuzi/Fynal which sit at the bottom of my reads to begin with.

 

[Kantrip]

So you're saying there's nothing about their play that you liked, so by PoE they are scum?

For felipe, his play is just near identical to his play in the newbie game: Never caught up, lots of fluff in his post (that says that he's not caught up), and trying to answer questions and give opinions while not being caught up.

I'd put Felipe/Gova's slot lower on the PoE totem pole than anyone. I still don't like how Ryker and armor played, which translates to your slot and Red Ryu's slot.

Red Ryu's play hasn't looked much better, and his reaction to Asdioh's gambit is WIFOM and could have been faked.

I don't like your claim, either, but that's a different story.

Personally, I think we should finish this mass claim on the off-chance there's a 3-man scum team.

 

[th3kuzinator]

but im town

 

[#HBC | J]

Wasn't his first scum-game also his first game?

Of course there are somethings I liked but that doesn't outweigh what I like of others or what they have done that I have disliked either. So you are using PoE yourself Kanty except you just re-arrange the names to be J/RR/Felipe.

I do agree to the sentiment that we should continue with the mass-claim.

Kuzi really shouldn't post while high/drunk/etc. =P

 

[Kantrip]

I just meant if I were to use PoE, that's the conclusion I would come to.

I want RR dead based off of prior scumminess in his slot that wasn't alleviated after he replaced.

alright, so who's next for claiming?

 

[Kantrip]

@MOD, if you can answer this: Does the town idiot have a night action?

 

[#HBC | J]

Couldn't I confirm that? Lol I mean it's weird but I could explain some things.

 

[th3kuzinator]

what i do in my soare tine is none of your beeswax

 

[Kantrip]

Did you eat soup's body?

 

[#HBC | J]

I was Soupa's body dummy. xP

 

[Kantrip]

Oh yeah I totally forgot, lol.

There have been a lot of replacements this game.

I would like to know whatever you can share.

 

[#HBC | J]

Well I would but I kind of think it's unethical to do as such since it's like I literally saw the role PM and kindof defeats the purpose of the role.

 

[Fynal]

iirc general consensus has me next

i am that guy whose office chair makes farting noises, vt

my read on gova was null, felipe's posts are pretty freaking opportunistic/sheep. Both the TTK vote and the FoS armor/J because his role doesn't fit (iirc kuz said that?). i'm gonna wait for his catchup. actually he's kinda sheeped kuz a lot hasnt he

@felipe: my question in whatever it was, which i'm going to restate because it bugs me when people say "my ###" when it was a half sentence question:
do you see anyone as scummy besides J?

working through kuz nao

 

[Kantrip]

Ah alright. Well, the answer may make a difference is all.

It seems to me, with what we have claimed so far, that the vanilla cop may have been an important role in this game, and your role (if you're being honest about it) may have been a sort of back-up in case the vanilla cop was killed before he could share his results. Unfortunately, we lynched the vanilla cop before he could GET any results. There is almost 100% at least one other power role that you could eat, because revolving the entire game around a vanilla cop is too swingy to be the case here.

I am your first kiss, vanilla townie.

I will wait until the rest of the claims to finish my thoughts here.

 

[Kantrip]

Is it just Asdioh and kuz that need to claim now?

 

[Fynal]

who claimed "your first kiss" before... i swear someone did

 

[Asdioh]

I suppose it's time for everyone to claim, since fynal claimed...

...oh wait, kantrip did too.

now it's down to me and kuz?

i am that flavor that I already mentioned, vanilla townie.

 

[#HBC | J]

Is it just Asdioh and kuz that need to claim now?

Yuppers because iirc,

Fynal - VT
Felipe - VT
Kanty - VT
RR - VT
J - Nom nom nom PR

Kuzi
Asdioh

 

[#HBC | J]

Asdioh ninja'ing me. ;_;

let's gogogo Kuzi.

Really though? 2 PRs, a Miller only claimed/flipped?

 

[Kantrip]

Yep yep, I expected this. The set-up definitely was based off of the vanilla cop.

Kuzi, claim.

 

[Fynal]

lotsa VT up in dis...

lets see dat claim kuz

 

[Asdioh]

 

[Fynal]

bah i keep reading kuz and i keep not finding interesting things. i def like some of his stuff, for example his stating that RR's thinking-he-was-daykilled was prolly not legit and null anyway, (which i agree with)

i'm gonna go do my calc homework real quick and try again when im done

 

[Asdioh]

Kuz is clearly lurking the thread, thinking of a fakeclaim now that 3 VTs have claimed

 

[felipe_9595]

Kuz, if i had to choose a second Fos, would be Fynal, but is not something based on what i have read. Call it guts.

 

[Kantrip]

Felipe, I ask you this because I'm not sure if it's part of your regular play, or only what you do as scum:

Do you ever have any cemented reads with reasoning you can provide for yourself?

 

[felipe_9595]

I dont have any solid reads. I have tryed to get into the game but i replaced way too late on it. I feel like a tard, i am not doing nothing at all :/