on the RAID thing
https://www.reddit.com/r/smashbros/comments/8d8k58/raid_weekly_in_chicago_bans_bayonetta/
-RAID is a very small weekly series to begin with, hitting 17-25-ish. 39 is the biggest number of entrants at a RAID event and this was quite recently.
-A guy posts a thread of Reddit saying that Bayonetta was banned. This was the first I had heard of RAID, as I am most familiar with Poplar Creek Bowl and Ignition.
Statement from the TO: Hey guys, Santi here.
Effective immediately, Bayonetta is temporarily banned from Raid Tuesdays.
This has been something I’ve wanted to do for some time, even before we started getting more Bayo mains to the weekly. I still encourage our weekly Bayo players to come and compete - they are all skilled players and I have no doubt that they will place well without her.
However, the character itself - at least in my opinion - is toxic to the community and is broken to an extreme. I am aware that I’m not a talented player, but even so I hate fighting against her against all types of player skill levels.
I have spoken to many players about this topic and a lot of them also feel the same way. It’s a lot to get into, but in the end of the day it is my decision. I know the idea of even a few Bayos in bracket prevent other players to attend and compete (both to and outside the RT weekly)
This ban will be temporarily unless people respond to it well. I understand this will affect PR eligibility but honestly if it means her being banned I’m okay with it.
Also, in terms of doubles - the characters Cloud and Bayo are also banned.
That’s all, later!
-There are three active Bayonetta mains at RAID. Tyroy, Rose, and Razor. Unibrownies to my knowledge is a ZSS but used Bayonetta either at this particular watershed event (RAID Tuesdays 32) or had begun using her prior. Finding character information out is impossible in most cases due to a lack of VODs.
-Bozz, an apparent regular attendant, made a post on Reddit.
Bozz's statement (Not a TO, only an attendee)
ChaosBozz 199 points 1 day ago
Because I see people being sarcastic ***hats in this thread and I've attended raid a few times myself, I feel obligated to throw in my 2 cents.
Bayonetta was the reason why attendance was dropping at Raid. There's no getting around that fact. Many Chicago PR'd players are finding it more taxing than enjoyable to play against our top ranked bayonetta, Tyroy.
No one has literally anything against Tyroy, he's been a valuable part of the community for years. However his character, and to be frank, his skill with the character was so frustrating for many people to play against that they simply stopped attending.
This isn't a major TO trying to take a stance against bayo, this is a weekly trying to preserve the scene by appealing to long standing community members.
-This set off a lot of red flags for me because they mostly discussed tyroy and got immediately defensive about the decision as if it were based around him. I did not like this, and I chose to doubt the claim that attendance dropped.
-I think it could be argued that attendance may have been declining if there were special circumstances for RAID 29(?) having 39 entrants. Otherwise, attendance numbers were all over the place and there wasn't a sign of significantly decline with a recent increase occurring due to RAID 29.
-At this point, I had concerns over ethics, because I was worried that tyroy had been banned because he kept winning and Bayonetta was simply a scapegoat.
This would have been particularly absurd since no other regular RAID attendant had ever even qualified for OrionRank in 2017 despite exceedingly lenient standards that year, with big_mak being their second best player. In fact, Javi won three consecutive RAID events without dropping any games, according to the challonge brackets for 4, 5, and 6.
-I ended up posting the above graph and expressed my concerns.
-Santi, the TO of RAID, at some point compiles a list of reasons that are way less vague that the OP's post on Reddit.
The reasons santi gave are:
1) the weekly itself isn’t big enough. That’s not to say it’s because of Bayo, but because the weekly isn’t that big I believe it shouldn’t be a big deal. It’s only a 17-25 person weekly as of now
2) most of the players that do enter despise playing against Bayo. Including myself. Ever since day 1, I knew she should be ban. When she got patched I thought t was okay but it isn’t in my opinion
3) the new smash game is about to release later this year. At this point, I wanna experiment with stuff that people were too scared to try. It would affect PR eligibility, but I also want my entrants to have a good time while not wanting to even try by seeing her get selected
4) all the bayos who attend the weekly are talented players. If they do decide to continue to attend, mind you - maybe not as often - I know they will still place well. If anything, this gives them an opportunity to try with their secondaries
5) she is clearly broken. Players justify her and honestly, with money involved - I don’t blame them for picking her. But I’ve seen too many good players loose to bad bayos or less skilled players just because of her
6) I wanna work things up to the new smash. So trying things like this now will help the weekly get a vibe of what we should be doing. It isn’t the norm but i want my weekly to be unique. I’m not saying other people gotta follow me. If anything, I don’t wanna be the sheep
I don't take issue with Santi's decision or reasoning at this point since he does not focus on Tyroy and instead takes issue with the character herself. The TO accepts the fact that RAID is no longer PR eligible and I firmly believe local scenes should do whatever rulesets they want too, so my concerns over ethics don't really apply anymore based on the TO's decision.
I remain skeptical but the scale of the weekly series and the existence of multiple other series in the same subregion of Chicago leaves me to be fine with the decision.
I also agree with banning Cloud in doubles, of course, but that's become very common and is also applying to Smash & Splash and (presumably) CEO.