So perhaps most of us here alreadyunderstand the gist of what I'm about to post, but I'mma post it here anyway as I intend to eventually post it elsewhere.
I'm calling this the "Sakurai's Cat" theory. ...Or phenomenon? Whatevs.
...And noo, not based on Sakurai's actual pet cat. It's a play on "Schrodinger's Cat".
Basically, A character at any point could have two or more roles in Smash until Sakurai confirms otherwise.
This can't apply to just any character. It needs to be a character that currently floats in the middle of unconfirmed and confirmed as a result of actual existing evidence. Naturally, Ridley falls into the category of being a "Sakurai's Cat". But why exactly?
Well the obvious thing comes to mind; Sakurai said "Samus's Trauma may appear...", or as it was translated, "An enemy from Samus's past may appear at any second...". The statements have been construed as either implying that Ridley would be a stage hazard or that it's just a reference to Other M.
And then there's the stage itself. I construed back when the Pyrosphere was first revealed that its layout was indicative of an arena fitting for a stage hazard to appear and attack the players. Since then I've rescinded my belief that Ridley was a guaranteed stage hazard. However my view on the Pyrosphere itself hasn't changed as much and thus continues to lead me skeptical about Ridley's true role.
...And that's what leads me to this wacky label of a theory that is "Sakurai's Cat"! As of currently, Ridley is PLAYABLE AND A STAGE HAZARD!
... No no, not based on Ridley's multiple incarnations. I mean based on my proposed Sakurai's Cat theory: Until official declaration by Sakurai himself, it should be acceptable that there will be only one Ridley in Smash, and he is CONFIRMED as PLAYABLE and as STAGE HAZARD simultaneously! But why exactly? I surmise the following:
- Sakurai once claimed "If we had put our best efforts into it, we may have been able to do it". This may possibly still apply even to this day, which means...
- Sakurai and Co. actually are putting their best effort in to it! However Sakurai is all too familiar with failing to get a character in, thus...
- The Pyrosphere's layout is designed as such to allow for a stage hazard... primarily Ridley!
- Should Sakurai and Co. fail at their effort to make Ridley a Newcomer, they only need to take the assets and mold them into a Stage Hazard. Should they succeed, the Pyrosphere still looks good enough to be a neutral stage.
It's why I think it's taking so long for Sakurai to just get it over with and announce Ridley as a hazard: There's a chance Sakurai SUCCEEDED. Otherwise it would be so easy to just call the attempt unsuccessful, reallocate resources, and show off a stage hazard Ridley. They could continue working on him afterward too, so no need for him to be near 100% if just a hazard.
So until Sakurai opens up the proverbial box and reveals the state of the cat inside, technically this means everyone is correct AND incorrect on the matter. Unless you think Ridley is an Assist Trophy. If you do, LOL get out of this thread.
BTW, this also applies to Palutena thanks to that leak that hasn't been disproven. Palutena is effectively unconfirmed AND confirmed right now.