The ‘Would you rather have in smash?’ game thread

[-crump-]

Return of Ice Climbers. They were my main in Brawl and I miss them a lot! Wobbling and chain grabbing should be removed, though.

Would you rather have Hyrule Castle 64 or Peach’s Castle 64 return?

 

[Mega Bidoof]

Hyrule Castle 64. It’s just a more cohesive stage that makes sense, as opposed to the random mess and Peach’s Castle floating in nowhere.

Would you rather have Goku or Spongebob be added?

 

[Jubileus57]

Believe it or not I'd much rather have Spongebob. I loathe Dragon Balls and love Spongebob ^^'

Would you rather have Daisy or Pauline playable?

 

[G-Unit]

Daisy; you can make Pauline a Midnight Bliss transformation for Mario in someone's Final Smash.

Should the menus in this next port be able to tilt, or not?

 

[CrusherMania1592]

EDIT: Jesus I got G-Unit'd

Be able to tilt



Would you rather have 20 unlockable characters or 20 unlockable stages?

 

[CannonStreak]

EDIT: Jesus I got G-Unit'd

Be able to tilt



Would you rather have 20 unlockable characters or 20 unlockable stages?

20 Unlockable characters.

Would you rather have more new Nintendo IP characters or more new Retro characters?

 

[G-Unit]

I'd rather have more new Retro characters.

Which assist trophy would be better: Knuckle Joe, or Ryo Sakazaki?

 

[Sprite]

Knuckle Joe, I love the Kirby enemies.

Would you rather have them cut Bayonetta or Cloud?

 

[CannonStreak]

Knuckle Joe, I love the Kirby enemies.

Would you rather have them cut Bayonetta or Cloud?

Cloud.

Would you rather have Ryu or a character from another fighting game series?

 

[RealLuigisWearPink]

Ryu can stay, doesn't get more iconic than that.

Would you rather Ice Climbers return but are competitively terrible or they come back as Assist Trophies?

 

[FamicomDisk]

I’d still prefer them as characters. After Sakurai said that they wanted to have them in 4, but couldn’t get them to work on the 3DS, it’d feel a little frustrating it they came back... and still weren’t characters again.

Would you rather have the Duck Hunt Dog or the Ice Climbers return?

 

[kylexv]

Ice Climbers probably.

Would you rather be able to toggle hazards on or off for stages or have a ranking system for online play.

 

[Johnknight1]

Toggle hazards on or off for stages. Matters more than having any ranked online system when custom online games exist.

Would you rather get your most wanted realistic newcomer in the game or get 5 reasonably popular newcomers?

 

[Meta_X]

Definitely gonna go selfish and, if Zero counts as reasonable enough, then I gotta pick him. If not him then I'd be ok with 5 general popular newcomers before pretty much any other personal pick.

Would you rather have Smash Run or Target Smash (the traditional platforming one, not the current angry birds one) return for the next Smash game?

 

[BlazingFireOmega]

Would you rather have Smash Run or Target Smash (the traditional platforming one, not the current angry birds one) return for the next Smash game?

Break the Targets, unless it's like brawls.

Who would you add as a Konami rep; Bomberman or Simon Belmont from Castlevania?

 

[Jeck]

Simon Belmont hands down. By the way, does he seem really ignored to you guys this time? I remember him being really popular as a Smash 4 pick.

Would you prefer they added Porky as a character or Jeff and Poo as costumes?

 

[ColietheGoalie]

Simon Belmont hands down. By the way, does he seem really ignored to you guys this time? I remember him being really popular as a Smash 4 pick.

Would you prefer they added Porky as a character or Jeff and Poo as costumes?

Porky as a character. Gotta bring in those villains!

Transformations return or roster cuts?

 

[RineYFD]

Transformations return.
If you had to pick between these two to be in Smash for a Kirby rep would you pick Adeleine from Kirby 64 packed full of Kirby references and could mean the return of old Kirby characters who aren't used nowadays if she's popular enough or Susie with Robobot mech because she's more recent?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Adeline

would you rather have a character you like from a game you don't, or a character you dislike from a game you do?

 

[FamicomDisk]

Adeline

would you rather have a character you like from a game you don't, or a character you dislike from a game you do?

Hm... I'm gonna go with a character I dislike from a game I like. I might not like the character, but if it's a game I like, then it gets more representation. Seems fair to me! I can't love every inclusion.

Would you rather have Pokémon Trainer return, putting Charizard, Ivysaur, and Squirtle back on him, or would you rather have Ivysaur and Squirtle join as their own characters, and Charizard return like that?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

the latter.

would you rather have a Sony character or a Microsoft (non-Rare) character?

 

[Sprite]

If Crash counts as a Sony character than that option, I feel like he'd fit into smash perfectly.


Would you rather have Steve from Minecraft of Sans from Undertale as newcomers?

