Does anyone have the article where Arle's creator said they didnt want Arle in fighting games?
Here's the quote itself, I don't have a link to the article.
---
For my own personal take on this that nobody asked for, since I think about this often - I feel like people have misconstrued this to mean Arle isn't possible for Smash Bros, when it reality it's referring explicitly to Puyo's own games.
Off the bat, anyone who plays Puyo already knows how weird this statement is. Characters like Draco and Rulue are explicitly shown punching, and the other characters are effectively attacking one another with a variety of spells and whatnot. But regardless, let's say that this statement
was consistent and Puyo was this nonviolent world. Envisioning a world where Arle did not decapitate Schezo.
The "Puyo World" is a lighthearted place. There's a certain brand that they want to maintain for the core series games, and considering a fighting game was shot down it seems that they don't want to pursue any projects that pit these characters against one another in such a fashion... under the Puyo Puyo name. Like, recontextualize this and consider how Animal Crossing devs would feel about their characters beating one another up, or about an Animal Crossing fighting game being developed and marketed alongside the peaceful and friendly vibes that the series is known for. As awesome as this would be, it's quite obvious why that wouldn't work out.
But in Smash, this doesn't matter. Villager and Isabelle fighting Solid Snake and Bayonetta is perfectly okay - so would it be okay for Arle? Well first off, something to keep in mind about Villager / Isabelle is how the
spirit of Animal Crossing is still maintained in their movesets. A lot of their attacks aren't really attacks so much as they are accidents or simply going about their happy lives - catching bugs, collecting items, chopping down trees, going fishing... Bottom line, there's no harm in Arle being in Smash if the
spirit of Puyo is maintained through Arle and the rest of the series representation. It wouldn't be very difficult to create a moveset revolving around the use of Puyo and Arle clumsily attacking her opponents, without being explicitly violent.
Also, to put it bluntly: it's f**king Smash Bros. You'd have to be a real stick in the mud to turn down the opportunity to be in the biggest gaming crossover of all time, especially a series like Puyo that has been shooting for a bigger western audience for a long time now. I think with Sakurai at the helm, someone who has proven time and time again to represent characters in as faithful and loving a way as possible, the positives would simply outweigh the concern of Arle getting smacked around. After all, it's not like Smash and Puyo don't share a similar cartoony, slapstick spirit to them in the first place. Sakurai has made crazier things happen.