The ‘Would you rather have in smash?’ game thread

[Zangiefsthighs]

June

WYR have Pyro or chell as a valve rep

 

[Hollywoodrok12]

June

WYR have Pyro or chell as a valve rep

Chell easy. I really want Heavy, and seeing him get humiliated Spring Man style to my least favorite character from the same game is an absolute no (he doesn't have any funny lines due to his inability to talk and I find his concept unsettling. Don't hate him like I do Min Min, but I'd hate him in Smash). I can't deal with that again. Also Chell would be really cool.

WYR Lloyd or Heihachi get in as a 2nd Namco rep?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Heihachi

WYR have a newcomer selection consisting entirely of obscure characters nobody's ever heard of, or a newcomer selection consisting entirely of characters even your grandma could name?

 

[Freduardo]

Grandma could name. It’s going to be limited to Mario series characters because I think Super Mario Bros is the only game I could name her ever actually playing, I’m playing a lot of Mario 35 today, and I wouldn’t mind if the rest of the dlc was lakitu, Hammer Bros, Koopa Paratroopa, and Boo as those would probably be the only characters she’d have a chance at naming that aren’t already in the game. (Or maybe Pitfall Harry, Tails, Ms. Pac Man, Q Bert, and Digdug. All of which I’d also be fine with).

WYR Hammer Bros or Lakitu?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Lakitu.

WYR replace Zombie with a Piglin, or Enderman with a Skeleton?

 

[Perkilator]

Lakitu.

WYR replace Zombie with a Piglin, or Enderman with a Skeleton?

Endedman with a skeleton.

WYR have a House of the Dead Spirit Event or a Dead Rising Spirit Event?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

HoTD

If there were two Warios (one Ware and one Land), WYR one be called "Wario" and the other be called "Wario Land"/"Land Wario", or one be called "Wario" and the other be called "WarioWare"/"Ware Wario"?

 

[Perkilator]

HoTD

If there were two Warios (one Ware and one Land), WYR one be called "Wario" and the other be called "Wario Land"/"Land Wario", or one be called "Wario" and the other be called "WarioWare"/"Ware Wario"?

Ware Wario so I can make werewolf jokes.

If Vol. 2 had 10 fighters instead of 6, and two were revealed at once after Min Min, WYR they revealed Sora and Steve or Sakura Shinguji and Crash Bandicoot?

 

[Janx_uwu]

Sora and Steve.

WYR have a good Break the Targets mode in the style of Melee, or an improved Smash Run from 3DS? (with online play for each and whatnot)

 

[Perkilator]

Sora and Steve.

WYR have a good Break the Targets mode in the style of Melee, or an improved Smash Run from 3DS? (with online play for each and whatnot)

Improved Smash Run.

WYR have:

-Ho-Oh and Grima as bosses

or

-Queen Sectonia and Dark Emperor (Find Mii) as bosses

 

[Hollywoodrok12]

Improved Smash Run.

WYR have:

-Ho-Oh and Grima as bosses

or

-Queen Sectonia and Dark Emperor (Find Mii) as bosses

Sectiona + Dark Emperor. Modern Kirby, man

Going off of Modern Kirby WYR Waddle Dee Train Tracks or Gigavolt (in neither case do the hazards OHKO if you would get hit to the screen or crushed)

 

[Perkilator]

Sectiona + Dark Emperor. Modern Kirby, man

Going off of Modern Kirby WYR Waddle Dee Train Tracks or Gigavolt (in neither case do the hazards OHKO if you would get hit to the screen or crushed)

Gigavolt.

If you could add an FE newcomer in Ultimate without the ability to alter the FE side of the veterans (because of “Everyone is here”), WYR have Azura instead of Chrom or Claude instead of Byleth?

 

[Janx_uwu]

Gigavolt.

If you could add an FE newcomer in Ultimate without the ability to alter the FE side of the veterans (because of “Everyone is here”), WYR have Azura instead of Chrom or Claude instead of Byleth?

Claude instead of Byleth.

If Sega got one character in Fighter's Pass 2 WYR have a second Sonic rep, or a different Sega IP we haven't seen yet?

 

[Perkilator]

Claude instead of Byleth.

If Sega got one character in Fighter's Pass 2 WYR have a second Sonic rep, or a different Sega IP we haven't seen yet?

Different SEGA IP (preferably Sakura Shinguji).

WYR have Zacian as a newcomer or Scorbunny as a newcomer?

 

[Janx_uwu]

Different SEGA IP (preferably Sakura Shinguji).

WYR have Zacian as a newcomer or Scorbunny as a newcomer?

Zacian (kind of tired of fire types)

WYR have a stage based on Tetris or Dr. Mario?

 

[thecursedside]

Tetris

As a new Zelda rep WYR have Young Impa from Age of Calamity or Impa from Hyrule Warriors?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Young Impa

WYR add Impa (any) or Tingle as a newcomer?

 

[Janx_uwu]

Young Impa

WYR add Impa (any) or Tingle as a newcomer?

Impa (I want Tingle more, but I also want to avoid the drama coming from diehard Zelda fans)
WYR add Captain Toad or Blue Toad as a newcomer?

 

[thecursedside]

Blue Toad

It would complete the SMB2 quartet, and Blue Toad is best Toad.

WYR have Master Hand be (somehow) playable?

 

[Perkilator]

Blue Toad

It would complete the SMB2 quartet, and Blue Toad is best Toad.

WYR have Master Hand be (somehow) playable?

