Shadow13
Smash Journeyman
- Joined
- May 27, 2009
- Messages
- 349
Okay, so you are saying that would be a right time to kill?Oops. I didn't realize their were other responses on the last page.
If God told me to kill someone, I probably would. Yes it would be murder. Would it be immoral? Not necessarily. You gotta remember, God called it off. It was just a test.
There really isn't anything used as evidence to support that besides The Bible, which contradicts itself a lot.It's an interesting idea, but it doesn't stand up to evidence for Eve being the first woman.
I would shoot the suicide bomber to save lives. If it was needed I would kill one of the twins to save the other.A lot of that is based on technicalities. A suicide bomber is about to blow himself up in front of a huge crowd, you included (this is all hypothetical, so let's say you're 100% sure it's a suicide bomber). You have a gun. Would you shoot him? (preferably in the head, so he can't pull the switch. and don't try the "this would never happen" excuse, because there are a lot of suicide bombers in Israel every month, and there's also a lot of Israeli soldiers, so I'm sure this has come up before) I would. It's self defense as well as the saving of many lives.
How about a story from a few years ago in the newspaper. It was titled, "Kill Mary to save Jodie?" (http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,997967,00.html). Two babies were just born. But they're Siamese twins, one had a functioning body, but the other didn't have a functioning heart or lung. She was depending on the other one to live. but together they could only live 6 months. if they were separated, however, one would live a normal life and the other would die. The parents, devout Christians, refused to have them separated, saying something like, "we know G-d will make a decision, and we're fine with whatever he chooses". However, the doctor pushed for the separation, and eventually won in court.
For reasons like that, maybe you guys should drop religious backup. I mean, I guess it's all subjective, but religion and the Bible are not evidence at all. Terrorists use the Koran to back up what they believe about American and Jew killing (although it must be said that they completely twist the words and put it so out of context that it doesn't even slightly resemble the point it was trying to make. kinda like what Christians do). Picking and choosing which verse to cite is unfair and stupid. there's a small section in the bible about how you should "Stone disobedient children" (Deuteronomy 21:18-21) (http://www.bigissueground.com/atheistground/ash-bibleshocking.shtml (even more humorous is it's one page after the overused quote, "If a man also lieth with mankind, as he lieth with a woman, both of them have committed an abomination; they shall surely be put to death; their blood shall be upon them" - Leviticus 20:13)). Even Evangelicals agree this does not make it right. Although prostitution is illegal in 49 states, from the link directly above, "Prostitution is punished by burning the woman alive according to Leviticus 21:9". yah...'nuff said.
How you were using Bible quotes to show how there are some crazy things they would wish to do to somebody for prostitution or whatnot is a good way to debate with somebody who only references religion.