BEWARE: EXCESSIVELY LONG/SERIOUS POST AHEAD:
Mr. Shinblanka is in a ******** position. As I'm sure he would love to do, and most to all of SRK would support, he could drop either Melee or Brawl and call it a done deal. But then whichever side he dropped would begin endless complaints of "Why meeeeeeeeeee why not the other guy!!!"
And Smash is not like a lot of the other smaller brackets he runs at FR. He runs games like SF:A2 for the hardcore lovers of the game, but if you get maybe 20 entrants for that, play out a bracket that's a couple hours on 1-2 TVs. The bottom line is, Smash takes FOREVER. As we all know, a 30-40 man bracket (and don't forget the teams!) takes literally all day.
Melee is pretty much more alive in GA than Brawl is anyway. (Not to mention the fun factor). Playing a Brawl tournament match is like doing homework. It takes forever, it totally sucks, and the only satisfaction you get afterwards is knowing that you're done (and knowing that it might help you make money in the future). The only thing as equally frustrating as losing is getting caught in quicksand - you know you're gonna die, but it's not happening for another 20 hours while you die of boredom first.
Ok ok enough Brawl bashing, back to the business. Fighting games in general have always been at odds with Smash. Condescending looks have been given, hurtful words have been said, tears have flown like waterfalls, but we should be looking (as Shinblanka is) as to what is best for the FIGHTING GAME community - as 1 whole. Regardless of what anyone thinks of the quality of Brawl (I suppose I have made my biased opinion known already....) more drama and tension has arisen between Smash and the rest of the FGC then has ever before existed. Smash players and FGC people were separate, but they knew that they could not compete in the other's game(s). The Smash community got absolutely embarrassed at FR11 by Jwong's 2nd place finish (although I would've beat him had I gotten to play him
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1c4fb/1c4fb4a004ac374ae735c210f8560be0dce354ac" alt="Wink ;) ;)"
).
With steadily declining tournament newcomers in both Brawl and Melee in our region, now is a critical time for Smash Bros. FR is the biggest ****ing tournament in the SE by FAR for almost every single fighting game on the market, but for some for Smash reason it's only a local tournament with far-away travelers entering it as an afterthought. Why is this? It's not just Jwong's presence, I can guarantee that (as evidenced by 80 man bracket this past weekend).
I personally think Melee is the ST of the Smash series. It may not be perfect, but they did a lot of things right. And, unlike Capcom, the makers of Brawl specifically press released the notion that they were trying hard to make Brawl as non-competitive as possible.
I thought I was going somewhere with this.....well I'll wrap up and save the rest for another day when someone will inevitably disagree with something I said or my inconsistent unbiased-jumping-to-biased-jumping-back-to-unbiased writing style.
SUMMARY OF POINTS:
1) If logistics is an issue (or if Shinblanka does not wish to run 2 Smash brackets [plus teams...], Melee > Brawl
2) FIGHTING GAME COMMUNITY = FIGHTING GAME COMMUNITY. Smash is a fighting game, is it not? Let's integrate that **** into the community, come on guys. Stop whining. Yes Shin gave you short notice on the TV setups, but he also said to call Waba if you'd be late and he'd work with you. That puts responsibility on your end.
3) If you must, take that Smash out of there. Won't stop me from coming to that hype, but will be filled with many more people I am less familiar with =(
I've been to a fair amount of big and small tournaments, and Shin is hands down the best at getting brackets done. You'd think it's an easy job, but apparently it's not because not many people seem to do it right.
Waaa I have so many opinions, can the internet handle all of them?! Ok I stop here. Discuss. Or completely ignore wall. Either one.