No it wouldn't, no new characte
r is definitely the easier option. Dark Samus is also only really important to the Prime games, as opposed to the whole series. Because Metroid is so focused on Samus, the only other option as far as 'significant' characters go is Ridley. If Sakurai doesn't see Ridley working as a playable fighter, which is most likely the case, then the remaining option is that Metroid continues to be represented by Samus and Zero Suit Samus.
I know no new character is the easier option, that's what I meant I was afraid of. I probably stated it in a confusing manner, when I said easy alternative I didn't mean easier than nothing. I meant easier than Ridley. And yeah, Dark Samus was only important to the prime games, but look how much representation they've gotten in Smash in the past, and they are also the last well received Metroid thing. I never thought Dark Samus had a chance at playability, but it did get some decent recognition, especially after not having been an assist trophy last game.
But I have to agree with your last point, if Ridley isn't playable, I don't think I see Metroid getting a new rep. A little disappointing to me, but there really aren't any other feasible mainstay characters.
The only thing I'll disagree with is that you say it's most likely that Sakurai doesn't see Ridley working. He's said on record that he could make Ridley work. I'm not saying it's likely Ridley's playable either. I'm just saying we really don't know at this point, and we know Sakurai has changed his mind about quite a few things from brawl to now.
Seriously, just leave, don't start things like this in the RIDLEY SUPPORT thread, go back to what you do best, spectate
Hey, calm down. It's the Ridley discussion thread too. That means people with doubts can voice them in a non aggressive manner. That's what it sounded like he was doing to me.
If there is someone on this planet that could make Ridley work, it's Sakurai. I believe in his skills and experience, and trust him to work Ridley into a smaller shape like a blacksmith forges a sword.
Able to make work =/= going to do it
look what happened to Chrom. sure, it was a different situation. But the Chrom thread basically used your argument - if anyone can make Chrom unique, it's Sakurai. Sakurai recently told Famitus Chrom was just another boring sword fighter.
How would you solve the issue of flying/aerial dominant character having an overpowered recovery? Would he be able to fly freely but just be knocked really far? Would he have a stamina meter for flight? How would it work?
lots of characters in this game seem to have really long recoveries, or even buffed recoveries from brawl. Little mac is one of the few exceptions, because of his excellent ground game. I'd say having a huge recovery isn't too crazy to imagine, but I wouldn't think it'd be something central to his playstyle.