I played both games mainly brawl at a competitive level. SlayerZ, Samsora, Crow, and other Peaches had long agreed with me that peach was much better in brawl than smash 4. They took an insane amount of her options from brawl to smash 4 because the overall game got a slow down which in turn adjusted her position on "the tier list" but if you were to put brawl peach against smash 4 peach Brawl Peach would win everytime in the hands of a competent peach user.
You want facts:
Fair no longer auto canceled at a good frameand received a ton of lag.
LIFT got nerfed
Back air got a hitbox size reduction and active frame nerf
Jab received an end lag increase
Nair got a hitbox reduction and active frame nerf
Free pull removed
No glide tossing
Float cancel movement severly nerfed due to jump squat lag increase
Smash 4 buffs
Fair has kill power
Dash attack can kill
Float cancel fast fall (a nerfed version from brawl)
Dtilt footstool and turnip footstool
I can go on and on because I know both Peaches very well. She is my main so I took the time to learn all of that.
You want to argue with those facts. Learn them and test them for yourself and you will see Peach has an insane amount of opportunity in Brawl than she does in Smash 4. Constant nerf after nerf from Brawl to Smash 4. It was very sad. Hopefully it gets better in Ultimate which it looks like it kind of is. At least a foot in the right direction.
I dont think you understand my post at all. I'm not even disagreeing they took away many of her tools (which is what you called "nerfed") and I'm not disagreeing that if you put Brawl Peach against Smash4 Peach Brawl will win almost always. But there's one basic concept, which was what my post was about, that you seem to ignore all the time:
A character's strength is based on their strength compared to other characters in the same game (NOT compared to the previous version if a character).
Since you seem to like giving lists of facts, here you have a relevant one:
- It makes no sense to determine whether they nerfed or buffed Peach by comparing SSB4 Peach to Brawl Peach in a vacuum.
- Sure, they gave SSB4 a lot of "nerfs" but EVERY character a loooot of nerfs and what happens if everyone gets nerfed harder than Peach? She will come out stronger than the rest and because her matchups against the rest are better (she isnt better "because the game slowed down", I have no idea what that even means)
- In fact, at least 95% of the Brawl character will destroy their Smash4 counterpart. Even Smash4 Mario, who's top tier, will likely be destroyed by Brawl Mario if you put Brawl Mario is Smash4. That doesn't mean they "nerfed" Mario.
- Also, this means that even if Peach seems "buffed" in Ultimate right now, she could still be worse in Ultimate if all characters are buffed more. Currently, all characters seem to have gotten many buffs. Even characters that were already powerful such as Pikachu and Ryu. Peach is looking fine based on the limited info we have but it's still too early to celebrate.
(- Also, her jumpsquat never got increased. They only changed the minimun float height, but that had no consequences to the start-up of her ground float aerials.)
Either way based on the changes you have listed you mostly seem to miss how flexible Brawl Peach was compared to SSB4 Peach due to landing lag increases, so if that's the case, then Ultimate Paisy (and Ultimate in general) will be more for you. Ending lag has been decreased across the board and the game has been sped up from SSB4.