Yeah, I'll be honest when the content of Brawl is pretty much all I like about it. The gameplay wasn't entirely that great(it has its points, like some cool new techniques), only the SSE felt like it wasn't half-done or lazily thrown together(like Classic, All-Star, and the Target Tests were). Music I hold as being completely decent, but that's because of too many damn remixes of Brawl's main theme... which was kind of only okay.(the remixes felt mediocre, but the actual main theme sounded good, with the vocals, but without...) A lot of the Trophies had some fairly stupid requirements(the biggest being you had to get them yourself with the Trophy Stand...), and getting them was already a pain since they removed the Lottery(Coin Launcher is nice, but only really useful for getting more Stickers, which are super easy to find anyway) and the Grab the Trophy mini-game. I mean, I can deal without the Lottery, sure, but the other one gone as well? Ugh, horrid.
The biggest thing I like about Brawl was pretty much the roster itself.(not necessarily how they play, but they were all very good choices. I would've loved to have all the planned ones in, even if that includes Toon Sheik, although again, while that was the original plan, he probably would've made it Tetra in the end, which would've been better, but a Toon Sheik pretty much has a design, so she's actually possible now, if he wants a Toon Zelda in, anyway). I would've liked a third third party, though. The forbidden 7 and one more third party, sure, why not? Hard to say who. Pac-Man would've been neat, and MegaMan would've been unlikely due to some turmoil between Nintendo and Capcom at the time. Maybe Geno might've worked.(and if he did get in, he could've came back for For and we could've maybe had a second Square-Enix character. But now, even if we were to get a SE character, I'd want somebody other than Geno just to rep a Non-Mario series. But if we can get both, then hell yes!)