• Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!

    You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!

Tier lists: by stage

KoRoBeNiKi

Smash Hero
Writing Team
Joined
Apr 26, 2007
Messages
5,959
Location
Brooklyn, NY
Slippi.gg
KORO#668
Tier lists: By stage

As per the community not caring, only Hyrule and Dreamland are required (Congo Jungle/Peach's Castle, what stage?).

Note that this is NOT sponsored by the backroom, this is just a separate thread before you ask.
I just want to conduct this from a statistical purpose and that is all to see people's differing opinions. This is also to make it so character discussions about tier lists (see Link discussion for examples) go in a central topic.

It seems that people have varying tier lists, though specifically on stages. I'll compile them and form an average per stage after let's say 20-25 people post or something or more depending on how active this is.

Please note that I am not looking for matchup discussion outside of small chit-chat concerning others opinions. This only concerns this one concept. Matchup discussions go in the character matchup thread(s).

I would prefer that Congo is added as it is the 3rd neutral but it is not required.

Please construct them like this. Please give reasoning if possible. Copy/paste these:

Hyrule
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
Dreamland
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
 

Han Solo

Banned via Warnings
Joined
Nov 9, 2011
Messages
1,277
Location
Midwest Corellia
I should note that I didn't put much thought past the top 6 for each stage.

Hyrule- Rat is number one because rat. Fox is just about even with Pika because of laser camping, tent, and less chance of gimping. Kirby, Falcon, Mario, and Yoshi are all very close. Link is helped out greatly because of the size of the stage.
1 Pikachu
2 Fox
3 Kirby
4 Falcon
5 Mario
6 Yoshi
7 Link
8 DK
9 Puff
10 Ness
11 Luigi
12 Samus

Dreamland - Gimpland. Pika and Kirby reign supreme because the stage is very small compared to Hyrule. Falcon can gimp most characters at 60%. Fox is still pretty good, but he is hurt a lot by the top three's gimp game. Mario is pretty even with Fox I'd say, but I'd give Fox the advantage. Link is hurt the most because of a lack of recovery and very little space for projectiles.
1 Pikachu
2 Kirby
3 Falcon
4 Fox
5 Mario
6 Yoshi
7 DK
8 Luigi
9 Puff
10 Ness
11 Samus
12 Link

Congo Jungle
1 Pikachu
2 Kirby
3 Falcon
4 Fox
5 Mario
6 Yoshi
7 DK
8 Puff
9 Ness
10 Luigi
11 Samus
12 Link

Peach's Castle
1 Pikachu
2 Kirby
3 Fox
4 Mario
5 Falcon
6 Yoshi
7 Luigi
8 DK
9 Puff
10 Ness
11 Samus
12 Link
 

The Star King

Smash Hero
Joined
Nov 6, 2007
Messages
9,681
For stages that aren't Dreamland or Hyrule - like usual, people are not going to know what they're talking about, but are going to attempt to talk about it anyways and craft some BS lists based on a few moments of internal theorycrafting/simply imagining their performance on these stages.

Humans are very bad at admitting their ignorance to themselves, and it irritates me.
 

KoRoBeNiKi

Smash Hero
Writing Team
Joined
Apr 26, 2007
Messages
5,959
Location
Brooklyn, NY
Slippi.gg
KORO#668
Then post only Dreamland and Hyrule. Should I just delete the "joke" stages?

I also find it a bit ridiculous that we do not know anything about a neutral.
 

The Star King

Smash Hero
Joined
Nov 6, 2007
Messages
9,681
I might. And that's up to you.

And yeah, but that's the result of most of the community avoiding Congo Jungle for some reason.
 

KoRoBeNiKi

Smash Hero
Writing Team
Joined
Apr 26, 2007
Messages
5,959
Location
Brooklyn, NY
Slippi.gg
KORO#668
I am just wondering your honest opinion. I realize that people dislike those stages. I think I might as well but I'll wait for your opinion. Also post your Hyrule/DL please.

I will delete them for now for your reasons. I do find them valid. If people do want to post, be my guest.
 

