I'm still not completely convinced that this new leak is fake, I'm seeing a lot of people trying to prove it's false but nothing definitive so far.
I'm getting ESRB leak flashbacks, when people just WANTED Shulk to be fake.
I mean, I'd have no objections to the characters shown. I'm a huge
Bravely Default fan (as are most of us here, I'd wager, since we like handheld turn based RPGs). Heck, even if it was a
Fatal Frame character, that would be pretty hype, that's another series I enjoy.
If there's a "I hope it's not real", that would refer to how bad it looks. I mean, Isaac is the best, but his colors are way off, even accounting for color correction. Agnès's face is massively distorted (and no, Chrom's is nowhere NEAR as bad), with basic perspective and biology thrown out. Ken's render doesn't look like a render. The Chorus Kids don't even show up on a color background like every other character (and, seriously, how hard would that have been to do?).
Then there's the other things, like the inconsistency of the quality, proportions, styles, etcetera. It's copying this picture:
Note the difference? Complete images, names, consistent art styles, consistent proportions, dimensions, lighting, quality, etcetera.
I mean, heck, I've loathed the Chorus Kids since Gematsu, and yet I'd gladly welcome them onboard if it meant we would get Isaac and Agnès. That would be a hype as heck roster. It is not that I don't want these characters.
This just screams fake. And I'm worried about Isaac fans getting their hopes up for a really rather poorly done image compilation. The ESRB leak was leaking official images. The quality on most of these are way too low for that. Why are they so cut off? So much so that we can't even identify them all positively?
This would be a great roster. I'd love it to be real. I just don't think it is, and I think that the opposite of what you suggested is true. People are believing it because they want it to be real. This doesn't have nearly the effort of Rayman or even Springman + Decidueye.