The SkyWorld Legality Discussion -->

[flyingpork002]

oh no don't get me wrong i love the Dair spikes thru the clouds, but more often than not its me on the gimped end than the opponent, just not a good ganon level for me.

no level is a good gannon level, he gets ***** on every level

 

[da K.I.D.]

Hanenbow isn't banned.. and rainbow cruise doesn't take the focus off fighting.. ever recall playing on PokeFloats...

QFT


Skyworld may be really annoying, and you all may hate it (i personally love it) but that is not enuff to warrent a ban

 

[popsofctown]

I can't stand how much it slows down some characters attacks, because they are dealing damage to the platforms. Ness' downsmash takes about a year.

 

[Krakatoa]

Btw.. Would MuteCity have been banned in melee if tether characters had existed back then?

but there wasn't, it's completely different, there is a major disavantage to tether characters in this stage and it would be really good if they ban this stage

 

[Ch0zen0ne]

It doesn't matter if there wasn't.. i asked a question... if tether toons were in melee would mutecity have been banned?

yes?

or

no?

 

[Rapid_Assassin]

I hate the stage, but I'm biased (tether recovery). The only thing I see about it being ban worthy is the "cave" and "loop" in the stage. Do we really want to see 27 minute long 1 stock matches of Pit vs. ROB because they can get back from anywhere and just tech the walls over and over?

 

[Ch0zen0ne]

Anyone can tech the walls, and ROB/Pit can also BOTH be wall spiked... ROB is actually surprisingly bouncy for such a large character.. and Pit is just light as F*ck.

 

[Metal]

It doesn't matter if there wasn't.. i asked a question... if tether toons were in melee would mutecity have been banned?

yes?

or

no?

Is that a joke? Because I don't get it; you couldn't wall-grapple Mute City.

And why do you keep bringing up other stages? If you're going to make a point through another stage, just state the concept without specific names. You're supposed to counter points, not rant on a totally different matter...

Skyworld has the unique problem of being an automatic Stage Spike or a Cave of Life. The bad thing is the two go hand in hand; if the stage isn't one, then it probably is the other. Those floating side platforms? They can be walls.

 

[Homelessvagrant]

It doesn't matter if there wasn't.. i asked a question... if tether toons were in melee would mutecity have been banned?

yes?

or

no?

This is just stupid, what does mute city have to do with skyworld, asking ifs doesn't solve the haves. What if mute city was banned...would it prove anything? This isn't a discussion on whether a stage is fun or not, but a discussion on whether it's tournament worthy or not.

And tethers is hardly he reason for the stage to be banned. You have been brought informations, been shown videos, I believe even shown pictures (or was that in another thread) on how every character that isn't pit or Rob get gimped by the stage. This is by chance occurances bought about when the stage doesn't clue in to a thrid jump or when the stage rebuilds gimping someones recovery. We've discussed the cave of life and the loop of non ending matches, and the by chance saving platform at the bottom that can screw or save players (by chance).

Now please, tell me how can you see so many errors in a stage and still debate this issue. Do you not know when to give up? This whole debate is really getting stupid now.

 

[Ch0zen0ne]

The purpose of bringing up MuteCity was tethers.. you nailed it on the head... the purpose of making that point was to show that it is an unrealistic argument to ban a stage to assist other characters in keeping the game "even".. counterpicks are COUNTERPICKS b/c they are chosen to COUNTER the other characters and give the current character advantage..

 

[PKPower]

Why does anyone care about Skyworld anyways? It's just a dreadful stage. If someone chose that on Wifi I would leave the match. Just play on the said "Neutral" stages that everyone likes like FD, Smashville, Yoshi's Island (Brawl), and Battlefield? Stages that give unfair disadvantages and advantages to some characters like Skyworld are just bad.

 

[Mezase Master]

You leave a match because someone picks a stage you don't like? Wow, that's childish.

 

[xepherthree]

You leave a match because someone picks a stage you don't like? Wow, that's childish.

Mario Bros... No.

 

[Amazing Ampharos]

Let's have less of the necrobumping here.