The loaded question in the beginning that stood out to me. You were posting well until this point, with a good amount of posts. After that you mention mafia would lurk (which can go either way), just the way of saying: "Hey guys, I'm not scum because scum would do this!" The fact that you answered your own question speaks for itself: you weren't even looking for anybody else's opinion, you just wanted to let yourself be extra known as "Mr Not-scum".
First off, I would like to comment on me answering my own question. Me answering my own question just shows my opinion to everyone, incase they would want to ask me. To say that because i answered my own questoin means that I don't want anyone else's opinion, doesn't make sense. ME answering, and me listening to someone else's answer aren't related at all. Also, I've had this discussion with Junglefever about the loaded question, you explaining it again doesn't change much. In fact, i would recommend you re-read that part where Junglefever calls me out on it. If it's not there I guess my memory is juat bad. Fact is i explained that I was asking to question to get the ball rolling, but it really didn't help out as much as I expected, So i thought more about my questions from then on.
I always want others opinions by the way.
You stopped because it was obviously suspicious and you didn't want to get lynched over it. So, your question wasn't all that important when you saw it backfired on you.
It wasn't an obvious suspicion. I would not have noticed it until it was called out. One loaded question isn't enough to get lynched over unless it's something extremely severe.
Why are you looking to get people prodded (and afterwards modkilled)? Easy pickings for scum?
I look to get people prodded in order to ensure activity. I asked for mod-kill on players yesterday as well. Now look at the conversation we're having. :|
Granted, we lost a cop for it
Hey guys, I want to skip information and just get straight to the killing.
Me saying i'd rather not take a week to lynch one person is different than saying "i want to ignore all the information we currently have and lynch someone randomly". Remember I branched into forum mafia from epic mafia, I tend to take things very quickly. Something i'm not used to quite yet.
You were looking to get Spire prodded. Then you mention it's unfortunate that Ndayday got prodded. Looking to be "goodie town", typical mafia tactic.
I can see where you would get that idea. This is a good point actually. +1
. (by the way, i come back to this later in the response)
What I also noticed was the little convo between you and Frown afterwards - where Frown mentioned "why it would be bad". I honestly can't believe I missed that slip-up, but now it seems to me like mafia communicating with each other.
Mafia communicating to each other is one player explaining why something is wrong to another player? I see, doesn't that mean when you talked to Frown, explaining how town killing matt was implied, would also be mafia talking to each other? It's a small conversation granted, but putting me in that category would also put you in that category.
Please answer this though.
From how we seen Frown play in D1, would you say he's more likely to buddy his scum buddies, or press against his scumbuddies.
I'll mention it again: "Hurts mafia". This isn't good word choice and in my opinion a slip-up.
I've already explained this, looking at both sides of the town isn't something that's scummy, especially over something like mod-killing that's done by an outside force.
"Guys, don't listen to what Frown says to me because he's my scumbuddy" is what I read.
That's what you read, but is it what is being said? He's admitted bias towards me, and bias towards junglefever as well (saying he's the best town we have). Does that mean Junglefever would also be scummy for this?
This post was edited. I don't know the rules about editing but honestly - I think you're scum and I'd be happy to see you get prodded over it.
To see me getting prodded, or see me getting killed? I do believe that i deserve infractions for those edits. However I promise you (in a game of mafia, lawl, how important is that) that those edits were very trivial grammatical errors. I've stopped doing this and edit by way of post (EBWOP)
I can see where you would find me being scummy. I won't lie, after reading your re-read, I had some odd changes in gameplay from day 1, to day 2, to day 3.
However, where does it say that I'm not sad about getting spire prodded? Where does it say that I am? I'd rather not have town get prodded at all, it generally screws up the flow of gameplay, you can agree that you can't get good reads on players when players will not discuss anything towards anyone. Also going away for a long period of time in a private game is just as much of a problem, we don't have replacements that we can fill in, only mod-kills are possible right now. How is this not something to be sad about from both perspectives. As much as I don't like it, I will want it to happen if it brings activity into the thread. I've been ranting about inactivity for quite some time.
