The ‘Would you rather have in smash?’ game thread

[Freduardo]

Big roster as log as everyone works and there's a good variance

Would you rather King K. Rool and Ridley get in as a Ice Climbers-like duo with each other, or they get in individually but as Marth clones?

I guess ice climber duo. Better than Marth clones.

Would you rather have a Pokémon trainer that cycles between Meowth, Liepard, and Delcatty; or a Pokémon trainer that cycles between Houndour, Arcanine, and Stoutland? (Dogs vs cats)

 

[Meta_X]

Would you rather have a Pokémon trainer that cycles between Meowth, Liepard, and Delcatty; or a Pokémon trainer that cycles between Houndour, Arcanine, and Stoutland? (Dogs vs cats)

Normally I'm a cat person but those dog choices seem more interesting to me. However if you replaced two of the cats with Luxray/Luxio/Shinx and Litten/Torracat then I'd be all for it.

Would you rather Classic mode played classical music as its soundtrack or All-Star mode played All Star by Smash Mouth the entire time?

 

[nirvanafan]

classical

would you rather have no battlefield or final destination or have every stage be battlefield or final destination with a different skin.

 

[Olo]

I would rather have no Battlefield or Final Destination.

Would you rather have no story mode, or a literal exact remake of Subspace from Brawl?

 

[Fire Emblemier]

Literal exact remake of brawl's Subspace Emissary. That means Snake would return lol.

Would you rather have the ability to play co-op "singleplayer" modes like All Star and events online or an updated For Glory where there are more stages than Final Destination

 

[Granite Countertop]

I would rather have the single-player modes available online.

Would you rather....

1) Have a BoTW-themed moveset replace Link's moveset entirely.
2) Have Toon Link removed from the roster, making room for BoTW Link as a completely separate character from the "Classic Link".

 

[RealLuigisWearPink]

I enjoy Toon Link so overhaul regular Link (Toon will keep the old moveset alive anyhow)

Would you rather the Ouendan cheer squad be an Assist Trophy or the Elite Beat Agents be an Assist Trophy?

 

[nirvanafan]

Elite Beat Angels

Would you rather have Banjo as a playable character but the only Rare representation or have a bunch of Rare IP (Conker, Perfect Dark, etc. and still Banjo) make it in with other roles (stage, items, etc. and obviously trophies).

 

[BlazingFireOmega]

Would you rather have Banjo as a playable character but the only Rare representation or have a bunch of Rare IP (Conker, Perfect Dark, etc. and still Banjo) make it in with other roles (stage, items, etc. and obviously trophies).

I don't see how you can have a Rare rep without a stage and stuff but I'm gonna say Banjo

Arms rep or Xenoblade 2 rep?

 

[Basty]

Xenoblade 2 rep, mainly Rex

Would you rather see Lucina with a new moveset or Dark Pit with a new moveset

 

[waddledeeonredyoshi]

Dark Pit, he just has more potential.

Would you rather see the return of tripping or Smash tour again instead of a proper adventure mode?

 

[RineYFD]

Infernape. It’s goku in Smash.

Would you rather rather have a Star Trek character or a Star Wars character in Smash?

If you are interested I have a Infernape support thread. https://smashboards.com/threads/infernape-the-fire-fighting-monkey-blazes-it-up-in-smash.453843/

Dark Pit, he just has more potential.

Would you rather see the return of tripping or Smash tour again instead of a proper adventure mode?

Smash Tour. At least it's optional not to play Smash Tour.

 

[RineYFD]

Also would if you had to pick between Shovel Knigth or Shantae who would you pick?

 

[Llort A. Ton]

Also would if you had to pick between Shovel Knigth or Shantae who would you pick?

Shovel Knight!
Would you rather this game
1. Has tons of new content, but you have to re purchase the DLC from the last game, or
2. Has all the DLC from the last game, but you have to pay extra for all new content besides Inklings?

 

[nirvanafan]

Repurchase past DLC

Would you have Pokemon Trainer return or have Charizard remain an independent fighter

 

[Garteam]

Charizard as an independent fighter

Would you have Crash or Doom Guy for a western third party rep?

 

[CaptainAmerica]

...Crash, but realistically I really want Dovahkiin for a western 3rd party.

Would you rather have CDs back to unlock music or have to unlock all extra songs through challenges, e.g. "play x number of times on this stage"?

 

[BlazingFireOmega]

Would you rather have CDs back to unlock music or have to unlock all extra songs through challenges, e.g. "play x number of times on this stage"?

CDs, thought having both options wouldn't hurt.

Melee's air dodge or Sm4sh's air dodge?

 

[Scribe]

Assuming everything else about the system mechanics stays the same, Smash 4's air dodge.