Or…? (Btw, Master Hand’s already technically playable near the end of WoL)

 

[thecursedside]

Or Tabuu my bad

 

[Perkilator]

Or Tabuu my bad

Tabuu.

If you could pick an obscure Nintendo character for the base game, WYR have had DeMille from Tomato Adventure or Ayumi Tachibana from Famicom Detective Club?

 

[ZagarTulip]

Ayumi Tachibana

WYR have a character in Smash that is based on your fave animal OR have a character that shares the same first name as you?

 

[Perkilator]

Ayumi Tachibana

WYR have a character in Smash that is based on your fave animal OR have a character that shares the same first name as you?

Pass.

WYR have Frank West or Jill Valentine?

 

[Janx_uwu]

Pass.

WYR have Frank West or Jill Valentine?

Frank West. Think he'd be more interesting from the game play side of things.

WYR have a Smash spinoff that's a traditional fighter or 3D arena fighter?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

3D Arena

Since a certain someone can't wait his turn: WYR have a character in Smash that is based on your fave animal OR have a character that shares the same first name as you?

 

[lady_sky skipper]

3D Arena

Since a certain someone can't wait his turn: WYR have a character in Smash that is based on your fave animal OR have a character that shares the same first name as you?

Sure! I gotta admit I kinda want Bubsy in Smash Ultimate because it would be funny to both play as him and beat him up.

WYR have a Smash Bros spin-off that is a platformer or an action rpg?

 

[Perkilator]

Sure! I gotta admit I kinda want Bubsy in Smash Ultimate because it would be funny to both play as him and beat him up.

WYR have a Smash Bros spin-off that is a platformer or an action rpg?

Action RPG.

Since a certain someone can't wait his turn

I'm sorry, but it seems you can't stand it when people pass on a question. Not every should feel obligated to give an answer.

Anyways, WYR have an Assist Trophy Spirit with a battle against , or a Poké Ball Spirit with a battle against ?

 

[Janx_uwu]

Assist trophy spirit battle.

Would you rather have Shadow or Metal Sonic as an echo fighter for Sonic?

 

[lady_sky skipper]

Assist trophy spirit battle.

Would you rather have Shadow or Metal Sonic as an echo fighter for Sonic?

I'd actually rather have Shadow as an echo fighter for Sonic.

WYRH an F-Zero spinoff that's a beat-em'-up or a 3D Mario style game?

 

[Perkilator]

I'd actually rather have Shadow as an echo fighter for Sonic.

WYRH an F-Zero spinoff that's a beat-em'-up or a 3D Mario style game?

Beat-em-up.

WYR have Bald Bull as a Fighter or an Assist Trophy?

 

[StrangeKitten]

Beat-em-up.

WYR have Bald Bull as a Fighter or an Assist Trophy?

Assist Trophy. There are other Punch Out characters I'd rather get, such as King Hippo

WYR get a Subspace Emissary 2, or a boss rush mode?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Action RPG.


I'm sorry, but it seems you can't stand it when people pass on a question. Not every should feel obligated to give an answer.

Anyways, WYR have an Assist Trophy Spirit with a battle against , or a Poké Ball Spirit with a battle against ?

Dude, the whole point of this thread is being obligated to give an answer. You know you can just save your question for later, right?

Anyway, Boss Rush.

WYR have Duck Hunt pushed back to 64; Olimar pushed back to Melee; K. Rool pushed back to Brawl; or Steve pushed back to 3DS/Wii U?

 

[Mamboo07]

K. Rool pushed back to Brawl

WYR have the Crabs from Fight Crab as a fighter or Chemical Plant from Sonic as a stage?

 

[ZagarTulip]

Crab from Fight Crab

WYR have Doc Louis from PunchOut as a Fighter OR an Updated Pokefloats stage?

 

[Janx_uwu]

Crab from Fight Crab

WYR have Doc Louis from PunchOut as a Fighter OR an Updated Pokefloats stage?

Doc as a fighter.

WYR have a Portal stage or a Cuphead stage as DLC?

 

[Perkilator]

Doc as a fighter.

WYR have a Portal stage or a Cuphead stage as DLC?

Cuphead stage.

WYR PopCap have been bought by Nintendo, or not at all?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Not at all. Nintendo is barely better than EA.

WYR add Galaxy 2; 3D Land; DK64; and Wario World to 3D All-Stars, or make it a proper remake of just the 3 games? (either way the limited release stuff doesn't happen)

 

[Perkilator]

Not at all. Nintendo is barely better than EA.

WYR add Galaxy 2; 3D Land; DK64; and Wario World to 3D All-Stars, or make it a proper remake of just the 3 games? (either way the limited release stuff doesn't happen)

Add Galaxy 2 to keep it Mario themed.

WYR have Smash Ultimate Deluxe Edition or a 3rd Fighter’s Pass (either case adds 4 more characters)?

 

[Janx_uwu]

Add Galaxy 2 to keep it Mario themed.

WYR have Smash Ultimate Deluxe Edition or a 3rd Fighter’s Pass (either case adds 4 more characters)?

3rd Fighter's Pass. I don't want characters put behind a $60 paywall.

WYRH a Sonic Gems Collection Remastered (featuring the original Gems games along with Knuckles Chaotix, SegaSonic The Hedgehog, Spinball, all of the education games like Schoolhouse, and 3D Blast) or a Sonic Handheld Collection (Drift 1&2, Triple Trouble, Tails games, Advance Games, and Battle)?