The ‘Would you rather have in smash?’ game thread

[Freduardo]

Okay I guess I'll keep the ball rolling, I'm still enjoying this thread quite a bit.

Would you rather see them add Goldeneye James Bond (cut from Melee) or Tetra (cut from Brawl) as playable?

Haha. You’d think I’d know my own rules, but you’d be surprised. Thank you!

Toon Link, but still a clone.

would you rather have Ridley in accurate size, or Olimar in accurate size?

Ridley.

Would you rather have Ridley as a playable character, or dark Samus and Sylux both as playable characters with Weavil as an AT?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

the latter.

would you rather all the vocal songs sung by Goofy, or all the instrumental songs played on Kazoo?

 

[CursedKaiju]

Ridley, cause otherwise there really is no point to olimar

would you rather have banjo&kazooie,shantae and spyro or shovel knight, crash and rayman?

 

[Deleted member]

Ridley, cause otherwise there really is no point to olimar

would you rather have banjo&kazooie,shantae and spyro or shovel knight, crash and rayman?

I'll go with the former.
Would you rather have an even worse Jigglypuff or a much better Bayonetta?

 

[nirvanafan]

Worse jigglypuff

Would you rather have each franchise get a new stage or have every single past stage return.

 

[ObeseCity]

Each franchise gets a new stage.

Would you rather have Corrin replaced with Azura or Dark Pit replaced with Viridi?

 

[Sprite]

Viridi cause obviously Corrin has a better moveset than dark pit.


Would you rather have melee fox return or brawl meta knight return

 

[Fire Emblemier]

Melee Fox, mostly for the "TORYAHHH".

Would you rather have Ike look like his brawl self or Smash 4 self?

 

[RealLuigisWearPink]

Brawl design, actually. I'm not a huge fan of Buff Ike

Would you rather have Corrin cut but replaced with 5 new FE characters or keep the FE lineup as is?

 

[Freduardo]

Brawl design, actually. I'm not a huge fan of Buff Ike

Would you rather have Corrin cut but replaced with 5 new FE characters or keep the FE lineup as is?

Corrin replaced by 5 new. That’s 5 new!

Red Shells Return but green shells are removed or poke balls removed but every Pokémon who ever was in a pokeball is made an AT.

 

[DeiSakuChris]

Corrin replaced by 5 new. That’s 5 new!

Red Shells Return but green shells are removed or poke balls removed but every Pokémon who ever was in a pokeball is made an AT.

Red Shells return. That **** was so fun.

Would you rather have: A Subspace-Emissary style story mode returns with all Smash 5 characters playing a part in it, but at the cost of 5 less possible newcomers included in compared to Smash 4, with no possibility of DLC. (Sorry if I'm not very clear. That'd mean Smash 5 would have 16 newcomers).

 

[Mighty Moose]

Definitely Subspace. I'm not sure there's even 15 new characters i'd be super excited for!

Your favourite potential newcomer makes it in to the game and Bayonetta gets buffed, or they don't make it and she gets nerfed?

 

[RealLuigisWearPink]

I can ignore Bayo, small price to pay for K.Rool!

Would you rather Meta Knight go back to being Brawl levels of OP or be cut entirely?

 

[Applebutter61]

Has anyone asked this inevitable question yet? Would you rather see the return of Snake or Wolf?

 

[Applebutter61]

I can ignore Bayo, small price to pay for K.Rool!

Would you rather Meta Knight go back to being Brawl levels of OP or be cut entirely?

Cut. Plain and simple. Brawl Meta knight was busted.

 

[RineYFD]

Wolf. He has better chances due to Konami and Kojima. And since Sakurai is close friends with Kojima I can't see him coming back. Plus they don't deserve ANYTHING to be represented in Smash. Not even a single trophy with everything they've done to their own employees or treating their franchises that everyone loves like they're disposable and just make pachinko machines out of them. Screw Konami. (Sorry for that rant by the way. I just find them vile)
If you had to pick between a second representative for Namco would it be Lloyd from Tale of Symphonia or Klonoa from the Klonoa series?

 

[BlazingFireOmega]

If you had to pick between a second representative for Namco would it be Lloyd from Tale of Symphonia or Klonoa from the Klonoa series?

Klonoa, hands down.

Keep Cloud or replace him with Geno from Mario RPG?

 

[TheWill44]

Replace him with Geno.

Would you rather have a WarioWare (Brawl) moveset or Wario Land (PM kinda) moveset of Wario?

 

[CursedKaiju]

Replace him with Geno.

Would you rather have a WarioWare (Brawl) moveset or Wario Land (PM kinda) moveset of Wario?

WarioLand for sure

Would you rather add Krystal or Dixie Kong?