The Star King

Smash Hero
Joined
Nov 6, 2007
Messages
9,681
If I ever do it I'll do it later, don't wanna do it now :C

/procrastinating

And even for Hyrule and Dreamland I feel rather unsure about, because I haven't thought about it much (or rather, I haven't payed much attention while playing). That's why I think my BR tier list was terrible BTW, I haven't thought about it much and I basically submitted the old one with Fox and Kirby switched. But after that I started paying more attention in-game to how the characters function and also thought about how their match-ups are as a whole, and now I'm pretty sure about stuff like Link > Ness > Luigi ~= Samus
 

M!nt

Smash Champion
Joined
Jan 26, 2011
Messages
2,087
omg I typed a long list and then bam 502 Bad Gateway :mad:
 

M!nt

Smash Champion
Joined
Jan 26, 2011
Messages
2,087
Hyrule
1 Pika
2 Fox
3 Link
4 Kirby
5 Captain Falcon
6 Mario
7 Jigglypuff
8 Yoshi
9 Ness
10 Donkey Kong
11 Samus
12 Luigi

Dreamland
1 Pika
2 Kirby
3 Captain Falcon
4 Mario
5 Fox
6 Yoshi
7 Donkey Kong
8 Jigglypuff
9 Luigi
10 Link
11 Samus
12 Ness

Congo Jungle sucks

Peach's Castle
1 Pika
2 Kirby
3 Mario
4 Captain Falcon
5 Fox
6 Jigglypuff
7 Samus
8 Yoshi
9 Luigi
10 Ness
11 Donkey Kong
12 Link

The Best Stage(AKA Saffron)
1 Pika
2 Fox
3 Kirby
4 Mario
5 Captain Falcon
6 Jigglypuff
7 Donkey Kong
8 Yoshi
9 Link
10 Luigi
11 Samus
12 Ness

lol @ my lists
 

WOTG

Banned via Warnings
Joined
Feb 16, 2009
Messages
710
Location
Katy, Texas
Hyrule
1. Pikachu
2. Fox
3. Link
4. Kirby
5. Mario
6. Falcon
7. Jigglypuff
8. Yoshi
9. DK
10. Ness
11. Samus
12. Luigi

Dreamland
1. Pikachu
2. Kirby
3. Falcon
4. Mario
5. Yoshi
6. Fox
7. DK
8. Jigglypuff
9. Ness
10. Luigi
11. Samus
12. Link
 

tacos

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Sep 19, 2010
Messages
459
Location
Brownsville, Texas
meh... rough draft of teh lists.
might edit them later
/need to add congo and peaches castle

Hiderule


1 Pikachu
2 Fox
3 Mario
4 Kirby
5 Falcon
6 Link
7 DK
8 Yoshi
9 Luigi
10 Jigglypuff
11 Ness
12 Samus

Gimpland

1 Pikachu
2 Kirby
3 Falcon
4 Mario
5 Yoshi
6 Fox
7 DK
8 Luigi
9 Jigglypuff
10 Samus
11 Ness
12 Link
 

asianaussie

Smash Hero
Joined
Mar 14, 2008
Messages
9,337
Location
Sayonara Memories
For stages that aren't Dreamland or Hyrule - like usual, people are not going to know what they're talking about, but are going to attempt to talk about it anyways and craft some BS lists based on a few moments of internal theorycrafting/simply imagining their performance on these stages.

Humans are very bad at admitting their ignorance to themselves, and it irritates me.
hello i am a poster in the melee tier list thread how may i be of service
 

M!nt

Smash Champion
Joined
Jan 26, 2011
Messages
2,087
Samus's best stage is Peach's Castle imo, dair ****.
 

asianaussie

Smash Hero
Joined
Mar 14, 2008
Messages
9,337
Location
Sayonara Memories
samus has some semblance of a recovery with her ledge grab game, automatically disqualifying peach's as her possible best stage

hyrule is probably her best stage since attrition etc
 

ballin4life

Smash Hero
Joined
Nov 12, 2008
Messages
5,534
Location
disproving determinism
Fox #3 on Peach's = WTF. I always go Pika on Peach's (and there's one specific Kirby that I play in every tourney who always CPs me to Peach's castle).

I've been thinking Falcon vs Pika on DL is an even matchup, but I guess Kirby still counters Falcon there ...


Made these off top of my head and I'm very open to being convinced otherwise:

Dreamland:

S
Pika
Kirby
Falcon

A
Mario (FUSK)
Yoshi
Fox
DK
Jiggs

B
Ness
Luigi
Samus
Link


Hyrule:

S
Pika
Fox

A
Falcon
Kirby

B
Mario
Link
Yoshi

C
Jiggs
DK
Ness

D
Luigi
Samus


(collapsed duplicates in the format Koro wanted)

Dreamland:

1 Pika
2 Kirby
3 Falcon
4 Mario
5 Yoshi
6 Fox
7 DK
8 Jiggs
9 Ness
10 Luigi
11 Samus
12 Link

Hyrule:

1 Pika
2 Fox
3 Falcon
4 Kirby
5 Mario
6 Link
7 Yoshi
8 Jiggs
9 DK
10 Ness
11 Luigi
12 Samus
 

Battlecow

Play to Win
Joined
May 19, 2009
Messages
8,740
Location
Chicago
Hyshouldnotbelegalrule

1. Pika
2. Fox
3. Kirby
4. Falcon
5. Mario
6. Yoshi
7. DK
8. Jigglypuff
9. Ness
10. Link
11. Luigi
12. Samus

Dreamonlygoodstageland

1. Pika
2. Kirby
3. Falcon
4. Mario (I actually think mario does better on hyrule overall, but fox is so good on hyrule that he drops a spot)
5. Fox
6. Yoshi
7. DK
8. Jigglypuff
9. Ness
10. Luigi
11. Samus
12. Link

I'm probably very wrong about link being so very bad on DL, but eh, personal experience and all that. If you wanna value my list anywhere near as highly as boom's, that's your problem not mine.
 

#HBC | ѕoup

The world is not beautiful, therefore it is.
Joined
Sep 15, 2010
Messages
6,865
Hyrule
1 Pika
2 Fox
3 Falcon
4 Mario
5 Kirby
6 DK
7 Yoshi
8 Jigglypuff
9 Ness
10 Link
11 Luigi
12 Samus

Dreamland
1 Pika
2 Kirby
3 Falcon
4 Fox
5 Mario
6 Yoshi
7 DK
8 Ness
9 Jigglypuff
10 Luigi
11 Samus
12 Link
 

KoRoBeNiKi

Smash Hero
Writing Team
Joined
Apr 26, 2007
Messages
5,959
Location
Brooklyn, NY
Slippi.gg
KORO#668
compiling people, just not posting as to not increase my post count too much...oh wait :awesome: Might edit later

I should post my own though
Hyrule
1. Some broken character, I mean Pikachu
2. Foks
3. Kirby
4. Doug
5. Link (barely)
6. Mario
7. Yoshi
8. DK
9. Jigglypuff
10. Ness
11. Luigi
12. Some bad character, I mean Samus

Dreamland
1. Pikachu
2. Kirby
3. Falcon
4. Fox
5. Mario
6. DK
7. Yoshi
8. Jiggs
9. Ness
10. Luigi
11. Link
12. Samus
 

The Star King

Smash Hero
Joined
Nov 6, 2007
Messages
9,681
Battlecow is it just me or did you copypasta the old tier list for your Hyshouldbelegalrule list
 

Olikus

Smash Champion
Joined
Nov 12, 2009
Messages
2,451
Location
Norway
Hyshouldnotbelegalrule

1. Pika
2. Fox
3. Kirby
4. Falcon
5. Mario
6. Yoshi
7. DK
8. Jigglypuff
9. Ness
10. Link
11. Luigi
12. Samus

Dreamonlygoodstageland

1. Pika
2. Kirby
3. Falcon
4. Mario (I actually think mario does better on hyrule overall, but fox is so good on hyrule that he drops a spot)
5. Fox
6. Yoshi
7. DK
8. Jigglypuff
9. Ness
10. Luigi
11. Samus
12. Link

I'm probably very wrong about link being so very bad on DL, but eh, personal experience and all that. If you wanna value my list anywhere near as highly as boom's, that's your problem not mine.
Who Else should be last on DL than link?

:phone:
 

Peek~

Smash Lord
Joined
Dec 9, 2007
Messages
1,284
Location
˙͜ >˙
DL
S: Pikachu, Falcon
A: Kirby, Fox
B: Mario, Yoshi, Ness, DK, Jiggly, Samus
C: Link, Luigi

I cant figure out how B should be ordered.
Dreamland is Ness best stage.
 

The Star King

Smash Hero
Joined
Nov 6, 2007
Messages
9,681
^The "Red" from Kaillera is a Kirby main. HOW DID I NOT MAKE THAT CONNECTION

If you disagree, read the quote and talk to star king, he'll back me up.
Who can argue with those vids

Also huh you put Yoshi above Mario on both lists HOLY CRAP DO YOU THINK YOSHI MIGHT BE BETTER THAN MARIO I'M NOT THE ONLY ONE FINALLY I CAN COME OUT OF THE CLOSET ABOUT THIS OH GOD YES YOU'RE MY BEST FRIEND FOREVER
 

Olikus

Smash Champion
Joined
Nov 12, 2009
Messages
2,451
Location
Norway
I want to hear some opinions why people think yoshi is better than mario on hyrule.

You reading this aa? oli can ask nicely too.
 
Top Bottom