The Official SBR-B Brawl Tier List v3.0

[Cook Kirby]

Ike and Sonic are still WAY WAY too high imo.

I have to agree with you. Whilst Sonic mains are celebrating that impressive ascension up the list, I seriously cannot see why he moved so far. It seems to me to be almost a fan service. As for Ike, he didn't drop far enough in my opinion.

 

[Ishiey]

Wolf's placing in his tier along with the whole lucas>mario>ness thing are my two biggest questions. Overall though, looks pretty good, and the system seems a lot more accurate.

About the placing, I noticed that samus ranked worst out of all characters but higher among low tiers. This happened with some other characters too (ex. wolf ._.), can you put something in the OP clarifying the process and how those things happened and if/how the original rankings were taken into consideration?

 

[Red Arremer]

I think we need an Inui board now.

I support this notion. I also want an Inui icon for the profile.

 

[Ryusuta]

I can't believe I'm saying this, but... this tier list is actually not that bad. I can't find any serious points of disagreement. Nice job, guys.

 

[Suspect]

I have to agree with you. Whilst Sonic mains are celebrating that impressive ascension up the list, I seriously cannot see why he moved so far. It seems to me to be almost a fan service. As for Ike, he didn't drop far enough in my opinion.

That might be because of where you live, there are some sonic mains/users doing very well here

 

[gm jack]

No Zelda/Sheik? Other than that, it seems about right. Thought Sheik would be a spot or two higher, but other than that, seems decent.

 

[Anaky]

No i thought Link would be S tier, if not in his own tier in SS lol.

 

[etecoon]

I'm interested in your thoughts.

I don't see you on but I just think he avoids trouble a lot better than Snake, harder to combo, juggle, gimp, trap, I think he has much superior options in the disadvantaged state. I also think that he's safer overall...could be wrong, I need to play more wario, I'm much more knowledgeable about snake than wario so there might be some bias in that <_<

and how gay do you play(on brinstar )?

 

[Cook Kirby]

That might be because of where you live, there are some sonic mains/users doing very well here

Ah, yeah, that's a good point. And btw, I think Marth is gay.

 

[Red Arremer]

What do the numbers "mean" exactly? "Average" of what? Average number of votes? If so, why is having a higher number bad?

Is it so hard to understand how the voting process went? =/
Average of votes in points, and there were a certain amounts of grades a character could get. 1 is the best, and with higher points it gets worse.

I'd also like to see a list of people who voted.

Well, then keep on wanting, it won't happen.

No Zelda/Sheik? Other than that, it seems about right. Thought Sheik would be a spot or two higher, but other than that, seems decent.

I think I already told people in the "What to expect" thread that there will be no Z/S spot.

 

[gm jack]

You did. There was just always that slim chance you were messing with us.

Where about do people think a combined Z/S would go? My gut instinct is saying low B, but that it just looking at their combined matchups and picking the better one for each situation. However, a lot of them are outdated, so I know it isn't accurate.

 

[Red Arremer]

Well I wasn't, lol.

I'd say at the current metagame Z/S would be placed around B Tier-ish, maybe high end of C. The combo isn't all that developed yet and we don't see many people placing with it either.

 

[JayBee]

Wario in top 5 makes me happy. It makes me feel like all the effort we've made amounts to something, haha. Moving 5 spots through the best of the best is pretty massive.

i feel the same way about Sonic, X.

 

[Remzi]

I actually like this one. Falco is a bit high considering his lackluster tourney results. He should be one below Marth but w.e.

Also, Link > CF.

All in all, accurate list.

 

[Cook Kirby]

I'd put Z/S at about mid-to-low B Tier.

 

[Anaky]

I actually like this one. Falco is a bit high considering his lackluster tourney results. He should be one below Marth but w.e.

Also, Link > CF.

All in all, accurate list.

I agree with this, Marth is 4th for Europes tourney results after wario, pretty accurate overall.

 

[BMX]

Wario= 10,000 people picking him up. ^_^

Sonic= Amazing. lol I'm going to have steak now.

 

[Chis]

I knew Sonic would rise, about time.

 

[Suspect]

Wario= 10,000 people picking him up. ^_^

dang you caught me

 

[Power of Slash]

Wario is definately not going to get an influx of people playing him.

Just my thoughts.

 

[Red Arremer]

Wario is definately not going to get an influx of people playing him.

Just my thoughts.

And your thoughts are the truth.

 

[BMX]

dang you caught me

I think Marth is gay. I make it gayer by pooting on them. D:

 

[Shadowblazen]

Marth not S tier = strong disappointment
Wario +5 = thing I hate most about this new tier list
Game and Watch -3 !? = but the turtle ...
Captain Falcon = YES!

And lol, Meta Knight went down a tier.

 

[smashkng]

Marth not S tier = strong disappointment
Wario +5 = thing I hate most about this new tier list
Game and Watch -3 !? = but the turtle ...
Captain Falcon = YES!

And lol, Meta Knight went down a tier.

I think Wario is the 2nd best in Brawl, but in the past he was ranked lower due unpopularity because people didn't know how good he actually is.

 

[gm jack]

Marth not S tier = strong disappointment
Wario +5 = thing I hate most about this new tier list
Game and Watch -3 !? = but the turtle ...
Captain Falcon = YES!

And lol, Meta Knight went down a tier.

Wario is an excellent character, but is very hard to use correctly. He easily deserves 3rd place.

G&W suffers against the high tier characters. He destroys most people below him, but struggling against the top characters on top of a lack of placings is going to lead to a fall.

 

[BMX]

I think Wario is the 2nd best in Brawl, but in the past he was ranked lower due unpopularity because people didn't know how good he actually is.

I agree. I'm totally biased and agree that he shoud be 2nd. lol

Wario deserves this spot, but it's time to step it up.

 

[Willz]

I liked Falcon being bottom. Oh well I'll main Ganon as well now. =P

 

[Red Arremer]

Wouldn't that be Inui? XD

 

[Willz]

Inui is broken. Can't play him at all.

 

[BMX]

His Up-B is broken. Check it out. Twice the length of the shuttle loop. YOu play him and you lose all pride. -_-

 

[JayBee]

dont you guys think you are over doing it this inui stuff much? lol @ getting the tier list thread locked.

how do you unlock inui in brawl anyways? i've tried multiman brawl but no dice.

 

[Willz]

I heard his Neutral-B is broken as well. His nado takes up the whole screen & hits your characters weak point for massive damage! Any proof?

 

[jamzthehedgehog]

Yay sonic in mid tier! The hedgehog is finally acknowledged for his steak mind games. GO GO SONIC :D

 

[cp2]

Captain falcon for the top!!!

And i knew sonic wasn't low

 

[Willz]

Why is Sonic so high lol.
8 places up what the hell...

 

[Camalange]

This list is ridiculous.

gg Sonic mains, gg XD
All our work paid off...but 8 places higher?? All I can say is gg guys XD

But there's no way in hell Falcon is above Link and Ganon, nor is Link the second worst character in the game.

 

[Frown]

I still think the first one is the best.

 

[Dark Shifter]

hey frown, remember this?
http://www.smashboards.com/showthread.php?p=7465789#post7465789

let me know when you gonna toss over those 300 points

 

[Spelt]

D Tier header should've been blue ...
why does it go from green to bronze to purple?
-spaz-

 

[Camalange]

Oh yeah, silly Lucas, how'd you get above Mario and Ness you rascal!