 

[Sprite]

DIxie Kong


Would you rather have Decidueye or Sceptile

 

[RineYFD]

Decidueye.
If you had to pick between Sora from Kingdom Hearts or Frog from Chron Trigger for a second Square Enix representative who would you pick?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Sora because the novelty of having a Disney character in Smash would be great

would you rather have amiibo used to unlock new characters, or just the original 12?

 

[Jeck]

Sora because the novelty of having a Disney character in Smash would be great

would you rather have amiibo used to unlock new characters, or just the original 12?

Wait, that's vague... I'm gonna go with the second one because I'm interpreting the first part as limited availability DLC which would be a nightmare with Nintendo's stocking track record.

Would you rather they delayed it until first half of 2019 to balance it and add a couple more characters or they released it right at E3 with GameCube controller and competitive scene support?

 

[Jubileus57]

Delayed. The more the merrier. Also it would give them more time to bring Subpsace 2

Would you rather see the 3DS stages return or the WiiU ones?

 

[FamicomDisk]

Delayed. The more the merrier. Also it would give them more time to bring Subpsace 2

Would you rather see the 3DS stages return or the WiiU ones?

Gonna say Wii U. The 3DS does have some fun stages that I want back, too, like Magicant and the Spirit Train, but the Wii U has more stages, and more stages that are fun and memorable to me.

Would you rather have a custom stage builder like Brawl's, or like Smash Wii U's?

 

[iCrash]

Ooh, tough. I liked the layout of Brawls a little more so I'm gonna go with that.

Would you rather have the rage mechanic back from Smash4, heavily nerfed/changed in some way, or removed entirely?

 

[Llort A. Ton]

Ooh, tough. I liked the layout of Brawls a little more so I'm gonna go with that.

Would you rather have the rage mechanic back from Smash4, heavily nerfed/changed in some way, or removed entirely?

I dont despise rage, but I wont lose sleep if its gone. Removed entirely.

If Snake returns, would you rather him keep his Brawl moveset or have his PM moveset/revemped moveset?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Brawl moveset

would you rather have Smash reworked as Fast Food Mascots Free-For-All or reworked as Sonic Smash Bros? no guest stars in either.

 

[Sprite]

Fast food mascots would be funnier

Would you rather have Subspace emissary come back or have a condensed version of it that comes with smash run?

 

[nirvanafan]

Subspace Emissary

Would you rather have Chrom added with Lucina & Robin getting removed or have Lucina & Robin return with Chrom remaining as part of Robin's final smash.

 

[RineYFD]

Subspace Emissary

Would you rather have Chrom added with Lucina & Robin getting removed or have Lucina & Robin return with Chrom remaining as part of Robin's final smash.

Robin and Lucina returning with Chrom as a part of Robin's final smash.
If who would you pick between Infernape or Emploleon for Smash as a Gen 4 Pokemon representative?

 

[Freduardo]

Robin and Lucina returning with Chrom as a part of Robin's final smash.
If who would you pick between Infernape or Emploleon for Smash as a Gen 4 Pokemon representative?

Infernape. It’s goku in Smash.

Would you rather rather have a Star Trek character or a Star Wars character in Smash?

 

[Jubileus57]

Empoleon. I loathe Infernape with a passion.

Would you rather have Wuhu Island or Pilotwings back in Smash Switch?

 

[Applebutter61]

Infernape. It’s goku in Smash.

Would you rather rather have a Star Trek character or a Star Wars character in Smash?

Star wars. Stars wars is more epic, it would fit better in smash.

 

[Freduardo]

Empoleon. I loathe Infernape with a passion.

Would you rather have Wuhu Island or Pilotwings back in Smash Switch?

Pilotwings

Would you rather an SSE that changed the gameplay to match the series the levels came from or one that stayed smash all the time like the original SSE?

 

[lady_sky skipper]

Pilotwings

Would you rather an SSE that changed the gameplay to match the series the levels came from or one that stayed smash all the time like the original SSE?

Honestly I would rather have a Pilotwings stage that has one of the islands from Pilotwings 64 along with the rest so all of the Pilotwings games would be represented.

 

[Freduardo]

Honestly I would rather have a Pilotwings stage that has one of the islands from Pilotwings 64 along with the rest so all of the Pilotwings games would be represented.

Keeping th game going:

Would you rather an SSE that changed the gameplay to match the series the levels came from or one that stayed smash all the time like the original SSE?

 

[Deleted member 396530]

Nothing
Could Ness Be 6 Feet?

 

[Hinata]

Keeping th game going:

Would you rather an SSE that changed the gameplay to match the series the levels came from or one that stayed smash all the time like the original SSE?

One that matched the series the levels came from. That sounds pretty damn fun.

Would you rather have a big roster that has a large number of 3rd and 4th party characters, or a small roster that's only 1st and 2nd party?

 

[RealLuigisWearPink]

Big roster as log as everyone works and there's a good variance

Would you rather King K. Rool and Ridley get in as a Ice Climbers-like duo with each other, or they get in individually but as Marth clones?