I've been lurking this thread for a bit recently, and I'd like to thank Bowser Jr. supporters that are still around.
Bowser Jr. is my most wanted newcomer, and my second favorite character overall (Yoshi beats him, obviously), but after the Rosalina trailer, I was kinda, "Well, that sucks. There goes my most wanted guy, never knew how much it sucked to just be shot down like that." And for a while, I always thought he never had a chance after that. But after looking at this thread and thinking about it some more, I think he can still easily make it as a playable character. There are still plenty of things going in his favor.
- Pokemon had 6 representatives in Brawl, whereas Mario only had 4. Even Zelda had more than with 5 characters. Kinda weird than Pokemon and Zelda would beat out Nintendo's flagship and best selling series.
- Rosalina may hurt his chances, but I also think it kinda helps simultaneously. With Rosalina being revealed, Sakurai showed 5 Mario characters before 2013 even ended, knowing the game wouldn't be out for another year. Isn't it kinda weird he would show ALL of the characters of Nintendo's biggest series so quickly?
- New Super Mario Bros. Wii and U were 2 games that Bowser Jr. were prominent in, and they both came out after Brawl. The Wii game was even the 4th best selling game on the Wii, and U featured Bowser Jr. even moreso since he was the main obstable in the last level of the game and was featured in the final boss fight. Plus, I think it's cool that Rosalina could represent the Galaxy games (even though Jr. was kinda the secondary antagonist there), and Bowser Jr. could represent the New Super Mario Bros. games. Plus, knowing how well those games sell, they have to be getting some form of reprensentation in the game, like a stage or something.
- He's always had potential for a unique moveset, and his Paintbrush seems to be getting used again recently, in spin-off games like Mario Super Sluggers and Mario Golf: World Tour, although the latter could be too recent for Smash. And he still doesn't use his Paintbrush in the main series games. And anyone who says he would be too similar to Bowser is kinda wrong. Bowser uses brute force and weight to fight, Junior kinda does the opposite and uses weapons/mechs to do the work for him while staying away.
- It's not unheard of for 2 or more newcomers to a series. In Melee, Pikachu and Jiggs were accompanied by Mewtwo and Pichu, and in Brawl there was Lucario and Pokemon Trainer. Kirby got Meta Knight and Dedede. Mario got 3 newcomes with Peach, Bowser, and Dr. Mario (in Melee). And 2 of them were secret charcters, whereas Pokemon had 3 secret characters (talking about Melee). So why can't Mario have Rosalina and Bowser Jr.?
- Only 6 newcomers have been revealed so far.
http://www.smashbros.com/wii/en_us/characters/index.html In Brawl, there was 12 newcomers and 12 secret fighters. So there is still plenty of room for new characters, since 29 have been revealed already, and I assume Sakurai would follow the same trend and not show secret fighters until after the game comes out, so nobody gets spoiled. Even though he did already show characters that tend to be secret, such as Luigi and Marth. I know he said that he doesn't want the roster to be too big, but some characters are going to get cut, so more room for newcomers/secret newcomers.
- A lot of Bowser Jr's competition has been eliminated, being Waluigi and Toad (to a lesser extent).
- Even if he's not a playble character, I still think he warrants a role in the game, maybe Assist Trophy or Boss on a Bowser's Castle/New Super Mario Bros. stage. Obviously, I much prefer and think that he's a playable character.
Geez, I ranted a lot, sorry, I just love this little guy!
I just think I get my thoughts off better if I explain it fully, but I guess that translates into a wall of text.
On a completely unrelated note: Pink Gold Peach/Baby Rosalina > Bowser Jr./Diddy Kong...why...?