I think planking villager generally loses to characters that have good spikes like falcon, Megaman has a spike but it's not really the greatest and not too good at this strategy imo. Scatt tried some things against me when we did practice it, but none of it was really effective (he tried his megaman's bomb customs that throw in an arc to hit me on the edge and his tornado up-b to get me off the edge, but neither seemed that effective, you can pocket the tornado up-b and use it back at him actually lol), that was just in a pretty short time we tried it so like i said megaman might have some counter play to it that I just didn't see yet, even if he does though you don't have to play planking villager the whole time though, you can just mix it up with planking and just staying on stage camping behind sapling or something though.
Also, anyone have any notable gaw experience? I played against a pretty decent one and I think villager loses that MU. Turnips are really ineffective in that MU, gaw's up-b and uair beat our dair and his key beats our uair. Dash attack is good against us because it puts him low to the ground so it's hard to slingshot and if you do get him with it his head on his dash attack is invincible so he will beat it.
While I was at it I just put down my current opinion on some of our MUs. A "?" just means I'm pretty iffy on it myself, "???" means I have no idea, "!" means I think it's one of our worst MUs. This is assuming no customs btw.
bowser- win
bowser jr- win
falcon- lose
charizard- win
dark pit- even?
diddy kong- lose
donkey kong- win
dr. mario- win
duck hunt- lose
falco- even?
fox- lose?
ganon- win
greninja- ???
ike- win
jigglypuff- lose
king ddd- win
kirby- win?
link- win
little mac- lose?
lucario- lose!
lucas- ???
lucina- win
luigi- win?
mario- lose
marth- win
mega man- lose!
meta knight- win?
mewtwo- win?
mii brawler- win
mii gunner- win
mii swordfighter- win
gaw- lose
ness- even
olimar- ???
pacman- win
palutena- lose
peach- win
pikachu- even
pit- even?
rob- win
robin- win
rosalina- lose!
roy- win
ryu- win
samus- win
sheik- lose
shulk- win?
sonic- lose
toon link- win
wario- even?
wii fit- win
yoshi- lose
zelda- win
zss- lose?
Some interesting notes here that could be good discussion I think would be is I think Lucario is one of our worst MUs, I think we lose to jifflypuff, I'm not sure what to think of greninja, olimar, or lucas, I think we lose to yoshi, pikachu seems evenish, i've only ever played one little mac ever that made me think that MU was bad for us but it was back in december so I don't know if other little macs haven't caught on to the MU or if I just got better at it, as I said I think GaW beats Villager.
Also, I feel like lylat is an autoban vs any small character. I played a greninja on it and it felt really bad just because greninja has one of, if not, the lowest standing animations in the game and a lot of his moves put him very low to the ground, very hard to to hit him with slingshots and stuff. I don't mind it vs tall or fat characters, in some MUs I like it, but vs smaller chars it just seems really bad to me.