Honestly, I think things improved a lot.
Back in the day, I started to support Robin only after I randomly stumbled around the forums out of boredom and saw this thread. I did not think there was an actually realistic chance for them to make it, but I really liked them in Awakening and the idea of the character in Smash for their diversity.
Nowadays I actually do believe Robin is the most likely FE newcomer, even with the gematsu leak looking pretty accurate. Heck, even if Chrom is actually in the game, I don't see any reason why we couldn't have 4 FE characters, and having both Chrom and Robin would actually be a nice parallel to Awakening.
So I've basicly found hope out of nothing. And even if Robin won't make it into Smash, I at least had a good time talking about them here.
XD I feel kind of bad when I think about it.
When I first came into here, I told @
Gingerbread Man
how bad the OP was, how he was over-complicating the character, and how everyone was wrong about the likelihood of her appearing. When I came into here, originally while I loved Robin a lot in Awakening, I couldn't see the point in adding her. While she is a spell-caster, I don't think that inherently made her unique, since anyone with magic can more or less shape it into whatever they want. The concept behind magic is making the impossible possible, after all.
Honestly? Truly? While I can now say Robin has a host of valid play styles, I still don't think she is "special" in the grand scheme of things. No doubt she is far more valuable than the majority of the Fire Emblem leads prior to her, being a spell-caster, lacking the characteristics of royalty (attire and presentation), and just IMO being one of the coolest looking leads. That said, she is just that; a Fire Emblem character. Smash Bros could only have Marth as a playable character and I wouldn't flinch. When I try to think of good characters for Smash Bros, I look at a combination of representing the widest scope of Nintendo history as possible, while at the same time having something unique. Ike hails from Radiant Dawn, which is really only from a mere generation prior.
Looking at current newcomers, Villager is one of the brightest stars. In many ways, he traces back to the N64 era, and represents not just a different series, but comes from a simulation game. Comparatively, Robin more or less is just an amnesiac, bound-by-fate, descendant of some great deity, stock RPG character just like any other. Subjective, of course, but I would say she is still a way better character than a lot of suggestions regardless. Even compared to characters from similar origins, she has plenty of advantages, and hailing from Awakening means she would be quite the crowd-pleaser as well.
She isn't unique as a video game character, but unique enough that she will have an easy time differentiating herself from other fighters. Certainly will help Fire Emblem's brand image considerably, which is a huge plus.