 

[RealLuigisWearPink]

Steve for actually being on Nintendo

Would you rather have Ridley playable but as a Bowser clone or King K. Rool playable but as a Bowser clone?

 

[PixelSun]

Steve for actually being on Nintendo

well undertale was announced recently for the switch ya' know

Would you rather have Ridley playable but as a Bowser clone or King K. Rool playable but as a Bowser clone?

King K. Rool. Ridley can wait.

Would you rather have a new Mother character or an Undertale / Lisa character?

 

[RineYFD]

well undertale was announced recently for the switch ya' know

King K. Rool. Ridley can wait.

Would you rather have a new Mother character or an Undertale / Lisa character?

Mother.
Would you rather have Tails who has an original moveset and we can make Mario and Luigi Vs. Sonic and Tails dreams happen or Eggman but Eggman's a semi-Bowser Jr clone but has a Death Egg Robot final smash and is a villain for the Sonic series?

 

[Sprite]

Tails, I feel like he's more important than eggman


Would you rather have ivysaur or dark pit return?

 

[ColietheGoalie]

Tails, I feel like he's more important than eggman


Would you rather have ivysaur or dark pit return?

Ivysaur, for sure. I miss him being on the roster.

20 unbalanced newcomers, or 5 newcomers and the roster is balanced perfectly?

 

[Freduardo]

Tails, I feel like he's more important than eggman


Would you rather have ivysaur or dark pit return?

Dark Pit if he gets his staff and luigifies. Otherwise, Ivy.

I got ninja’d

Ivysaur, for sure. I miss him being on the roster.

20 unbalanced newcomers, or 5 newcomers and the roster is balanced perfectly?

20 unbalanced. At the end of brawl there was a reason I was playing the hacked version with 90 unbalanced characters. As OP as Sephiroth and Riku were.

 

[Jeck]

Okay I guess I'll keep the ball rolling, I'm still enjoying this thread quite a bit.

Would you rather see them add Goldeneye James Bond (cut from Melee) or Tetra (cut from Brawl) as playable?

 

[ObeseCity]

Tetra, but I'd lose my mind if Bond was announced.

Would you rather they add Reggie-fils-Aime or the Wii Safety Man as a joke character?

 

[kylexv]

Wii Safety Man. At least he's a video game character.

Would you rather have a 40 character roster with 5 new characters or a 50 character roster with no new characters.

 

[PixelSun]

Would you rather have a 40 character roster with 5 new characters or a 50 character roster with no new characters.

50 IF they are completely rebalanced, if not just 40 characters w/ 5 newcomers.

Would you rather have ICs to return or Wolf?

 

[nirvanafan]

50 IF they are completely rebalanced, if not just 40 characters w/ 5 newcomers.

Would you rather have ICs to return or Wolf?

Ice Climbers since they are more unique, also I really appreciate your avatar

would you rather 10 new comers with no 3rd party or 5 new comer with 1 or 2 newcomers

 

[BlazingFireOmega]

would you rather 10 new comers with no 3rd party or 5 new comer with 1 or 2 newcomers

I'm guessing the last one was 5 newcomers with 1 or 2 3rd parties. Pick that one.

Keep one Capcom rep: MegaMan or Ryu?

 

[CannonStreak]

Mega Man.

Would you rather have the Fan item or Cracker Launcher back?

 

[Jeck]

Fan. And give me the flipper, the red shell, the old proxy mine, and fries with that.

Would you rather see a quality trailer reveal for every newcomer or just have it all inside the game as a disjoint cutscene for some adventure mode?

 

[BlazingFireOmega]

Would you rather see a quality trailer reveal for every newcomer or just have it all inside the game as a disjoint cutscene for some adventure mode?

I don't like how reveal trailers kinda spoil stuff, but I'll still choose that because of the quality of Smash 4's trailers.

Would you rather replace Kirby's current moveset with one that uses his copy abilities or have a Kirby rep like Gooey to use that moveset and leave kirby the same?

 

[-crump-]

I don't like how reveal trailers kinda spoil stuff, but I'll still choose that because of the quality of Smash 4's trailers.

Would you rather replace Kirby's current moveset with one that uses his copy abilities or have a Kirby rep like Gooey to use that moveset and leave kirby the same?

Add a Kirby rep that can use copy abilities. Gooey would be a fun pick, even if I’d prefer someone like Magolor or Marx, personally.

Would you rather have a playable rep from Pushmo or Code Name: S.T.E.A.M.?

 

[RineYFD]

Add a Kirby rep that can use copy abilities. Gooey would be a fun pick, even if I’d prefer someone like Magolor or Marx, personally.

Would you rather have a playable rep from Pushmo or Code Name: S.T.E.A.M.?

Code Name S.T.E.AM seemed more interesting to me then Pushmo.
If you had to pick between these two to return would you pick Young Link with his mask transformations or Toon Link with some of his weapons from Wind Waker?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Toon Link, but still a clone.

would you rather have Ridley in accurate size, or Olimar in accurate size?