Would you rather have all of the unrevealed newcomers be Fire Emblem characters or have them all be Kirby in different hats?

 

[Freduardo]

More kirbies! Kirby the Fighters X Smash!

April fools. Go with fire emblem.

Would you rather have Takamaru or Mike Jones from Star Tropics as a playable character?

 

[nirvanafan]

Takamaru

Would you rather have an N64 mode (like in PM) or a tag team mode

 

[Garteam]

Tag team mode

Would you rather BOTW Link revamp and replace Link's previous moveset or have him as a separate playable character alongside Classic Link and Toon Link?

 

[PeridotGX]

BOTW Replace

Would you rather have Ridley be a clone of Peach or Unique, but only usable in Smash Tour.

 

[YoshiandToad]

Clone, the idea of Ridley hiding behind a tiny Toad and using his butt is too damn good to miss out on

Would you rather have one unique Fire Emblem newcomer or three DK newcomers but they're all clones of Diddy?

 

[Garteam]

One unique Fire Emblem character

Would you rather have Ridley, but he's a clone of Charizard, or King K. Rool, but he's a clone of Bowser?

 

[PeridotGX]

Ridley as a Charizard clone. Seeing the reactions of the Ridley fans would be incredible.

Would you rather have Steve (Minecraft) or an Undertale Character in SSB?

 

[Garteam]

Steve easily, he has a lot more moveset potential and Minecraft is more iconic than Undertale

Would you rather have Ganondorf uncloned but the Inklings are clones of Mega Man, or the Inklings get a unique moveset but Ganondorf is still a clone?

 

[Carrill]

Inklings should have a unique moveset with Ganon still as a clone.

Do you want Mimikyu or Decidueye in the game as a playable character?

 

[Scribe]

Decidueye seems like he has more moveset potential so Imma go with him.

Would you rather have a bunch of new third-party characters but they're all from gritty, realistic franchises like Wolfenstein, Dark Souls, etc. or have Shovel Knight in Smash, but he's the only new third-party character.

 

[Freduardo]

Decidueye seems like he has more moveset potential so Imma go with him.

Would you rather have a bunch of new third-party characters but they're all from gritty, realistic franchises like Wolfenstein, Dark Souls, etc. or have Shovel Knight in Smash, but he's the only new third-party character.

I’m going to say more new characters. I liked Snake.

Would you rather have a character from shonen jump or American superhero comics (marvel or dc)?

 

[CaptainAmerica]

...well...*checks username*

That one's easy.

EAT VIBRANIUM SHIELD, PIKACHU!

...ahem...

Would you rather have an All-Star mode that's randomized (like Melee's), or one that's based on release dates (like Brawl/SSB4)?

 

[PierceWantsToSmash]

Release Dates, but going from newest to oldest.

Would you rather bring back Dedede's chain grabs or nerf Jigglypuff even more?

 

[Garteam]

Dedede's chain grab, I just can't hurt Jigglypuff any more, she's been through enough.

Would you rather add another Mega Man character or another Sonic character?

 

[RineYFD]

Another Sonic character.
Would you rather have Dark Pit and Gannondorf's movesets to be revamped so they aren't clones of Pit and Captain Falcon, but we lose two character slots in doing so or have two completely new characters instead?

 

[Llort A. Ton]

Revamped move sets for Dark Pit and Dorf.

Would you rather have a starting roster of ONLY the original 12 + Final Destination & Battlefield for starting levels, but there is the most expansive and entertaining single player content seen ever in a Smash Bros game for you to unlock all the other characters,

OR

Have ALL characters and stages unlocked from the get go, but the ONLY mode in the entire game is the 2 minute battle?

Assume both rosters have 75 characters and 60 stages.

 

[CaptainAmerica]

Everything unlockable. We need some single player modes in Smash badly, and the "Challenger Approaching" is fun.

Would you rather have the classic mode auto-downgrade the difficulty like in SSB4 when you lose, or not have any challenges involving "Beat classic at level 9 with character-you-suck-with"?

 

[Garteam]

Auto-downgrade, the "Beat classic level 9 with Marth without losing a life in under 9 minutes and play only with your feet" mission was the bane of me

Would rather have Lucina get her own moveset but Dark Pit gets cut or Dark Pit getting his own moveset but Lucina gets cut?

 

[SwagGuy99]

Dark Pit with his own moveset. Pichu as a playable character, or Decidueye as an assist trophy?

 

[Almand]

Pichu playable.

Odyssey Mario as a playable fighter, or Princess Daisy?

 

[RealLuigisWearPink]

Oddyssey Mario without a doubt...

Would you rather Gangplank Galleon be a stage or Minecart Madness be a stage?