Hahaha, I just love breakdowns. My name actually comes from the breakdown in the song "The Plot to Bomb the Handle" by A Day To Remember (I know ADTR is gay but whatever).
I agree so hard.
I wish they would just do it, but then again it's probably not very easy to write a song that's that good.
Breakdowns aren't bad. They are just often abused and not taken to their full potential. There are bands that will use at least 5-6 different breakdowns and ruin the punch they are supposed to have, OR they will throw some sort of cheeky synth over it to make it seem all artsy or something like that, when really they are also just sterilizing it. A breakdown should be not just a change of pace, but a physical and emotional sway in the song completely. For example, Parkway Drive's "Dark Days." The song does have some chugging in it, but it has an ending breakdown that shakes you, and there's no going back to the same feeling that you had earlier on in the track. Another good example in Rolo Tomassi's "French Motel". You understand the chaotic atmosphere that they are trying to bring right from the get-go, but the breakdown really brings that pandemonium home. The song then turns to a more heavy, dark tone compared to the lighter chaos taking place in the beginning.
Breakdowns aren't a bad thing, they just need to be used to their potential and not abused to all hell.
...here's looking at you, Rise Records bands.
Not gonna lie, I literally just did a vlog about this with my friend, the topic has come up quite a few times in conversations before.
Idk, for me it was Alaska, I didn't enjoy Mordecai as much until I heard it on the Colors Live DVD. That being said, I'm kinda glad they haven't tried to write more like their older stuff. I'd much rather them keep evolving along the path they're on, THEN do a re-recording of their self-titled and The Silent Circus, just for the hell of it.