Jin being above Arakune is my personal opinion. I have a much easier time against every Arakune player i've played than against Jin players. Don't argue against that since its just my own opinion
However..
Yes. SBO has been the only major blazblue tourney since the console release. I would just think that people would actually wait for a couple of more major tournaments to happen before deciding to change the tier list. If their basing it off of that, then why is Rachel higher than Nu? Yea that makes complete sense right?
And about Carl..just because a couple of good players are really good with Carl does not mean Carl is automatically really good. Just those players are(Same goes for Mike Z and Tager. One player does not make a character :|)
In the end though, I'm sure all of you will agree that the game needs more time to develop before anything is certain. Right?
I have a much easier time against Falco than Ganondorf in every tournament I play in. In
my humble opinion... Ganondorf is better than Falco.
NYAA NYAA MY OPINION I R UNTOUCHABLE BLARGHARAGH.
SBO may be the first major tourney since
console release, but you have to remember that BlazBlue has been out since December of last year. (Maybe even earlier, I know I played BlazBlue over x-mas break at some time after it first came out). So Japan has had a good 9 months almost to get a fairly accurate tier list. Think about SF4, which came out at the beginning of the year for the US. We already have tier lists for that in the US that most people feel is already settling down.
Arcadia magazine is serious business when it comes to those tier lists, and while I personally don't have the greatest frame of reference for the matter considering my very limited knowledge on Rachel, I can imagine how she might be better than NU. I
do know she has a very good up close game with some serious mixups with the top, and she can space well with wind, and frogs and what not. I don't think anyone can match NU's stupid mid to far range game, and the ability to do incredibly simple 60-70%'s. But you can also destroy NU in a couple hits.
I don't really see how it could be outside the realm of possibility for her to be top in your mind.
And I don't think Carl is good simply because of a "Couple good players." There are exactly 3 character that can get out of the loops, and that's Rachel with the wind, Hakumen with his Drive counter, and Ragna. From what I understand, Ragna can only get out reliably if they grab and he breaks. I believe he has to wait out the air tech time anyway if he gets caught in the normal clap combo, and then that's still over 50% of his health gone. The other characters are boned, and forget about it against Bang or Tager (and I think maybe a couple other people) because he doesn't even have to air dash to get the next grab in, meaning he doesnt have to reset the loop at all once his air dash's are gone, giving them an opportunity to safely barrier burst. The loop isn't the biggest problem in and of itself, because average damage from the loop is like a Tager 720, or a Hakumen combo with maybe 3 or 4 seals, but the fact that it's relatively simple to combo into if you get in any sort of hit. There's really no strings attached.